Down to last two choices: vs1 1.20 vs1 1.22

[vball]

Need advice on the following two rocks:

Color D
1.20 Depth %61.6
Table d %56
Crown angle 34.7
Pavilion depth %43.2
Medium girdle , no culet
6.81-6.85x4.21
Symmetry:EX Polish: EX Cut:EX
1.5 on HCA

Color D
1.22 Depth %62.1
Table d %56
Crown angle 34.5
Pavilion depth %43
Medium girdle , no culet
6.82-6.84x4.24
Symmetry:VG Polish: EX Cut:EX
1.1 on HCA

The diamonds are so close it's hard to decide, but the 1.20 has a bit more fire. Otherwise both rings are amazing and it's hard to see anything even with a microscope.

 

[Lorelei]

Welcome

I am not a huge expert here, but I tried the Holloway Cut Adviser for you and it wouldn't work for me, how did you get it to go - maybe I entered the specs wrongly? I take it you want a D colour and this is important to you? Also what is the clarity of these diamonds and who certified them - are they GIA certs?

 

[vball]

It worked for me. Make sure it''s Crown angle, not percentage. Both stones are roughly the same on paper, and are certified.
I didn''t check the stones with an idealscope, but they look great in person anyway.

 

[Lorelei]

Ok, I will retry. If you have seen both then great, the second diamond is a little deeper, but go with your eyes mainly.

 

[vball]

Any other inputs on this? Can someone plug this into diamcalc?