shape
carat
color
clarity

Wedding Wishy-washy bridesmaid... i want to scream!!!

Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.

amy_dub

Shiny_Rock
Joined
Sep 25, 2007
Messages
167
Please forgive me if I get bridzilla-ish on this, I will try my best not to. I''d really appreciate your advice on how to deal with this.

Ok, so Jon and I are getting married September 27. We''re just under 3 months away. We asked everyone we wanted in our wedding party if they would participate back in January (roughly a month after getting engaged). My best friend from childhood gets online shortly after we were engaged and is telling me that she and the father of her 5 year old are finally getting married. She''s set her date for oct 15 and she''d like for me to be in her wedding. I told her yes and then asked her to be in mine as well. She was thrilled and mentioned that she would love for me to be her maid of honor. I was a little shocked by this, but then she changed the subject and nothing else was mentioned about it.

In february she emails me pictures of a dress she''s chosen for her bridesmaids and tells me i need to be measured here (we live 4 hours apart) by a seamstress so she can order my dress. i get measured and email her. She then emails back that the wedding dress she bought cannot be altered to fit her so the bridal shop is buying the dress back. So now she''s purchasing a dress from David''s Bridal and that''s where she''ll get the bridesmaid dresses too. I''m like, ok, just let me know the dress and I can purchase it here at the local david''s bridal.

Well I never hear anything back from her until this past Tuesday night, 4 months later. she emails me to tell me her mother, who has a long history of drug abuse, passed away over the weekend and the funeral is wednesday. Her mother hasn''t been a part of her life for a good 6 years following her parents divorce. I email her back with my apologies over her mother and offer to help in anyway i can. I also ask how wedding plans are going. She emails me back last night (5 days later) and says "well, I don''t know if I''m going to be able to make it to your wedding. My cousin is getting married the week before you and i''m getting married 2 weeks after you. I''ve just got so much going on" then she continues to tell me she needs to know what size dress i wear if I plan to be in her wedding because the dress she chose has been discontinued and she doesn''t even know if she can order one for me. She says everyone else ordered their dresses and matching shoes weeks ago and that she didn''t mean for it to be like this, but she didn''t know the dress was going to be discontinued.

As you can imagine i''m furious. I''m 3 months from getting married and she''s telling me she doesn''t even know if she''s going to be here. So i email her back and tell her with so much going on with her and with the dress situation that maybe it''s best if we both just remove ourselves from each other''s wedding. I don''t want it to get to the day of my wedding and she not show up. Is it wrong of me to be like that? She never contacted be about the dress for her wedding and is now acting like it''s my fault that I don''t have a dress, when she never called or emailed me about it. I''m not a mind reader!

So now I guess I have to find a "replacement" BM to fill her spot, but I feel like whoever I chose, possibly my 15 year old cousin, is going to feel badly about being a replacement. My mom says "well, we''ll just remove a groomsmen. 5 bridesmaids is ridiculous anyway" I of course protest because you don''t just remove a groomsman because a bridesmaid drops out. Mom says "we''ll find something else for one of them to do." I''m like, yeah ok, let''s hurt one of their feelings and have them pissed and not show up either! My mom thinks more than 3 BMs is overkill, simply because she only had 3 when my parents got married back in 1980. Every person i chose as a BM was someone that I wanted in my wedding and aren''t just random people i''ve chosen for the heck of it, as are Jon''s groomsmen.

At this point i don''t know what to do. My Dad says to just ask my cousin to be in the wedding, despite the fact that it''s short notice and don''t tell her that she''s a replacement. He says to just say that I realized I didn''t have her involved in my wedding and that I would really like to have her as a BM. I''m letting my BMs pick their own dresses, as long as it''s black and tea length, they can wear what they want (to make it easier for them). It shouldn''t be hard for her to find a dress to fit within those two requirements in 3 months.

Any advice? Am I being unreasonable? What would you do in this situation? I realize her mom just died, but she hasn''t been in her life for years, and i don''t think that her mother passing away has anything to do with the fact that she never told me about the dress.
40.gif
 
I think you did the right thing in removing yourself from your friend''s wedding. It sounds like she is going through a lot, and that although you two are friends, you don''t seem close enough to really be there for each other (nothing wrong with that, just not necessarily people who should be in each other''s weddings). Although, I would have checked to make sure she hadn''t been trying to contact you about the dress and not being able to get through to you, since it seemed a bit like there was some miscommunication, i.e. that she thought you knew what dress you were supposed to be getting when you really had no idea. As for being a bridesmaid short, I would just have an uneven bridal party. In fact, that IS what I''m doing. One of our groomsmen found out he will be out of the country with no way to get back for our wedding, so we are just having an extra bm.
 
To be blunt ... it doesn''t sound like she wants you in her wedding *anyway*. If she told everyone else about the new dresses & conveniently forgot you? SINCE FEBRUARY. She probably realized she was gonna flake on YOUR wedding and just eliminated you from hers mentally but never had the guts to fill YOU in on her plans.

As to you wedding ... invite the cousin if you wish ... or have unequal sides. Its not such a big deal in the grand scheme of things. But I can see how it would be annoying. Sigh.
 
the wording of her email made it sound like she just got busy and forgot to let me know about the dress. She has my both of my phone numbers, and she knows I''m online several times a day, so it would have been easy to email me at the email address i''ve had since 1996. I really don''t think there was any miscommunication. I just feel like she was just asking me to be in her wedding because she felt obligated since we close friends before i moved away 10 years ago. And now maybe she''s thinking she shouldn''t have and is giving me the run around about it all.
 
i think you're right deco. Now I have to figure out what to do about my bridal party. Like I needed this....
15.gif
 
Ditto to Deco''s post.

Date: 6/30/2008 2:24:38 PM
Author:amy_dub
you don''t just remove a groomsman because a bridesmaid drops out.
40.gif

And I''d also say that you don''t just add a bridesmaid because another drops out. I think it''s terribly rude to ask someone to be in your wedding just to fill a spot, so to speak. If they weren''t special enough to you to ask in the first place, it seems so frivolous to add them now.
 
First, I think you did the right thing by removing yourself from her wedding. Don''t worry about that part. Judging by the time line of her email responses, it sounds more like she is being late getting back to you than being mad about it.

As for your wedding party, I personally think that you should just go with whomever you have left. I''m having 2 BM, and FI is having 1 GM (no MOH ranking for me). The GM is going to have a nice time escorting two ladies! My friend also had their WP uneven like this. FI''s parents are complaining that it''s not "the right way to do it", but I don''t care.
 
I wanted my cousin in my wedding, but didn''t want an uneven number of GM and BM. Jon couldn''t think of another person to ask i decided not to ask her to be in my wedding. I''ve felt really bad about because i wanted her to be there, but I''m a very "matchy, matchy" person and don''t like the fact of an uneven number of GMs & BMs.
 
Speaking from someone who has a few flakey friends, I can understand your frustration. However, you can not let it get to you like this. Remove yourself from her wedding as she didn''t include you on the dress information. Allow her to back out of yours. Do not replace her in the wedding...you''ve got 3 months to go and it does not matter if there are more groomsmen than BM''s.

That is sad about her mother. 6 years of not being close to her may even make it harder.

This is always hard because you feel bad for her situation, but it''s no excuse for what she did before hand.
 

I think that your father’s suggestion is what I would go with. I would ask your cousin to be in the wedding but you don’t have to say “hey someone dropped out, can you do me a favor?”


To be honest, I would have felt the same way. My rule for bridesmaids is no one that is far. I have a bunch of cousins in Orlando (4 hours away) that would love to be part of the wedding. However, I’m not going to ask them. It’s too much work trying to coordinate everything and with all the stress that weddings bring, any little thing helps.
 
ETA: Sorry don't know why it posted twice
32.gif
LOL
 
Date: 6/30/2008 2:42:16 PM
Author: decodelighted
To be blunt ... it doesn''t sound like she wants you in her wedding *anyway*. If she told everyone else about the new dresses & conveniently forgot you? SINCE FEBRUARY. She probably realized she was gonna flake on YOUR wedding and just eliminated you from hers mentally but never had the guts to fill YOU in on her plans.

As to you wedding ... invite the cousin if you wish ... or have unequal sides. Its not such a big deal in the grand scheme of things. But I can see how it would be annoying. Sigh.
Side note: My best friend has an uneven bridal party (more women than men). She did it on purpose so that I would walk out alone right before she walks out (in her words...she wants to give me my moment in the spotlight).

Good luck!
 
Hi~

SO sorry your "friend" is treating you like this! I absolutely think you made the best decision! She sounds like a rather flaky friend and you shouldnt worry yourself over it! I think you should either ask your cousin as you mentioned, or possibly another friend. You definitely don''t want to have an uneven number of BMs to GMs. At least I don''t. My FI has more close friends than I do and he really wanted 5. I''ve known for the past few years I would only have 4. I talked him into it and letting the other one be a reader or an usher. Everything will work out! Now you dont have to buy a BM dress from Davids that you will probably never wear again! I tried SO hard to pick one I thought everyone would wear again and I think I did. Woohoo!
 
Date: 6/30/2008 3:01:58 PM
Author: Haven
Ditto to Deco's post.



Date: 6/30/2008 2:24:38 PM
Author:amy_dub
you don't just remove a groomsman because a bridesmaid drops out.
40.gif

And I'd also say that you don't just add a bridesmaid because another drops out. I think it's terribly rude to ask someone to be in your wedding just to fill a spot, so to speak. If they weren't special enough to you to ask in the first place, it seems so frivolous to add them now.
I agree with Haven and Deco. I don't see why you'd need to make the wedding party even.
 
Date: 6/30/2008 7:15:14 PM
Author: ZoeBartlett

Date: 6/30/2008 3:01:58 PM
Author: Haven
Ditto to Deco''s post.




Date: 6/30/2008 2:24:38 PM
Author:amy_dub
you don''t just remove a groomsman because a bridesmaid drops out.
40.gif

And I''d also say that you don''t just add a bridesmaid because another drops out. I think it''s terribly rude to ask someone to be in your wedding just to fill a spot, so to speak. If they weren''t special enough to you to ask in the first place, it seems so frivolous to add them now.
I agree with Haven and Deco. I don''t see why you''d need to make the wedding party even.

I just don''t like things uneven. I''m an accounting major.. everything has to be straight, even, in line, and equal. I''m insanely OCD.
37.gif
 
Sorry to hear about your bridesmaid situation --- I think you definitely did the right thing in removing yourself from your friends'' bridal party...
About your own wedding, DEFINITELY ask your cousin and explain the situation... let her know how happy you actually are that it happened because now it means she can be a bigger part of your special day... Being that she is 15, I think she will be thrilled to be included and totally understand if you explain the situation. I would be really bothered also about the "uneven" bridal party!

Hope it all works out for you!
 
i''m ocd with numbers--i count everything, i can memorize up to 13 numbers immediately if someone rattles them off at me, etc...basically, i''m rain man but without the people''s court fixation. that being said, people talk, and it''s not like your cousin wouldn''t find out she was added in after issues with another bridesmaid. if you add her, i would be upfront about it and let her know that you''re beyond thrilled that she can be a part of your wedding because if she finds out otherwise, in my opinion, i think "replacement" is exactly what she''s going to feel like. i of all people understand the need for symmetry and even numbers (!!!!!!), but not at the expense of someone''s feelings, so if you add her, handle with caution.
 
Agree with Deco.

I'd ask your cousin to serve as a bridesmaid, or how about as a junior bridesmaid Since she's 15, that fits perfectly. I'd ask her in a way that would make her feel special. I'm thinking she'd be thrilled to be asked, the less said about it the better. Just say, will you do me the honor of being a bridesmaid in my wedding??

I am sorry about your friend, sounds like she has a lot going on, and has moved on.
 
Date: 6/30/2008 7:18:55 PM
Author: amy_dub
I just don''t like things uneven. I''m an accounting major.. everything has to be straight, even, in line, and equal. I''m insanely OCD.
37.gif
They make meds for this yanno??!
31.gif
2.gif
"Junior Bridesmaid" sounds like a great idea though ... if you can''t get an RX in time.
3.gif
 
Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top