Worthy.com Review

When it comes to parting with your valuable diamond jewelry, finding the right avenue can be a daunting task. Traditionally, you had two options: selling directly to consumers on platforms like eBay or dealing with local retailers or pawn shops. However, both of these routes have their limitations and challenges. In this review, we take a closer look at Worthy.com, an innovative player in the diamond resale market, offering a unique approach to selling your diamonds.

Looking to Buy Your Perfect Diamond? Now that you understand the differences between lab-grown and natural diamonds, why not start shopping? Whiteflash offer fantastic high-quality options for both lab and natural diamonds, along with James Allen, and Continental.

Worthy.com has carved a niche for itself with its hybrid business model that aims to simplify the process of selling diamonds. Unlike the conventional methods, Worthy.com takes a different route by auctioning your diamond ring to a network of diamond dealers, wholesalers, and retailers. This approach is designed to secure the highest bid for your precious gem, eliminating the need for you to approach potential buyers individually.

But does Worthy.com truly deliver on its promise of maximizing the value of your diamond? In this article, we delve into the intricacies of Worthy’s business model to help you make an informed decision when considering where to sell your diamond. We’ll weigh the pros and cons, ensuring you have all the information you need to navigate the world of diamond sales effectively.

Gain the knowledge of diamonds and jewelry you need to make an educated decision. Check out PriceScope's comprehensive diamond education section. Learn about the 4Cs and more. Educate yourself and make informed choices with PriceScope. 

The Fundamental Business Model of Worthy.com

Worthy Review – Auction Diamonds, Jewelry, and Luxury Watches Online

Worthy.com has introduced a unique approach to the sale of diamond jewelry, primarily engagement rings and valuable pieces. At the core of their business model is the concept of auctioning these items to a wide network of potential buyers, including diamond dealers, wholesalers, and retailers. While this approach may sound promising, it’s essential to delve into the fundamentals to gain a comprehensive understanding of how Worthy.com operates and whether it aligns with your selling goals.

Ready to embark on your diamond-buying journey? The elite brands offered by our vetted vendors like Whiteflash A CUT ABOVE®Astor by Blue Nile™, and JamesAllen.com True Hearts are collections of diamonds with superior cut quality.

Understanding How Worthy.com Works

Worthy.com offers a unique platform for selling diamond jewelry, and understanding how it works is essential for anyone considering using this service. Here’s a breakdown of the key steps involved in the Worthy.com process:

  1. Initial Information Submission

  • To begin the process, you visit the Worthy.com website.
  • You provide basic information about your jewelry, including details such as the type of ring, diamond characteristics, and other relevant information.
  1. Estimated Range of Bids

  • After submitting the initial information, Worthy.com provides you with an estimated range of bids you might receive for your jewelry. This estimate gives you a sense of the potential value of your item.
  1. Decision to Proceed

  • If you decide to move forward with selling your jewelry on Worthy.com, the platform facilitates the next steps.
  • Worthy.com sends you a shipping label, making it convenient for you to send your jewelry to their facility.
  1. Clear and Easy-to-Use Forms

  • Worthy.com’s forms are designed to be clear and user-friendly.
  • They offer filters and straightforward fields where you can input relevant information about your jewelry.
  • The platform has separate sections for diamond engagement rings and other types of jewelry to streamline the process.
  1. Detailed Questions for Engagement Rings

  • If you are looking to sell a diamond engagement ring, Worthy.com typically asks detailed questions about the ring’s size, color, clarity, and source.
  • These questions help assess the quality and characteristics of the diamond, which can impact its market value.
  1. Fee Schedule

  • Worthy.com charges fees for its services, and it’s essential to be aware of these costs.
  • The fee schedule can be found in the “how it works” section of the platform.
  • Fees typically range from 14% to 22% of the final sale price, depending on the specifics of your transaction.

Here is an example of Worthy’s commission schedule:

What percentage does Worthy get?
  1. Fee Transparency

  • It’s worth noting that in some cases, users have reported that Worthy.com does not always proactively disclose their fees.
  • While they may provide estimates of the auction sale price, the actual amount you will receive is not always clearly stated.
  • It’s advisable to ask specifically about the fees to ensure you have a complete understanding of the financial aspect of the transaction.
  1. Duration of the Process

  • The duration of the entire process can vary based on the type of jewelry you are selling and other factors.
  • It’s important to note that discussions and negotiations with potential buyers may take time.
  • As an example, the author of this review mentioned that the process took two and a half weeks, excluding the pre-sale discussions.

Looking for the ideal diamond? Use PriceScope's advanced diamond search to explore a curated selection of the world's most exquisite stones. Begin your diamond search

Pros of Using Worthy.com

  • Worthy.com offers an excellent website with a user-friendly interface.
  • The auction-style approach allows you to reach multiple potential buyers simultaneously, potentially increasing your chances of obtaining competitive offers.

Cons of Using Worthy.com

  • Some users have reported that the process can be long and convoluted.
  • Worthy.com’s fees, which can range from 14% to 22%, may impact the final amount you receive for your jewelry.

Worthy.com presents an innovative way to sell diamond jewelry, with its auction-based platform and user-friendly interface. However, it’s crucial to be aware of the fee structure and potential complexities in the process. Understanding these aspects will help you make an informed decision when considering Worthy.com as a platform for selling your valuable jewelry.

Explore our vast jewelry search to find that perfect piece. Whether it's an engagement ring or a timeless necklace, we have it all. 

The Significance of Certification and Appraisal with Worthy.com

When it comes to selling diamond jewelry, having accurate certification and appraisal information is crucial. Worthy.com recognizes the importance of this aspect and offers a valuable service that sets it apart from other selling platforms – the certification and appraisal of your jewelry. Here’s a closer look at why this service is essential and how it works with Worthy.com:

  1. Importance of Certification

  • Certification is a critical aspect of diamond jewelry transactions. It provides a standardized and reputable assessment of a diamond’s quality and characteristics.
  • Among the most trusted certifications are those issued by renowned gemological laboratories like the Gemological Institute of America (GIA) and the International Gemological Institute (IGI). These organizations evaluate diamonds based on the “Four Cs“: carat weight, cut, color, and clarity.
  • Having a certified diamond adds credibility and transparency to the transaction, as both the buyer and seller can rely on an objective assessment of the diamond’s attributes.
An example of a GIA Diamond Dossier (certificate)

An example of a GIA Diamond Dossier (certificate).

IGI certification example

IGI Certification Example

  1. Worthy.com’s Commitment to Certification

  •  Worthy.com places a strong emphasis on ensuring that every ring auctioned on their platform is accompanied by a GIA or IGI certificate.
  • This commitment to certification means that when you sell your diamond jewelry through Worthy.com, you can expect that potential buyers will have access to reliable information about the quality of your item.
  1. Certification for Rings Without Existing Documentation

  • If your diamond ring does not have a GIA or IGI certificate at the time of listing, Worthy.com offers a valuable service.
  • The platform will send your ring to a reputable gemological lab for certification at no cost to you.
  • While the specific criteria for selecting items for certification are not disclosed, it’s reasonable to assume that Worthy.com will prioritize items with the potential for higher market value.
  1. Benefits of Independent Certification

  • Worthy.com’s certification process is valuable because it provides an independent and objective evaluation of your diamond.
  • Local appraisals, while useful for insurance purposes, may not always provide the level of detail and standardization that buyers and sellers require in the resale market.
  • By obtaining a GIA or IGI certificate through Worthy.com, you ensure that your diamond’s quality is assessed by a globally recognized authority in the field.
  1. Building Trust and Transparency

  • The presence of a reputable certificate from GIA or IGI enhances trust and transparency in the selling process.
  • Buyers are more likely to feel confident in their purchase when they have access to a trusted certification, which can lead to more competitive bids and a higher selling price for the seller.

The certification and appraisal services provided by Worthy.com are significant advantages for individuals looking to sell their diamond jewelry. By ensuring that each item is accompanied by a GIA or IGI certificate, Worthy.com enhances the credibility of the transaction and empowers both buyers and sellers with reliable information about the diamond’s quality. This commitment to certification contributes to a transparent and trustworthy selling experience, ultimately benefiting those using the platform to sell their valuable jewelry.

Explore the world's largest diamond and jewelry community. Connect with enthusiasts, experts, and novices alike. Share, learn, and engage in the vibrant online community at PriceScope.

Worthy vs. Abe Mor: Making the Right Choice

When it comes to selling your diamond jewelry, the choice between Worthy and Abe Mor ultimately depends on your priorities and preferences. Both platforms offer unique approaches to diamond resale. Worthy.com distinguishes itself with its auction-based model, while Abe Mor is known for its reputation as a trusted diamond buyer.

Worthy.com’s auction format allows sellers to reach multiple potential buyers simultaneously, potentially maximizing the selling price. However, it’s important to consider the platform’s fees, which can impact the final payout.

On the other hand, Abe Mor has gained a positive reputation among users for its professionalism and straightforward approach. Many have reported excellent experiences and competitive offers when working with Abe Mor.

Ultimately, the “better” choice depends on your specific goals. If you prioritize convenience and exposure to a broad range of buyers, Worthy.com might be appealing. However, if you value a reliable and reputable buyer with a track record of customer satisfaction, Abe Mor may be the preferred option. It’s advisable to thoroughly research and compare both platforms, read user reviews, and consider your individual circumstances before making a decision on where to sell your diamond jewelry.

If you're looking for more insights and reviews on jewelers, we recommend checking out PriceScope's comprehensive jeweler reviews. Get firsthand experiences and feedback from the jewelry community to help you make informed decisions about buying or selling diamond and gold jewelry.


In conclusion, Worthy.com offers a unique and innovative approach to selling diamond and gold jewelry through its auction-based platform. While their model aims to provide convenience and exposure to multiple potential buyers, it’s essential to consider the bottom line: the financial outcome for sellers.

One of the primary concerns with using Worthy.com is the fee structure, which can range from 14% to 22%. This fee can significantly impact the final amount you receive for your precious jewelry. Additionally, the process, while straightforward, may be perceived as lengthy and convoluted by some users.

Based on extensive testing and user experiences, it’s important to note that Worthy.com may not always offer the best financial outcome for sellers. In some cases, users have reported receiving substantially higher offers from alternative platforms like Abe Mor, with differences of up to 50% for the same piece of jewelry.

Therefore, the decision of whether to use Worthy.com should be made with careful consideration of your specific goals and priorities. While the platform’s certification and appraisal services, along with its user-friendly interface, are commendable, the impact of fees on your final payout cannot be overlooked.

In the end, sellers seeking maximum value for their diamond or gold jewelry may find it beneficial to explore alternative options and conduct thorough research to ensure their jewelry is sold in a way that aligns with their financial expectations and goals.

Scroll to Top