H color princesses

[jetmal]

I'm looking at 2 H color princess cuts.

one is 1.52 H SI1, 74 % table, 75% depth

the other is 1.55 H VS2, 71% table, 73.9 depth

I do not have crown and pav anlges....they can be obtained if I need to.
they both are eye clean, and good color


there is a $600 diff. between the 2.....
which one would you choose?

 

[f0rbidden]

I''m not an expert on diamonds at all, especially not princess cuts, but which one is higher? The VS2?
and is the SI an SI1 or an SI2 or an SI3?

Sight unseen, I would probably choose the VS, but then again, I''m a clarity fiend and to me clarity is second only to cut when choosing a diamond - not everyone agrees with that!

 

[Sundial]

I would want to know at least the crown height, but based on what you've shown I would choose the second VS stone because the table is a little smaller. Princess cuts are really hard to judge without seeing them though.

 

[jetmal]

sorry guys, its a SI 1...I went back and edited that