shape
carat
color
clarity

Wedding small ceremony only or ceremony with reception

Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.

eggy1024

Rough_Rock
Joined
Aug 5, 2008
Messages
40
please help.

my bf and i are beginning to plan for our shindig. we live in wisconsin, and have a variety of options in several areas around here. most of our family and friends are in the area as well. we made a rough draft guest list and ended up with approximately 130 people on it. not too bad, i think. and we could probably trim a few off it.

here''s our trouble. we recently vacationed in arkansas and LOVED it. we stayed in the most charming b & b i''ve ever seen. having the entire wedding there (all 130 [or however many make the final cut] guests) is not an option, because the rain site (indoors, vs. outside under a tent) holds 30 people. the b & b has only 7 rooms, so we really don''t think it''s fair to have people travel all that way and then end up in a hotel a few miles away. we want to have only parents and siblings (ends up being 8 people - 2 parents each and 1 sibling each, plus us) travel to arkansas with us for a ceremony only. we would pay airfare and lodging for everyone. after the ceremony we would take a limo to a big city (probably little rock or hot springs) for a fancy dinner for the 8 of us. the problem is that our families do not like this idea. mine are bummed that grandma and great aunt wouldn''t go (arthritic joints and long plane rides don''t mix). fair enough. and i know that this is "our" day, but family is important, and if i can avoid WW3, so much the better. both of our families prefer the traditional ceremony with reception after. they know it won''t be a church wedding, which doesn''t thrill my folks, but they''ll have to get over it. in this instance, the "traditional" route means having it around here, with the whole guest list. we''d really prefer the arkansas route. but am i going to regret not having the reception and dancing and all of that? has anyone else done a small ceremony only? we doubt we''d throw a reception after arkansas (that''s the expensive part of the wedding day...not the ceremony), or if we do, it''d be a casual event at a park or pot-luck style or whatnot.

feel free to share tips, opinions, experiences. i would appreciate it. a lot of venues are booked for 2009 already. i feel like we''re running out of time. i''m stressed.
 
Well. We were torn between a smaller destination wedding and a larger local wedding with our families in attendance.

I REALLY wanted a smaller destination wedding. But, for me, what won is the I absolutely wanted my grandparents at my ceremony (which they would not have been able to attend with the destination wedding option). But *I* was the one who was bummed about them not being there... not my family. I think the decision is this... what would bother you more: Not having Arkansas or not having the whole family?

Also, can you do Arkansas for your honeymoon? It sounds like an ideal honeymoon.
 
Are there other factors that play into this? It there a money issue or is it just that you like Arkansas?

Well I guess it depends on what your vision of your wedding was (pre-arkansas visit) if you always wanted a small wedding, casual etc, I would say you probably won''t regret it. However if you''ve always wanted a big wedding, and yet fell madly in love, I would think you might end up regretting it.

I initially wanted a small, elope wedding (but there were lots of factors that played into it, family etc.) and presently it is a traditional wedding, with reception. Right now, I have to say I am happy I didn''t do the elope alone thing, I think I would have missed having a wedding, and frankly, all of my extended family is really excited to come. Their seeing it as a family reunion kind of thing.

In any case, my final advice would be to go with your gut feeling. Everyone will probably adjust (and get excited about it too)
 
I totally wanted a destination wedding, but my DH wanted a traditional wedding....or, should I say, his parents made him want a traditional wedding. Anyway, we had one, and it was glam!

I think you could have the absolute best of both worlds with a little give and take.

I would have your traditional wedding, and take a long, lovely, extended honeymoon in Arkansas.

First and foremost, family and friends really do make the day. Having your Grandma at your wedding will mean something, it will be special. Do I think you should have a wedding just to appease people? No...it's your day. But its special to be surround by that much love. It will make your family happy which is great, since they will be your big support system during the planning.

And then jet off to Arkansas. Have a blast. Take three weeks if you want!

ETA: Your wedding is something you'll never be able to recapture. The pictures, the video, the whole thing is absolutely once in a lifetime. But, you could always have a vow renewal after 5 years in Arkansas too!
 
Date: 8/12/2008 3:21:48 PM
Author: allycat0303
Are there other factors that play into this? It there a money issue or is it just that you like Arkansas?

Well I guess it depends on what your vision of your wedding was (pre-arkansas visit) if you always wanted a small wedding, casual etc, I would say you probably won''t regret it. However if you''ve always wanted a big wedding, and yet fell madly in love, I would think you might end up regretting it.

I initially wanted a small, elope wedding (but there were lots of factors that played into it, family etc.) and presently it is a traditional wedding, with reception. Right now, I have to say I am happy I didn''t do the elope alone thing, I think I would have missed having a wedding, and frankly, all of my extended family is really excited to come. Their seeing it as a family reunion kind of thing.

In any case, my final advice would be to go with your gut feeling. Everyone will probably adjust (and get excited about it too)
No, money isn''t an object (within reason, of course though). It would definitely be cheaper (about $5K cheaper, according to our rough estimates) to get married in Arkansas, which means more money for projects around the house, etc., but that''s not the main reason for pursuing Arkansas. And I was never one of those girls who dreamed of her wedding day as a child. I honestly don''t know if I want a big fancy wedding or a small intimate one. Thanks for your input. :-)
 
Do you WANT a small wedding? Or just a wedding in Arkansas?

If you want a small wedding, and are OK without the 130 people and all the hoopla (or might even prefer not to have the 130 people), go for your small wedding vision in Arkansas without regret. I think a lovely picnic reception back home for all the relatives will help ease the sting. And yes, it will take strength to override all the family wishes, but if you have confidence that the smaller wedding is your preference, then procede.

If you would really like BOTH the 130 people and Arkansas, then you might have to revise your plan or choose which you want more. First off, it might be possible to have a larger wedding in Arkansas. 130 people would probably not make the trek (if that is how many would go to a local wedding) but 50-60 might. And there is nothing wrong with them staying in a hotel or paying their own way - as long as you would be OK with people not making it because of the expense and hassle of travel. I am assuming that you are considering a vacation area of Arkansas that would have some non-wedding things for visitors to do. And then you would have to rent a larger tent or cater it or something which might cost more $$$.

But it sounds very much like your vision is a smaller Arkansas wedding. If that is what you want, and you have confidence that it is what you want, go for it! Your parents will have to get over there dissapointment, but it is your life to live!
 
What part of WI do you live in? I think you should be able to find something for 2009. I managed to plan a Saturday night July wedding in the Hamptons(New York) in 3 months...you can do this if you are
How about door county? You could probably find a romantic b and b venue that grandma could get to. I also love the hills of SW Wisconsin. Maybe Green Lake or Waupaca? You might be able to find a compromise. While it is your big day, it is also a chance for your grandparents and parents to show off a bit.
Just my thinking, at the end of the day, what you want matters most.
 
I agree with Italiahaircolor. Have a grand wedding with your family (it will be great) and go to Arkansas for your Honeymoon. I think it will be much more special to go to your dream place just the two of you, as husband and wife, with the wedding stress done and over with.
 
Date: 8/12/2008 3:21:48 PM
Author: allycat0303
Are there other factors that play into this? It there a money issue or is it just that you like Arkansas?


Well I guess it depends on what your vision of your wedding was (pre-arkansas visit) if you always wanted a small wedding, casual etc, I would say you probably won''t regret it. However if you''ve always wanted a big wedding, and yet fell madly in love, I would think you might end up regretting it.


I initially wanted a small, elope wedding (but there were lots of factors that played into it, family etc.) and presently it is a traditional wedding, with reception. Right now, I have to say I am happy I didn''t do the elope alone thing, I think I would have missed having a wedding, and frankly, all of my extended family is really excited to come. Their seeing it as a family reunion kind of thing.


In any case, my final advice would be to go with your gut feeling. Everyone will probably adjust (and get excited about it too)

I think this is good advice. Maybe you could have an anniversary, wedding renewal in Arkansas?
 
Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top