Exploring the Best Jewelry Stores in Atlanta, Georgia

This article provides a comprehensive look at buying diamonds in Atlanta, Georgia. It covers the pros and cons of buying diamonds online versus buying from a store, as well as diamond buying tips and the best places to buy an engagement ring in Atlanta and online.

Buying Diamonds Online vs. Buying From a Store

When it comes to acquiring loose diamonds, you’re dealing with a major decision: online or in-store. Each has their own set of pros and cons, but if you take the time to assess the two options, it’s clear that buying diamonds online is usually the better choice. 

Online diamond retailers are subject to rigorous scrutiny to ensure they’re providing the best quality diamonds and outstanding customer service. This means they must meet exacting standards if they wish to stay in business. On the contrary, physical jewelry stores may not be bound to the same requirements, especially ones in prime locations. 

When it comes to price, online diamond retailers often offer significantly lower costs than jewelry stores. This is because you don’t have to pay for overhead costs such as retail space, staff and advertising, which all increase the cost of jewelry in physical stores. Web-based diamond sellers can keep expenses low and pass on the savings to the buyer. 

In the end, when it comes to buying diamonds, online vendors are the way to go. Quality and cost are major considerations when making a purchase, and online diamond retailers come out on top when it comes to both. With online reviews, they have to live and die by their customer service and diamond quality.

Want to buy online? Our high-caliber list of reliable vendors such as Whiteflash and James Allen are seasoned professionals when it comes to listening and assisting you in finding the ideal combination of the 4Cs that fits your budget. Reach out to us and get expert help today.

Diamond Buying Tips

  1. Establish a budget and stick to it. It’s important to set a realistic budget and determine how much you can afford to spend. Learn more about diamond prices here.
  2. Learn about the 4Cs of diamond quality. The 4Cs (color, clarity, cut, and carat) are the main factors that determine the value of a diamond. Familiarizing yourself with these characteristics will help you decide which combination of 4Cs is the best for you.
  3. Make sure your diamond is certified by an independent laboratory such as the Gemological Institute of America (GIA), AGS or IGI. A certification from a trusted source can help verify the quality and value of the diamond you’re considering.
  4. Compare prices from different vendors by using our diamond search.
  5. Read reviews and ask for recommendations. The most popular reviews on PriceScope are Whiteflash, James Allen, and Blue Nile.
  6. Don’t be afraid to ask questions. If you have any questions about the diamond you’re considering, don’t hesitate to get in touch.

The Best Places to Buy an Engagement Ring in Atlanta

1. Solomon Brothers Fine Jewelry

Solomon Brothers Fine Jewelry

Location: 3340 Peachtree Rd NE #1700, Atlanta, GA 30326, United States

Founded: 1980

Selection: The selection of jewelry at Solomon Brothers is truly impressive. They have something for everyone – from classic gold bands to modern statement pieces. Whether you’re looking for something for yourself or for a special someone, you’ll find exactly what you need here. They also offer custom design services if you can’t find exactly what you’re looking for. 

Customer Service: The customer service team at Solomon Brothers is second-to-none. From the moment I walked in the door I was treated with kindness and respect. Every question I had was answered quickly and accurately, and they went out of their way to make sure I found exactly what I was looking for. 

Experience: My experience at the store was nothing short of exceptional. The atmosphere was inviting and comfortable, making it easy to browse without feeling pressured or rushed. Everything on display was clearly labeled and organized neatly, so it was easy to find exactly what I needed without having to search through endless options like some stores do.

Conclusion: Overall, my experience at Solomon Brothers Jewelers Atlanta Store was outstanding in every way possible. Their selection of jewelry is vast and impressive, their customer service team is friendly and knowledgeable, and their store atmosphere makes it easy to browse without feeling overwhelmed or pressured into making a purchase that isn’t quite right for you. If you’re looking for high-quality jewelry with unbeatable service in the Atlanta area then be sure to give them a try – you won’t be disappointed!


2. Shane Co.

Shane Co Store

Location: 10885 Haynes Bridge Road Alpharetta, GA 30022

Founded: 1971

The Quality Has Dropped: In its heyday, Shane Co was known for its quality diamonds. However, over the years the quality of their diamonds has dropped significantly. While their stones may still be “certified,” customers report that the quality is far below what it used to be and that many of them are flawed or dull. As such, customers are better off looking elsewhere for their diamond needs if they want something truly special and sparkling. 

High Prices: Shane Co diamonds may not be as high-quality as they used to be, but that hasn’t stopped them from charging top dollar – often far more than other stores or online retailers – for their stones. This means that customers are essentially paying more money just to get access to lower-quality diamonds; not exactly a great deal! Moreover, if you’re willing to shop around you can easily find better deals elsewhere – even if it means going outside your comfort zone and buying online instead of in-store.

Poor Customer Service: Finally, many customers report that Shane Co’s customer service is lacking at best. From salespeople who lack knowledge about the products to long wait times when trying to return items or make adjustments – customers have had enough of the shoddy service offered by this outdated jeweler. As such, it’s best to avoid them altogether if you don’t want your diamond shopping experience marred by poor customer service and even poorer quality gems. 

Conclusion: All in all, it’s clear that Shane Co is no longer a viable option when it comes to diamond shopping in Georgia or anywhere else in the US or abroad for that matter! Their diamonds are overpriced compared to what you can find elsewhere and they’ve outlived their appeal due to poor quality gems and subpar customer service experiences. It’s definitely time for this outdated jeweler to step aside and make room for newer stores with better prices and higher-quality diamonds!

Learn more about Shane Co from our review here.


3. Masina Diamonds

Masina Diamonds

Location: 75 John Portman Blvd NW Suite 6N-106, Atlanta, GA 30303, United States

Founded: 1984

The first thing you’ll notice when you walk into Masina Diamonds is the stunning array of diamond jewelry on display. From engagement rings and wedding bands to necklaces and earrings, there’s something for everyone at this store. But it’s not just the quantity of jewelry that sets Masina apart; it’s the quality. All of the diamonds at Masina are ethically sourced and meticulously graded by independent gemologists. So, whether you’re shopping for a pair of diamond stud earrings or a diamond tennis bracelet, you can rest assured that you’re getting a piece of jewelry that is both beautiful and responsibly sourced. 

In addition to offering high-quality diamonds, Masina Diamonds also provides customers with expert guidance throughout the purchasing process. The friendly and knowledgeable staff will take the time to answer all of your questions and help you find the perfect piece of jewelry to suit your needs. Whether you’re buying a diamond ring for an engagement or a special gift for a loved one, the team at Masina will make sure you find exactly what you’re looking for. 

Finally, what really sets Masina Diamonds apart from other jewelers is their commitment to outstanding customer service. From start to finish, the team at Masina will go above and beyond to ensure that your experience is nothing short of exceptional. They offer complimentary cleanings and inspections for all pieces purchased from their store, as well as flexible financing options to make your purchase more affordable. Plus, they offer a lifetime warranty on all engagement and wedding rings, so you can rest assured that your investment is protected. 

Conclusion: If you’re in the market for quality diamond jewelry, then Masina Diamonds should be your go-to store. With an impressive selection of ethically sourced diamonds, expert guidance throughout the purchasing process, and outstanding customer service, Masina offers everything you could possibly want in a jeweler – and more. So next time you’re searching for that perfect piece of diamond jewelry, make sure to pay a visit to Masina Diamonds in Atlanta – you won’t be disappointed!


4. Forever Diamonds

Forever Diamonds Store

Location: 3393 Peachtree Rd NE Suite #2044, Atlanta, GA 30326, United States

Founded: 1981

My Experience Shopping at Forever Diamonds: Upon entering the store, I was immediately greeted by a salesperson who was friendly and knowledgeable about their products. The store had a wide selection of rings and other pieces of jewelry featuring diamonds. After browsing for a few minutes, I found exactly what I was looking for – a beautiful engagement ring with a stunning center diamond. The salesperson was very helpful throughout the process and answered all my questions about the diamond’s quality and origins. They even offered to clean and polish any jewelry purchased from their store free of charge! 

Why You Should Shop at Forever Diamonds: Forever Diamonds has been serving customers since 1984 and is committed to offering only the best quality diamonds available. All purchases come with a certificate of authenticity that guarantees that each diamond is ethically sourced and meets industry standards for quality. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable, which makes shopping here a pleasant experience. Plus, they offer free cleaning services so you can keep your jewelry looking like new! With all these factors taken into consideration, it’s easy to see why this is one of the best places to buy diamonds in Atlanta. 

Conclusion: For anyone shopping for high-quality diamonds in Atlanta, Georgia, there’s no better place than Forever Diamonds. From their commitment to ethical sourcing practices to their excellent customer service, this shop offers everything you need when searching for that special piece of jewelry or gift for someone special. Whether you’re looking for an engagement ring or just something sparkly for yourself—you can be sure you’ll find it here! So if you’re ever near Atlanta—definitely check out Forever Diamonds! You won’t regret it!


5. Highland Diamond

Highland Diamond Logo

Location: 1393 North Highland Avenue Northeast #2, Atlanta, GA 30306, United States

Founded: 2017

Highland Diamonds has a wide selection of items that range from classic pieces to unique custom designs. The staff was knowledgeable and friendly, helping me navigate the selection without being pushy or overwhelming. They also have an excellent repair service which I used when I needed a piece of jewelry resized – the repair was done quickly and accurately, ensuring that my item looked as good as new. 

The real highlight of my experience was the selection of diamonds available. These were all high-quality stones and they were priced fairly compared to other stores in the area. The staff took their time to explain each stone’s individual characteristics so that I could make an informed decision about what type of diamond I wanted to purchase. Additionally, they offered some excellent financing options which made it easy for me to purchase the diamond within my budget. 

In addition to offering quality diamonds and jewelry, Highland Diamonds is also dedicated to giving back to the local community. They regularly host fundraisers and donate money to various charities in order to help those less fortunate than themselves. This commitment speaks volumes about their commitment to doing good for others as well as their dedication to customer service excellence. 

Conclusion: All in all, my experience with Highland Diamond was positive from start to finish. Their knowledgeable staff provided excellent customer service while helping me find exactly what I was looking for at a price that fit my budget. Moreover, their charitable work proves that they are more than just another jewelry store – they are committed to making a difference in their community through philanthropy and by providing customers with quality products at fair prices. If you’re looking for a reliable jeweler in Atlanta who offers quality products at affordable prices, then Highland Diamonds should be your go-to choice!


Best Places for Buying a Diamond Online

1. Whiteflash

Whiteflash A Cut Above Hearts and Arrows diamonds

Whiteflash is a jewelry retailer that specializes in loose diamonds (lab grown and natural), designer engagement rings, wedding rings and jewelry. The company has been in business for over two decades and is highly regarded for its quality and customer service. Customers can choose from an extensive selection of GIA, AGS & IGI certified diamonds, designer jewelry, and custom engagement rings. They are world renowned for their A CUT ABOVE® super ideal hearts and arrows diamond brand and their first class customer service.

Learn more about Whiteflash from our review here.

2. Brilliant Earth

Brilliant Earth Homepage

Brilliant Earth has made a commitment to provide its customers with jewelry that has been ethically sourced, showcased by their teal-green leaf logo and teakwood ring boxes. This focus on combining elegance and social responsibility is quickly becoming a hallmark of their brand, as millennials become increasingly aware of the importance of ethical and sustainable practices. Through their mission of bringing transparency to an industry often beset with unethical and questionable practices, Brilliant Earth hopes to make a positive impact in the jewelry world.

Learn more about Brilliant Earth from our review here

3. James Allen

James Allen ring box

If you’re looking for a reliable, affordable way to purchase loose diamonds, engagement rings, finished jewelry, and gifts, JamesAllen.com is a good place to look. They offer the most competitive prices on the market, as well as the latest high-resolution images, video, and interactive meetings to make sure you are getting the best value for your money. And, with their innovative technologies, JamesAllen.com has become a leader in the industry, offering a wide selection of both classic and modern options to fit any budget. Plus, their non-commissioned customer service team and guarantees provide you with a risk-free buying experience.

Learn more about James Allen from our review here.

Scroll to Top