Help me decide

[michaell1999]

#1 1.43ct H VS2
#2 1.54ct I SI1

Both are close to same price. Is the .1 carat difference worth it?

 

[belle]

have you seen these?

 

[Dancing Fire]

Date: 11/21/2005 4:57:09 PM
Author:michaell1999
#1 1.43ct H VS2
#2 1.54ct I SI1

Both are close to same price. Is the .1 carat difference worth it?

get more info on these stones

the 1.43ct might be the same size, depending on the cut.

 

[JohnQuixote]

Which lab(s) did the grading reports?

Measurements in mm will help us answer the face up size question DF alludes to.

The depth%, table%, girdle and culet details, as well as polish and symmetry grades, should also appear on the grading documents. Providing those will be a good start to helping us help you, but we'll need even more to do a thorough job.

Crown and pavilion ANGLES will be very helpful. Star and lower girdle facet averages will allow us to predict with even more accuracy. These numbers appear on a Sarin, Ogi or Helium report if the seller can provide one.

Top notch (that's practical to ask for) would be an ideal-scope or ASET reflector photo, though many retailers - especially live ones - don't provide this service. You can visit this site for an overview on how IS works, if interested.

 

[michaell1999]

I haven''t seen these diamonds.
Heres the info from each GIA

From GIA
round modified brilliant
measurements
7.35 - 7.40 X 4.36mm
1.43 carat
depth 59.1%
Table 56%
girdle thin to medium, faceted
cutlet none
polish very good
symmetry very good
vs2
h
fluorescence medium blue

From GIA
round modified brillian
measurements
7.45 - 7.49 x 4.53mm
1.54 carat
depth 60.6%
table 53%
girdle medium to slightly thick, faceted
cutlet none
polish excellent
symmetry excellent
SI1
I
fluorescence none

Thanks