Compare diamonds included measurements

[michaell1999]

Sorry for the repost but I need to make the purchase soon. These two are almost the same price. Is one diamond better than the other?


From GIA
round modified brilliant
measurements
7.35 - 7.40 X 4.36mm
1.43 carat
depth 59.1%
Table 56%
girdle thin to medium, faceted
cutlet none
polish very good
symmetry very good
vs2
h
fluorescence medium blue
From GIA
round modified brilliant
measurements
7.45 - 7.49 x 4.53mm
1.54 carat
depth 60.6%
table 53%
girdle medium to slightly thick, faceted
cutlet none
polish excellent
symmetry excellent
SI1
I
fluorescence none
Thanks

 

[JohnQuixote]

Hi Michael. Without more details it will be hard to get much input. The minimum additional information needed to assess cut quality would be crown and pavilion angles.

In general terms the depth and finish details of the 1.54 are preferable to me, but without knowing crown and pavilion angles and/or seeing an ideal-scope image it's hard to speak as to the other qualities... Face-up color, particularly is influenced by cut quality. If your jeweler can provide a Sarin/Ogi or Helium report we can tell you more.