shape
carat
color
clarity

Seriously .. . the conversation had me in tears. . .(this is LONG)

Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.

hisspecialk

Rough_Rock
Trade
Joined
Apr 5, 2010
Messages
40
i am so confused about what this means and how i should feel! Today is our 2 year anniversary and we''ve been talking marriage for a long time. . .but nothing really concrete. . he brings it up or make reference to it more than I do. . .we have discussed detail so much (of jsut the actual wedding) that I think he could secretly plan our wedding all on his own and i''d still have exactly what I wanted. Yes!That much. .. . so I need help understand what he is saying to me. . .

We decided that on the upcoming trip we would discuss our future. We are leaving Thursday .. but somehow lastnight we ended up in the discussion, on the phone. . =( not at all what I envisioned!!! Anyway. . .

Anyway, this past Sunday was fabulous! We spent the whole day together. . . . . church, we cooked together for his gram after church, went to the movies and then to communion that night and then he spent the night over (no we did''t do anything =) lol i noticed that he brought up marriage, weddings and he future alot. Especially when we were with his gram and mom. and i was wondering if he was doing it cause he was sensing that i was antsy or. . . .he just brought it up cause that''s what was on his mind, ya know?

I didn''t say a whole lot just listened and observed.

Lastnight tho he asked me how much money i was making annually (he never ever had before) and i asked him he same question and then he said ok that means we make 107,000 together and i was like uh ok. . . and he started talking about getting a raise. . . and he asked how much did i think was good to spend on a wedding and i was like id on''t know. . he average for cali is about 35k and he was quiet. then i said but that''s this year. . every year that amount goes up. . .last year the average was 30k and i said shoot we coulda been done this and said that 5 g''s but you wanna have a sista on the 3-5 year plan. . .lol and he was like kay you are acting like 2 years is a long time! do you think it is. . and i said if we were 25 or 26 no it wouldn''t be. . but when you take into consideration our ages, the fact that we have agreed that we want a child together i think that changes. we are older, old enough to decide relatively quickly what we want and don''t want. period. so yes 2 years is a long time for us to be in a relationship and still be unsettled about what we are doing and where we are going. and he said we are not unsettled k, i want to marry you, i want a child with you - i want a life with you, I know you want a proposal and the rings needs to accompany that - I want to give you what you want. I don''t want any disappointment around my proposal, your ring on your part or mine. And i said well i hear you saying you want to marry me.. . .you''ve been saying that but theres nothing behind it.. no action. No step towards a future life together and he said where is the trust, where is the faith in the man you claim you love? etc etc. . .and he said i want you to be completely surprised, i won''t compromise on that k and i said i am not trying to ruin any surprise but I want to know his intentions, if he has a timeframe. ..etc etc and he asked why?!!!

I said that''s what people do.. .in the beginning we discussed our intentions (to be exclusive and possibly pursue a future) and I said we''ve moved passed that .. .and are on a different level.. .discussing intenions is to make sure we are still on the same page and he said we wil not make it to year 3 without being engaged. which is not what i wanted to hear so i was quiet and i said your time frame was 3 years? and he got upset (but tried to hide it) - this is not how I envision this conversation going. . .i wanted it to be a discussion. .. logisics, hopes, dreams. . .desires. . instead i felt like i was put in a position to have to justify why i want what i want - made me feel very antsy and uncomfortable. Anywho. . .he asked what mine was and i said 2 and a half and he said is that non-negotiable? I said we are talking about sharing our lives J. .. of course it is. . but i need you to know that 3 years is not acceptable to me. he got quiet and said i am not going to tell you a month when i will propose k.. .THAT is unacceptable to me.

i left it at. . i don''t need to know what month. . and just need him to know what is an isn''t acceptable to me. . .if you don''t want any disappointments around your proposal you might want to consider that. we got off the phone at this point.

Why would a discussion about the future be a secret? . .there is more occuring in the future than a proposal and a wedding....
i need to turn this around on this trip. . .i know i need to change my attitude cause i obviously got defensive .. =(
How can i move past this and turn it into something positive? Geez. . . there are more important things to discuss. . than a wedding. . . (i.e finances, where to live, kids, etc)???
HELP!!!
14.gif
 

Haven

Super_Ideal_Rock
Joined
Feb 15, 2007
Messages
13,166
K--It sounds like this was a positive conversation to me.

He loves you, wants to marry you, wants to give you everything you want in terms of a ring and a proposal, and he is adamant that the proposal be a surprise.

Are you upset because he doesn''t want to tell you when, exactly, he plans on proposing? It really sounds like he very much wants the proposal to be a surprise, so telling you would ruin the surprise.

It sounds to me like your LIW-itis is making it difficult for you to see this situation rationally. This man loves you. He wants to marry you, and has stated so. I''d urge you to be comforted by the fact that you have found each other and that you *do* have similar plans for your future together, so instead of bringing up the same conversation over and over again (and leaving it unhappy because he is not going to tell you when he''s going to propose) I would just focus on enjoying your time together.

I might be way off, but this guy sounds serious about marrying you, and equally as serious about making the proposal a surprise. Bringing up the timeline conversation seems moot to me, because he really sounds like he''s on board.
 

lulu

Ideal_Rock
Joined
Jul 11, 2003
Messages
2,328
Date: 4/6/2010 12:24:16 PM
Author: Haven
K--It sounds like this was a positive conversation to me.

He loves you, wants to marry you, wants to give you everything you want in terms of a ring and a proposal, and he is adamant that the proposal be a surprise.

Are you upset because he doesn''t want to tell you when, exactly, he plans on proposing? It really sounds like he very much wants the proposal to be a surprise, so telling you would ruin the surprise.

It sounds to me like your LIW-itis is making it difficult for you to see this situation rationally. This man loves you. He wants to marry you, and has stated so. I''d urge you to be comforted by the fact that you have found each other and that you *do* have similar plans for your future together, so instead of bringing up the same conversation over and over again (and leaving it unhappy because he is not going to tell you when he''s going to propose) I would just focus on enjoying your time together.

I might be way off, but this guy sounds serious about marrying you, and equally as serious about making the proposal a surprise. Bringing up the timeline conversation seems moot to me, because he really sounds like he''s on board.

Ditto.
 

fieryred33143

Ideal_Rock
Joined
May 18, 2008
Messages
6,689
Perhaps I''m missing the secret part
33.gif
.

Your timeframe of when you''d like to be engaged is 2.5 months.

His is 3 years.

No secret.

In the grand scheme of things, is 6 months really all that much of a difference? Or were you hoping for an engagement by 2.5 months and to be married by 3 years?

Everyone deals with the LIWitis in their own way so I''m not going to tell you how you should or should not feel. And most LIWs do get anxiety at some point about when the proposal is going to take place (not saying all, but most do). I''m also not going to tell you that it''s wrong or right to have internal timelines because that is a personal choice.

But since you asked for tips, the only thing I can tell you is that obviously you feel very strongly that this is the man you want to spend your life with since you are looking for a proposal and talking about having children. If you trust that he is being honest with you about his desire to be your husband and have a family together, then I would look at this conversation as a positive step towards that future not as a negative conversation.
 

hisspecialk

Rough_Rock
Trade
Joined
Apr 5, 2010
Messages
40
Hello Everyone and thank you for responding. . . . I think I got exactly what I came here for. ..

A REALITY CHECK!! I think my ITIS has been running amok for too long!

Each of you brought valid points. . . and I need to change my perception of this conversation.

He is a wonderful man and I am incredibly happy with our relationship.

I now have a glass of water in one hand and a CHILL pill in the *ringless* other. .=)

I appreciate all your responses. . .Have a great day!

12.gif
I''ll be good from now on! i promise! lol
 

babycush

Shiny_Rock
Trade
Joined
Oct 19, 2009
Messages
160
Date: 4/6/2010 12:39:34 PM
Author: hisspecialk



I now have a glass of water in one hand and a CHILL pill in the *ringless* other. .=)

This made me smile
5.gif
 

RaiKai

Brilliant_Rock
Joined
Mar 8, 2010
Messages
1,255
I hope you are still chilling as like the others I think he definitely is keen to marry YOU. And he seems to keen to ask you in a few months.

Relax! 6 months difference is nothing.
 

PumpkinPie

Ideal_Rock
Joined
Jan 17, 2010
Messages
2,841
Date: 4/6/2010 5:58:25 PM
Author: RaiKai
I hope you are still chilling as like the others I think he definitely is keen to marry YOU. And he seems to keen to ask you in a few months.


Relax! 6 months difference is nothing.

ditto :)
good luck!
 

tyty333

Super_Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Dec 17, 2008
Messages
27,367
I think I would be on cloud 9 if I were you! Six months is not a big deal when you are only talking 2-3 years. Heck, some
women have been waiting 8+ years for an engagment. To me it sounds like you *should* be very happy! Cheer up (and relax)!
 
Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.
Be a part of the community Get 3 HCA Results
Top