Allergic to all eye makeup

[Begonia]

Bloody h*ll. I was using a plain brown Lancome, and now that too is causing issues. I've worked my way through all hypoallergenic drug store brands with zero success. Any recommendations? I usually use a soft brown pencil.

 

[kenny]

... Any recommendations?

Look your natural self.

I can tell you're a wonderful person.

 

[Lookinagain]

So you are asking about eyebrow pencils? Do you know what ingredient in them that gives you issues? My eyebrows faded a lot with age and then on PS @mrs-b mentioned that she used Grande Brow serum on her brows. I ordered the trial size and it worked enough that my natural brows are darker now and I don't need to use any brow pencil. So I ordered the regular size and have continued to use it. I thought I'd mention that, in case you could use something in lieu of pencils, which give you an issue.

 

[Begonia]

Look your natural self.

I can tell you're a wonderful person.

Thanks Kenny. I needed that. Big time.

 

[Begonia]

So you are asking about eyebrow pencils? Do you know what ingredient in them that gives you issues? My eyebrows faded a lot with age and then on PS @mrs-b mentioned that she used Grande Brow serum on her brows. I ordered the trial size and it worked enough that my natural brows are darker now and I don't need to use any brow pencil. So I ordered the regular size and have continued to use it. I thought I'd mention that, in case you could use something in lieu of pencils, which give you an issue.

Eye liner , but thank you!!!

 

[Lookinagain]

Eye liner , but thank you!!!

Sorry, can't help with that....hopefully others can.

 

[Asscherhalo_lover]

Eye liner , but thank you!!!

Honestly, I don't wear it at all. My eyes have become so so so sensitive! If anything I use some shadow with a liner brush but I don't ever put anything on my water line.

 

[seaurchin]

I have tattooed-on eyeliner (also eyebrows and lipstick). Not sure how that works with allergies/sensitivities though.

 

[Begonia]

Honestly, I don't wear it at all. My eyes have become so so so sensitive! If anything I use some shadow with a liner brush but I don't ever put anything on my water line.

I can't use shadow either. Gah!

 

[Begonia]

I have tattooed-on eyeliner (also eyebrows and lipstick). Not sure how that works with allergies/sensitivities though.

Right??? I've considered that too. Tbh, if this keeps up, I'll just go au naturel.

 

[Sunstorm]

I am autoimmune and severely allergic and PMU solved the problems! I never looked back since. So glad I got the courage! I cannot stand anything around my eyes as far as products go. Ok for a special occassion but even so very hard not to smudge it all right up ny tears. There are great serums but I cannot stand those either.

 

[mrs-b]

I am autoimmune and severely allergic and PMU solved the problems! I never looked back since. So glad I got the courage! I cannot stand anything around my eyes as far as products go. Ok for a special occassion but even so very hard not to smudge it all right up ny tears. There are great serums but I cannot stand those either.

PMU? Permanent makeup? I dont suppose you'd be willing to share photos, would you? And - what color did you get and where did you get it done? I'm interested but nervous/hesitant.

 

[Ibrakeforpossums]

Example: https://www.neeyuanspermanentbeauty.com/ Friend, I asked her to do my eyebrows. She said, "Yes but you need a facelift first." The Chinese can be blunt.

 

[seaurchin]

PMU? Permanent makeup? I dont suppose you'd be willing to share photos, would you? And - what color did you get and where did you get it done? I'm interested but nervous/hesitant.

I don't want to post photos but I've had it done a few times through the years. (If you don't know, it's not really permanent and it fades with time so about every three years). Well, the lip color fades quicker. Then the brows. The eyeliner has stayed the longest.

But I'd ask to come in and look at their portfolio, if it's not online. And if it is online, check other sites and ask to be sure it's really that person's work and not "representative" photos. I'd also be sure to ask if it's photos of the work they've done or "representative." And ask how long they've been doing it. I think being careful with who you work with is everything, really. Oh, I'd also note the person's own face. Sometimes they are way too trendy for my tastes and then you're stuck with at least a shadow of huge, squared off brows, eyeliner wings or whatever. Yikes! Both of the ones I've gone to started with less/lighter and added more the next time if I wanted more.

I've had good luck (two different places) at the high end of town. )I guess only those with more experience and repeat customers can afford the higher stall rent there, IDK). Not a given of course but tends to go that way more than not imo. Both places also had a choice of people, with two price tiers according to their training and experience level. I pick the highest because I'd rather pay a couple hundred more bucks than have a less skilled person.

Eyebrows are the easiest to endure; I barely felt it. Lips are the most sensitive and eyeliner is also more to endure than eyebrows since it's so close to your eyes. So you might want to start with the brows (if you're thinking about getting the whole works). When I've gone, they only do one per session (brows, lips or eyeliner). I wouldn't want more than that anyway because after a couple of hours, I've just had enough for right then.

Then you go back a few weeks later for a touch-up.

I go in a little drugged up on pain meds etc. because it is kind of nerve wracking imo.

Good luck!

 

[Lookinagain]

PMU? Permanent makeup? I dont suppose you'd be willing to share photos, would you? And - what color did you get and where did you get it done? I'm interested but nervous/hesitant.

I'm glad you asked because I had no idea what it stood for and you figured it out before I could. No offense to those who do this, but it sounds scary to me. Whenever I get my hair cut, if it isn't exactly what I want, I always say, it's no big deal, hair grows. Not sure I'd have the same response with PMU.

 

[fussykiki]

Tattoo eyeline is a good option, but you need to figure out if you are allergic to the ink.

 

[mrs-b]

Example: https://www.neeyuanspermanentbeauty.com/ Friend, I asked her to do my eyebrows. She said, "Yes but you need a facelift first." The Chinese can be blunt.

Good lord....

 

[CMN]

Agree with @fussykiki. If you are allergic to several types of makeup I would be really nervous and hesitant about the possibility you would have a reaction to the dye. A much worse scenario given its long lasting nature.

 

[Rhd3]

Have you tried vegan brands? I stopped wearing mascara for a long time because of allergies, but I’ve found that I don’t usually react to vegan mascara (or eyeshadow).

 

[Begonia]

Have you tried vegan brands? I stopped wearing mascara for a long time because of allergies, but I’ve found that I don’t usually react to vegan mascara (or eyeshadow).

Will try some! Thank you!!

 

[maru8888777]

Clinique always gets recommended for people with sensitive skin... I don't use them, but I have allergies to lots of things and vegan mascara has also helped. Bare Minerals eyeshadow I can tolerate. I think you can line your eyes with eyeshadow dampened with a bit of water on a Q tip... sometimes people are sensitive to the bacteria that builds up on brushes.

 

[canuk-gal]

HI:

I would never tattoo my face. Ergo, my response is biased.

If , however, you are considering permanent make up--I would have a medical professional do a test Ink injection elsewhere on your body. Tolerance/reaction level , etc. Safety and risk assessment, first and always.

cheers--Sharon

 

[Demon]

Bloody h*ll. I was using a plain brown Lancome, and now that too is causing issues. I've worked my way through all hypoallergenic drug store brands with zero success. Any recommendations? I usually use a soft brown pencil.

You are really going through it right now. I really don't have any ideas on your issues, except to echo Missy, I think, on getting your PTH and calcium, as well as your vitamin D checked for the osteoporosis. I hope things start looking up for you soon!

 

[Begonia]

You are really going through it right now. I really don't have any ideas on your issues, except to echo Missy, I think, on getting your PTH and calcium, as well as your vitamin D checked for the osteoporosis. I hope things start looking up for you soon!

Thank you. I'm trying to do a deep dive on osteoporosis (a bit late I guess) so I know what to ask. I'll push for more testing once I'm feeling competent

 

[Betty Baguette]

Skin allergies...ugh

Here's something on metal allergies and eyeliner/shadow and tattoos.

Allergic to Metals? 6 Surprising Places They May Lurk

Find out what to watch for and what to avoid

health.clevelandclinic.org

 

[vintageinjune]

When I had my PMU eyeliner and eyebrows done, I was able to do a patch test to verify that I wouldn't have an allergic reaction. The aesthetician dipped a small needle in the pigment she would be using and scratched the skin behind my ears and I monitored for 5 days. That may be something offered if you wish to look in to it.

 

[mrs-b]

@Begonia -

I use Rumi, which I find excellent and is hypoallergenic.

Here's a link so you can have a look:

VolumeCare+ Mascara

Most women over 40 struggle to find the perfect mascara and the reason for that is simple: the needs of their eyelashes have changed, but they continue to use a mascara that's not suitable for them. Meet VolumeCare+ Mascara. The first mascara specifically designed for mature women with short &...

rumicosmetiques.com

 

[Begonia]

@Begonia -

I use Rumi, which I find excellent and is hypoallergenic.

Here's a link so you can have a look:

VolumeCare+ Mascara

Most women over 40 struggle to find the perfect mascara and the reason for that is simple: the needs of their eyelashes have changed, but they continue to use a mascara that's not suitable for them. Meet VolumeCare+ Mascara. The first mascara specifically designed for mature women with short &...

rumicosmetiques.com

Thank you. I'll check it out

 

[Lschneids01]

Bloody h*ll. I was using a plain brown Lancome, and now that too is causing issues. I've worked my way through all hypoallergenic drug store brands with zero success. Any recommendations? I usually use a soft brown pencil.

Hi I’ve become sensitive to all non hypoallergenic makeup now as well when I turn d 40. Especially the eye makeup. Two drug store brands that I buy that are affordable are E.L.F. Who have a great eyebrow pencil and tinted gel and eyeliner pencil. Also Almaty. I bought their mascara , eyeliner, eyeshadow, and eye primer and LOVE! Of course is Physicians Formula as well. I use their CC cream, concealer and bronzer. And setting powder. On a splurge at At Sephora I love Tarte , Tower28, and some others I can’t think of now. I can’t even wear earrings anymore unless they are hypoallergenic backings. So annoying!

 

[monarch64]

@Begonia when my mother developed alopecia, along came with it very severe allergies to makeup. In my opinion (which has no merit medically), your issues might also be intertwined