Which one should I choose?

[boxerdog]

Hi, I really need help deciding between these two diamonds. I appreciate any advice. Thanks!

Diamond #1 is from Dirt Cheap Diamonds, $5702
Princess Cut
Signature Series Ideal
GIA Certified
1.0 Carat
E-VS1
VG polish, VG symmetry
5.53x5.51x4.01
Depth 72.8
Table 62
Crown Angle 43.5
Crown Height 16
Pavilion Angle 38
Pavilion Depth 55
Girdle 1.9
Culet None
Fluorescence None
Attachment is for diamond #1

Diamond #2 is from Good Old Gold, $5818 www.goodoldgold.com/1_02ct_e_vs2_princess.htm
Princess Cut
Gia Certified
1.02 Carat
E-VS2
Excellent Polish, VG Symmetry
5.43x5.45x3.95
Depth 72.6
Table 68
Crown Angle ?
Crown Height 11.4
Pavilion Angle ?
Pavilion Depth 54.9
Girdle 6.9
Culet None
Fluorescence None

 

[decodelighted]

Well even though the carat weight is higher on the Good Old Gold one, the dimensions show that #1 will LOOK bigger. Not sure which one is better, cause I''m not up on the princess stats ...

 

[belle]

i like the first one, but i''m afraid the girdle might be toooo thin.

for a princess cut, i feel a thicker girdle may be safer.