shape
carat
color
clarity

Heartbreaking Jewelry Accidents...

Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.

whitby_2773

Ideal_Rock
Joined
Jan 5, 2009
Messages
2,655
as some of you may know, my husband and i recently had our original wedding rings and mr original e-ring melted down and made into beautiful new rings for our 25th wedding anniversary. this is GREAT, and something we''re so excited about; between his breaking, and mine giving me eczema, we haven''t worn our original rings in YEARS.

i had these rings made in australia, as we wanted to get them done by a friend who is a very good jeweler there, and also in the ''land of our birth''. just for sentimental reasons, y''know? this was project 1.

at the same time, i also sent home the wedding ring my father gave my mother (both deceased), the bangle my grandparents gave my mother for her 21st many years ago, and the setting for the 25th anniversary ring my father gave my mother; 3 VERY sentimental pieces as my mother died within months of their 25th anniversary. i asked my friend, who took them home to australia for me (with detailed instructions for the jeweler), to hold onto the second lot of jewelry till i was ready for project 2. my plan was to have these pieces melted down also and made into two rings - for my sister and i. i was going to have them set with small diamonds (my mother''s birthstone) either side of the birthstone of my sister and me.

so, about a week ago i decided i was ready to proceed. i told my sister - who was over the MOON; my father married again after my mother died, and when he died everything of sentimental value was left to my father''s second wife. so my sister and i had very few things from our parents of sentimental value.

it just so happens that my friend, to whom i gave the jewelry, has currently been here visiting and was leaving today to go home. so we had a talk about her going to my jeweler and giving them the second part of the instructions i had composed, and the rest of the jewelry. my friend asked me what jewelry i wanted in the new rings and, over the ensuing conversation, it became apparent that she has accidentally given the jewelers my mother''s wedding ring along with my and my husband''s original rings and that it has been accidentally melted down and included in OUR remade rings.

i''m terribly upset on a number of accounts. firstly, i really wanted tim''s and my new rings to ONLY be rings that were pertinent to tim''s and my wedding. secondly, after my father remarried, i was never particularly close to him, so the last thing i want in my wedding rings to/from my husband is a ring my father bought. and lastly, i''ve just TOLD my sister that ''her new ring'' was going to represent our grandparents (bangle), our parents at their marriage (wedding ring), and then the enduring nature of that marriage (25th anniversary ring). given that there were so few things of sentimental significance when my parents died, the few things we had were jealously squabbled over, and this was very much in the nature of an offering which i had hoped would symbolize the bond between my sister and i, and my willingness to share all that is precious to me. telling her that our mother''s wedding ring has been subsumed into my own remade rings will NOT be well received!

so this is basically a disaster. and it made me start to wonder - what jewelry disasters have other people had? have you ever lost ''dead aunt mavis''s diamond ring''? ever seen your one-of-a-kind engagement ring swirl down a sink, never to return? ever lost a 2 ct earring in the ocean? or have you ever broken a piece of jewelry that was somebody ELSE''S? borrowed something precious and lost it?

please share your worst lost/broken jewelry experiences here - it might even make us all feel better to know we''re not alone in our jewelry''s darkest moments!

feeling kinda miserable....
 
I''m really sorry to hear that! It''s too bad that happened! There is clearly no way to undo this. I think that your intentions were pure and that you really wanted to do this nice thing for your sister. I think this is an example of a time when a white lie might be in the best interest of everybody. You in no way intended for this to happen so is there really anything to be gained by telling your sister? Maybe letting her think that it contains all of those pieces together would be the kindest course of action?

Maybe that''s not a popular opinioin though....but sometimes bliss is ingnorance.

My story: My grandmother gave me a signet ring that had belonged to her when I was about 12 years old. I was wearing it at school and it fell off into the grass. I combed the yard over and over and my mom and I went after school....it was gone. I felt guilty about it for years and i never did tell her (and I''m glad because there was nothing to be gained by telling her as far as she knew I still had the ring which made her happy).

:) Alice
 
i''m sorry about your signet ring, alice
7.gif
i had one once that was my father''s. i dated a guy for a short while and let him wear it. he took it off one evening and put it on his nightstand; his dog ate it.

re the white lie...

i told tim, the most honest man i know, what had happened. but he also knows my sister (she''s a kinda scary lady!) and without hesitation, he looked me straight in the eye and said;

"Lie."

(i laughed)
 
Date: 6/24/2009 10:27:52 PM
Author: whitby_2773
i''m sorry about your signet ring, alice
7.gif
i had one once that was my father''s. i dated a guy for a short while and let him wear it. he took it off one evening and put it on his nightstand; his dog ate it.


re the white lie...


i told tim, the most honest man i know, what had happened. but he also knows my sister (she''s a kinda scary lady!) and without hesitation, he looked me straight in the eye and said;


''Lie.''


(i laughed)

Oh, whitby, that''s so unfortunate!
38.gif


If you choose to tell your sister a white lie, just make sure she won''t find you on PS some day!
23.gif
 
Oh, Whitby, that''s just *awful.*

I don''t see any way at all to separate your mother''s ring out from your wedding rings (possibly you could think of it as a tangible manifestation of the fact that family is almost always a factor in a happy relationship?), but possibly you could ask the jeweler to incorporate a tiny bit of gold from your rings into the new pieces for you and your sister? That way, you wouldn''t be lying about your mother''s rings being a (admittedly somewhat diluted) part of the new pieces, and you could just ... omit ... the info. that your wedding rings were maybe floating around in there, too.
 
Whitby: I'm so sorry that your well-thought out plans went awry! It can only begin to imagine how you must have felt when you figured out the mix-up.

As for my story... my grandfather and great-grandfather on my father's side loved the finer things, which included a small collection of gemstones and jewelry. Both of my parents grew up in the midst of the second world war, both families lost lost much of their wealth during the war, and three of my grandparents died during the war or shortly thereafter. My grandmother did manage to hold on to some jewelry and a few pieces of silver, however. My inheritance from my ancestor's gem collection was a beautiful, 2-3 carat, hand polished, alexandrite that was given to me after my graduation from college. It was well saturated and free of inclusions, and had a beautiful, complete, teal-green to magenta color change. My grandmother had it set in a simple gold pendant for me. Being very young, naive, clueless, and (at the time) purportedly non-materialistic, I didn't insure it, I reasoned that its primary value was sentimental rather than monetary. I did however carry it with me a lot to "keep it safe" even when I wasn't wearing it.

Do I even need to go on? Suffice it to say I was heartbroken when I lost it during a trip to San Francisco, and took more than one day off of work (I was a newbie then) to retrace my steps with the hope of finding it. I even sought help from a psychic -- LOL! It took a year or more for me to forgive myself even a little bit, and longer before I could get up the courage to tell my parents. When I did, my dear father confessed that he had lost an alexandrite when he was a child... so maybe I was just doing my part to carry on the family tradition?

Back to your situation, is there any possibility that you could get your stepmother to hand over some of your mother's jewelry, now that (I assume) some time has passed?


ETA: BTW Whitby, have you checked your SMTR thread lately?
2.gif
31.gif
 
Whit, the best truths are the ones that make others happy. She knew what was going into it right? Do you need to clarify that things went awry or can you just leave her to assume?

A relative was leaving me and my sister her large diamond rings, they were removed from her fingers at the hospice after she died. My mother lost her onyx class ring on the beach in Bermuda. Last year Dad gave her a vintage replacement one. She was thrilled. I will however never truly forgive my sister for losing my mickeymouse watch with grossgrain ribbon band back in elementary school.
 
Date: 6/24/2009 10:58:52 PM
Author: RubyCharm
Date: 6/24/2009 10:27:52 PM

Author: whitby_2773

i''m sorry about your signet ring, alice
7.gif
i had one once that was my father''s. i dated a guy for a short while and let him wear it. he took it off one evening and put it on his nightstand; his dog ate it.

re the white lie...

i told tim, the most honest man i know, what had happened. but he also knows my sister (she''s a kinda scary lady!) and without hesitation, he looked me straight in the eye and said;

''Lie.''

(i laughed)


Oh, whitby, that''s so unfortunate!
38.gif



If you choose to tell your sister a white lie, just make sure she won''t find you on PS some day!
23.gif
[
/QUOTE]

**choke**

laughing here, ruby...i didnt see that one coming, but you''re oh so right!!
 
Whitby,
I know how you feel. We were married (many years ago) in August, and I was given hubby''s grandmother''s diamond.
The following January, we were robbed at gunpoint.
So, a ring she had kept fifty years, I managed to lose in five months.
The think is, there is absolutely nothing you can do about it now.
Eventually, I came to accept it and not be so sentimental about my engagement ring.
Instead, I am now more sentimental about some other things I have, some other rings and silverware.
That is your only choice now.
The fun thing is, nearly thirty years later, I have an excuse to shop for colored stone engagement rings and not wear the same one every day! Life is too short to wring your hands over a material item.
1.gif

I love your posts, by the way. You have a real penchant for writing, I can tell.
 
I don''t have any stories of my own, just wanted to say I''m really sorry about the mix up, Whitby.
 
sorry that happened to you
7.gif
good luck with handling it, though i do like circe''s suggestion, then you wouldn''t have to worry about lying about something that''s not in there at least.

i seem to have not so good luck with jewelry lately. M got me a lovely green murano glass pendant two christmases ago and i was so excited i put it on after opening it and then we went out to supper. somewhere between me putting it on, getting into the car, eating at the restaurant, picking up my check from work, going on a carriage ride through a light display, and getting to a friend''s house where we spent the night, it fell off the chain.

had a bead fall off a bracelet last spring (i got the bracelet that same christmas from my grandma) and last month i somehow lost an earring (from my aunt and uncle for my birthday) in our hotel room after our friends'' wedding. the reception had gone late and i was so tired i just changed and fell asleep without taking them out and i woke up with only one in.

i''m fairly certain i will superglue my e-ring to my hand when i get it. it has to be harder to lose my fingers than jewelry, i still have all ten of them.
 
How terrible! I''m so sorry this mishap happened to you, and while I am an extremely honest person I have to say I think lying to your sister would be the best course of action. No good will come of telling her the truth I''m afraid, you had the best of intentions and I think that''s what matters.

The one jewlery mishap that stick out in my mind is when a ring my grandfather bought my fell off my finger and down a street grate
39.gif
 
Date: 6/25/2009 10:01:10 AM
Author: Pink Tower
Whitby,

I know how you feel. We were married (many years ago) in August, and I was given hubby''s grandmother''s diamond.

The following January, we were robbed at gunpoint.

So, a ring she had kept fifty years, I managed to lose in five months.

The think is, there is absolutely nothing you can do about it now.

Eventually, I came to accept it and not be so sentimental about my engagement ring.

Instead, I am now more sentimental about some other things I have, some other rings and silverware.

That is your only choice now.

The fun thing is, nearly thirty years later, I have an excuse to shop for colored stone engagement rings and not wear the same one every day! Life is too short to wring your hands over a material item.
1.gif


I love your posts, by the way. You have a real penchant for writing, I can tell.

yay! thank you, Pink Tower! i''m a psychologist/mediator by training, but for the past 6 years have been working as a writer of children''s novels. so i''m VERY glad you can see some degree of talent in that regard! (phew!)
9.gif
 
Pink Tower - i should have said also...

i''m so sorry about your experience with the robbery. incredibly frightening and unsettling. you seem to have developed an excellent attitude to deal with it.

:)
 
Excellent plan re the superglue, Squirrly!! That should do it!

And purselover, I’m sorry about the ring from your grandfather; those sorts of losses are irreplaceable!

Thanks steph. I have ot be honest and say –it’s really had a bigger impact that I would have thought – I mean – it’s such a small thing. I think with both parents deceased, those remade rings were going ot be like a little memorial – exactly the same way MY remade rings were like a little tribute. Ugh. Annnooooyiiiinng!!

Oh gees, VRBeauty! How horrible re your pendant! That’s a heart-breaker! And ooooh yes – I checked out those earrings, you enabler you! they’re GORGEOUS! I just love the setting. I have center stones, tho, and I do want to use them. (there was a voice in my head, tho, when I looked at those, that was going “do both! Go oooon, you can do BOTH…”)
 
THAT IS SOO DISAPPOINTING! I understand your heartache. I''ve never had a disaster like that but I can totally sympathise. I just wanted to give you a JUMBO HUG! (and I''ve got my leave in conditioner, so my hair smells AWESOME!)
 
Whitby,

Two things, quickly:

1. I''m a Montessorian, so that may be why I tuned in to the fact that you seem to intuit people''s feelings. I''d naturally identify with the way you write since Theory is so emphasized in how "We" approach young children. ( figure out what is ''the essential'' - you know?)

2. With the ring issue, I have a friend from Perth. She used to always say things to the effect that, as an Australian, she approached life with a ''sort of, make your own way attitude.'' I admire that quality in her very much.

Pink
 
Date: 6/25/2009 11:55:08 AM
Author: tlh
THAT IS SOO DISAPPOINTING! I understand your heartache. I''ve never had a disaster like that but I can totally sympathise. I just wanted to give you a JUMBO HUG! (and I''ve got my leave in conditioner, so my hair smells AWESOME!)

(stifling a BIG laugh!)

thank you for the hug, tlh! and thank GOODNESS you have the leave in conditioner workin'', or i would have had to think about it twice! but given that you DO have the leave in conditioner happening...

hug it out!

9.gif
9.gif
9.gif
9.gif
9.gif
9.gif
 
Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top