Please help! Time Sensitive Question

[fhuici]

Can you folks please give me your opinion on the following stone? I need to buy one of these stone''s within a couple of days. I''m kind of leaning towards the 1st one. Even though its a VS2, it''s mostly due to a small feather on the bottom. I couldn''t even see it under a loupe. Anyways, your opinion would greatly be appreciated. Please note that I didn''t include the cost because that''s not really what I need the opinions on. I need an opinion what which stone would look the nicest. Thanks

1st
GIA
Measurements: 6.04 x 6.03 x 4.20
1.22 carat
Depth: 69.7
Table: 74
Girdle: Medium
Culet: None
Polish Very Good
Symmetry: Very Good
VS2
Color: G
Fluorescense: None

2nd
GIA
Measurements: 5.96 x 5.83 x 4.21
1.20 carat
Depth 72.2
Table: 69
Girdle: Stk-Tk
Culet: None
Polish: Very Good
Symmetry: Very Good
VS1
Color: G
Fluorescense: None

3rd
GIA
6.23 x 6.17 x 4.10 mm
1.22 - carat
Depth - 66.5
Table - 76 %
Girdle - very thin to slighty thick
Culet - none
Polish - VG
Symemetry - VG
Clarity - VS1
Color - H
Fl - Faint

 

[Rank Amateur]

What shape - princess?

 

[fhuici]

Oh yeah, sorry about that. Its a princess cut. Thanks

 

[belle]

it sounds like you have seen all of these stones together. the nicest one is the one is definitely the one that you liked the best!

if you need someone that has never seen these stones to pick one only by the numbers, i''ll take #2

best of luck to you!