Cushion Cut - Final Selection! Leon Mege vs ERD

[p2aTHX]

I am well aware that cushion cut diamonds are subjective and can't be determined by specs alone.

I am in my final hunt for a cushion cut halo. My choices are:

#1 - ERD diamond with ERD modified ADA Halo
2.07 G VS2 - Please see GIA cert attached.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kgQTgJ7Qtx4&feature=channel_video_title



#2 - Leon Mege diamond with Leon Mege custom halo setting (more handwork and detailed than ERD supposedly?)
2.09 G VS2 - Please see AGS cert
NO PHOTOS OR VIDEO YET

--------
Difference in price between the two options is negligible.

My dilemma is this - #1 is a Cushion Brilliant, not a Old Mine Cushion. I believe #2 is an Old Mine Cushion based on the specs (AGS does not have that label). Should this matter?
Winner: ????

#2 is just slightly bigger. However, I don't know if anyone has bought a diamond from Leon Mege and how they fair vs a Mark T EngagementRingDirect diamond. Mark T is known to be a cushion expert and his opinion is respected
Winner: ERD

#3 Setting - modified ERD Ada setting vs custom Leon Mage. Consensus seems to say Leon Mege for this one.
Winner: Leo Mege

There are some other factors (ERD can deliver quicker), but I am really stuck at this point. I hope to obtain photos of #2 by monday to do a side by side comparison.

 

[mrssalvo]

I posted in your other thread but wanted to give this one a bump