which one-need PSer''s wisdom

[Ann]

Round 0.61 F SI1 Signature AGS 61.1% 57% ID/ID $ 2,090
Round 0.61 G VS2 Ideal GIA 61.1% 57% EX/EX $ 1,790
Round 0.62 G VS2 Ideal AGS 61.3% 56% ID/ID $ 2,170
Round 0.63 G VS1 Signature AGS 60.9% 56% ID/ID $ 2,410
Round 0.64 F VS2 Ideal AGS 61% 57% ID/ID $ 2,370

these are all James Allen, sorry I couldn''t post the measurements.

I have a question. Is .5 better than say, a 1.6 score?

 

[valeria101]

Date: 4/9/2006 4:26:25 PM
Author:Ann
Round 0.61 F SI1 Signature AGS 61.1% 57% ID/ID $ 2,090
Round 0.61 G VS2 Ideal GIA 61.1% 57% EX/EX $ 1,790
Round 0.62 G VS2 Ideal AGS 61.3% 56% ID/ID $ 2,170
Round 0.63 G VS1 Signature AGS 60.9% 56% ID/ID $ 2,410
Round 0.64 F VS2 Ideal AGS 61% 57% ID/ID $ 2,370

these are all James Allen, sorry I couldn't post the measurements.

If all these come with good cut credentials, well, the second, of course

I have a question. Is .5 better than say, a 1.6 score?

No. There are lots of old threads about it

Edited to add..

OK. saw the listings. And sure enough, the 'numbers' are there etc. Only the first comes with IS etc. However, it still sounds like these guys are darn close in color and clarity and it makes little sense to me not to go with the lower price (for lack of any serious quality or size difference between the choices).

 

[Sundial]

I guess I''m a sucker for brand names, but I like the idea of their Signature series stones. The G VS1 looks good to me, but of course it is the most expensive.