Blue Nile vs. Brilliant Earth

In the realm of online jewelry shopping, two prominent names often come to the forefront: Blue Nile and Brilliant Earth. These reputable companies have garnered widespread recognition for their commitment to offering high-quality diamonds and fine jewelry to customers worldwide. While both cater to those seeking exquisite engagement rings and other adornments, they diverge in their approaches to sourcing, pricing, and ethical standards. Understanding the distinctions between Blue Nile and Brilliant Earth is crucial for making an informed decision when embarking on the journey to purchase the perfect piece of jewelry.

Blue Nile

Blue Nile stands as one of the foremost online jewelers globally, renowned for its extensive range of diamonds offered at competitive prices. Established in 1999, it has become a prime destination for couples seeking engagement rings online. Blue Nile meticulously sources its diamonds from reputable suppliers, allowing customers the option to customize their rings, even designing them from scratch.

Selection and Quality

With over 150,000 diamonds in its inventory, Blue Nile offers an unparalleled selection. Their diamonds come with detailed certifications on the 4Cs (cut, color, clarity, and carat weight), ensuring transparency and quality assurance. Additionally, Blue Nile provides a wide variety of ring settings in various metals, including platinum and gold.

Astor Diamonds by Blue Nile

Image Source: Infernoar

Check out the Astor Diamond Collection Reviews

Sparkle with confidence! Explore a world of brilliance and transparency with PriceScope's trusted diamond vendors. From Whiteflash to Adiamor and James Allen, discover your perfect gemstone backed by high-resolution imagery, videos, and certificates. Shop smart, shine brighter!

Pricing and Value

Known for its competitive pricing, Blue Nile often offers lower rates compared to traditional brick-and-mortar stores. Moreover, they have a price match guarantee, ensuring customers get the best value for their money. Blue Nile also facilitates a diamond upgrade program, allowing for seamless transitions to larger stones.

Zac wedding band from BN

Customer Service and Returns

Blue Nile prides itself on excellent customer service, offering 24/7 support via phone, email, and chat. Their generous 30-day return policy grants customers peace of mind, with free returns and resizing options available.

Ethics and Sustainability

Committed to ethical practices, Blue Nile exclusively sources conflict-free diamonds adhering to the Kimberley Process. They also provide lab-created diamonds as a sustainable alternative, reflecting their dedication to environmental responsibility.

Brilliant Earth

Founded in 2005, Brilliant Earth emerges as a newer yet formidable player in the online jewelry sphere, distinguishing itself through a focus on ethically sourced diamonds and gemstones. Their offerings include engagement rings, wedding bands, and jewelry crafted from conflict-free diamonds and recycled precious metals, appealing to environmentally conscious consumers.

Selection and Quality

While Brilliant Earth’s selection may be more curated compared to Blue Nile, it prides itself on offering conflict-free diamonds and lab-created alternatives. Each piece undergoes stringent quality checks, with certifications from reputable organizations like the Gemological Institute of America (GIA).

If you're on the hunt for alternatives in the diamond market, consider the exceptional quality of Whiteflash's selection and the extensive collection of James Allen. Each provides a unique blend of choice and excellence to satisfy your quest for the perfect diamond.

Pricing and Value

Though Brilliant Earth’s pricing may be higher than some competitors’, it reflects their commitment to ethical and sustainable sourcing practices. Additionally, they offer financing options to enhance accessibility, ensuring their jewelry remains a worthwhile investment.

White Gold Stackable Rings at Brilliant Earth
Sapphire Gemstone Bracelet from BE

Customer Service and Returns

Brilliant Earth maintains a reputation for excellent customer service, providing free shipping and returns within a 30-day window. Their lifetime warranty further solidifies confidence in their products.

Ethics and Sustainability

With a strong emphasis on ethical sourcing and human rights, Brilliant Earth goes beyond standard practices. They work with suppliers who meet stringent criteria for fair labor and environmental sustainability, and a portion of their profits is directed towards communities affected by the jewelry industry.


Both Blue Nile and Brilliant Earth offer exceptional options for purchasing high-quality diamonds and jewelry online. While Blue Nile boasts a larger inventory and competitive pricing, Brilliant Earth stands out for its commitment to ethics, sustainability, and unique vintage designs. Ultimately, the choice between the two depends on individual preferences and values.

Scroll to Top