Please evaluate

[dedicated]

Hi all,
I''m still searching for the perfect stone (in my budget that is

Anyway, I found a few that seem good but could use your help in evaluating. Do these prices seem reasonable? Which one would you choose for more bang for the buck?

#1 #2 #3
GIA GIA GIA
Carat 1.01 1.0 0.92
Color G G G
Clarity SI-1 SI-1 SI-1
Depth 62.9 62.1 61.1
Table% 54.4 57 58
Girdle TK M-STK-F M-STK-F
Pol VG Ex VG
Sym VG G VG
Cutlet Small 0 0
Flu Faint 0 Faint

CrAng 34.7 35.6 34.7
Pav Ang 40.5 40.5 40.5
Cutlet 1.2% 0 0

HCA 0.7(TIC) 0.8(FIC) 0.6(TIC)

$$$ 4580 4945 4010

Thanks,
Dedicated

 

[Regular Guy]

Dedicated,

I''d be very interested in #2 (I have an FIC, too), and concerned about discussion here for 1 & 3.

 

[MissAva]

I like #2!

 

[strmrdr]

#2 is the best of that lot.
The G in sym may or may not be an issue.
Its not an ags0 so there should be a price break over ideals.
Can you get an ideal-scope image?
With decent optical symetry it could be a very nice diamond.
It should have lots of fire.
1 and 3 id skip.

I dont have time this am to check the price but if the symetry is decent and the price decent #2 sounds nice.