shape
carat
color
clarity

ATTN 'Guilty Moms''- Ignore the Time Magazine Cover

Sha

Ideal_Rock
Joined
Jun 27, 2007
Messages
2,328
http://news.yahoo.com/blogs/lookout...ing-cover-never-ask-mom-enough-185319610.html

Just sharing this interesting article on the recent Time Magazine Cover:

Ignore the Time breastfeeding cover: Never ask if you’re ‘mom enough.’ Here’s how.
By Virginia Heffernan | The Lookout – 21 hrs ago

This is a health bulletin. A sober, alarmist one. Aimed squarely at moms who feel guilty about their choices.

There is a neurotoxin that every mother must avoid. It's omnipresent. It's stealthy. And it's been found in radioactively high doses on the much-discussed breastfeeding cover of Time, which asked, "Are You Mom Enough?"

It's resentment. Avoid the story and steer clear of the poison of resentment—toxic to your brain and heart, and those of your kids.

Make whatever choices you want about breastfeeding, baby-wearing and co-sleeping (the ostensible subjects of the Time cover story). But avoid resentment, which is far more deadly to mother and child alike than lead, BPA and certainly commercial infant formula.

A woman cannot live a life or raise a child in a cloud of resentment. Resentment is life-threatening. It's enfeebling. And it's everywhere.

So when the cover story of so estimable a magazine as Time—by chronicling the lengths some women go to be responsive to their infants—issues an invitation to resentment, mothers must refuse. For their health. For their children.

Here's a handy rule for avoiding resentment: If you hate doing something, you absolutely must not do it.

This means that if you despise, in your heart of hearts, cooking or singing lullabies or breastfeeding or playing Frisbee, you are forbidden to even think of doing those things. As much as your children or your spouse or your weekly news magazine harangue you, stand your ground. If you hate it, skip it.

If you loathe watching Pixar movies or sitting criss-cross-applesauce or driving to field hockey practice or making homemade Halloween costumes or drilling SAT vocabulary or reading "Barnyard Dance" aloud—you must avoid these things. Dream up a workaround. Get your mom, dad, neighbor, wet nurse, spouse or babysitter to do them. Outsourcing is a choice you can feel good about.

The perfect opportunity to prevent resentment is at the outset. Ask yourself, "Do I hate being with children?" If the answer is yes, don't have one!

However, if the answer is, "Maybe, but I love the moral and social status associated with being a mom"—then have a kid or two, but make a lot of money first so you can hire a full-time, highly qualified concierge to keep you from spending too much time with them. You and they will be better off.

If you hate missing a moment with your kids, don't. Stay home with your children and savor the milestones and the long days. If you hate sleeping without a little body to cuddle, don't: co-sleep! If you hate anyone in your sleeping space, um, don't co-sleep. For even one night.

And if you hate breastfeeding—if it feels to you as it did to my friend Nell's grandmother, like "getting your nipple caught in a door"—for the love of everything BLOW IT OFF. Especially if you feel pressure not to blow it off—because that way resentment lies.

Get into bottle brands and enjoy the wonder of letting someone else do night feeding; and not pumping; and not seeing your baby as a mean parasite. Moms I know who have wept with misery over breastfeeding say they never felt more connected to their child, or more relaxed, than when they gave the first formula bottle.

Once you refuse, as a mom, to do the things you hate—especially the ones Dr. Sears or your friends or your mother-in-law says are non-negotiable—you open up a big beautiful space to the do the things you love as a mother. As mother to two kids, ages 6 and 2, I found out a few years ago that I hated to play catch. But I love to roughhouse. I hate to play with Legos, but I love board games. I hate to make dinner, but I love to make breakfast.

I have hated, at various times, to wake up early, to go to baby birthdays, to play soccer and to wrestle with car seats, but I loved to nurse, to go to play dates, to play in the water, to trim nails, to read and to create contests.

I wouldn't have known about my child-rearing hates and loves until I had children. And I wouldn't have discovered the danger of resentment until I took parenting advice that went against my nature—and lived to resent it. Strict religious practice and dietary restrictions sounded OK when I heard the justifications, but I wasn't listening to my heart. They were just not for me.

So now I forgo what I don't like. And I definitely don't do many of the exotic, exhausting and just weird-sounding things advocated in Dr. Sears' "Baby Book." (Take your baby to work with you if you must work in the first year?!) On the other hand, I'm all for the people who do love Dr. Sears and his advice. As long as they love doing it. My parenting pastimes sound exotic, exhausting and just weird to many people too.

Try it. No resentment. If you make child-rearing a set of practices you love, it becomes a piece of cake to love your children. That's still a cool mothering thing to do, isn't it?


I
 

Sha

Ideal_Rock
Joined
Jun 27, 2007
Messages
2,328
Thoughts? I liked what the author said about refusing to feel guilty for the choices we make as moms, but I thought her ideas about refusing to do the things we hate a bit simplistic. For most moms, I don't think things are so black/white. I hate waking up early at mornings, does that mean I SHOULDN'T do it? What about the single mom who hates cooking but has no choice to do it herself? I think the article smacks a bit of personal privilege. I think the author is probably married and can afford services like a cook or a nanny, so it's easy for her to say 'just don't do this or that'...but how many other mothers have that privilege?

I would've liked the article better if she explored the 'grey areas' a bit more.
 

Skippy123

Super_Ideal_Rock
Joined
Nov 24, 2006
Messages
24,300
I didn't read that article but I do have to say that I enjoy Dr. Sear's website for info on baby illness and a good source for questions etc. Anyway, I think some of these doctors love to breed fear too. I think as a mom you have to gather a lot of info and then decide for yourself. I found a website, I can't remember which doctor Dr. Jaye? sound right? He says he doesn't like the Rotovirus vaccine and hepatitis vaccines so I have a feeling that a lot of moms will take his thoughts into consideration and not vaccinate till way later. I couldn't give on child the rotovirus so they didn't get that vaccine (we never left the house so there was little doubt that they would get that but it could happen, we were told my our Hematologist not to get that particular vaccine).
So I think as long as you are a loving, thoughtful and informed mom then do what is best for you and your child. I will admit I had a lot of guilt for things not turning out how I wanted to have them done but at the end of the day my boys are happy and healthy and that is all that matters. :praise:
 

diamondseeker2006

Super_Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Jan 11, 2006
Messages
58,547
I agree that the article is just a bit extreme. Great...I don't like to cook or clean so I never have to do it again because she says I don't! WoooHooo!!!! Duh. Mothers make sacrifices for their children because they love them and want to do what is best for them, even if means doing some things we don't particularly enjoy.

Dr. Sears has tons of great information, but that doesn't mean you have to do everything like any book says. My daughter has really made use of his Vaccine book, though, to help educate her on vaccines rather than blindly following a schedule. Yes, she does vaccinate but some are not necessary at birth, for example.
 

Jennifer W

Brilliant_Rock
Trade
Joined
Jun 18, 2010
Messages
1,958
Ah, this pretty much sums up my take on parenting. I don't do guilt, and I don't do stuff I hate. I mean, I do stuff I don't love because it needs done, but if I really hate it? I either leave it undone or find a work around. Life's too short. I'm happy to make all kinds of sacrifices for my child, because I am a parent and that probably goes with the territory somewhere along the line, but I'm not so happy to sacrifice my complete being. I want to enjoy being a parent, and I don't want to be doing it with gritted teeth and a large helping of resentment (or even martyrdom, over all the amazing sacrifices I made).

I've never read Dr Sears, or any one else's views on child rearing. They just don't matter.

I freely admit though, I enjoy a great deal of personal privilege. I have a co-parent. We both have fairly relaxed and flexible schedules. Chances are, he's ok with doing something I don't want to do and vice versa, so we have the luxury of that job-share arrangement. We're also earning enough money to be able to afford some of the work-around solutions to things we don't want to do. While I won't apologise for that, I will absolutely recognise that it would be very different if I was a lone parent or struggling financially.

Sure, there are grey areas, but for me, the premise is actually quite sound - don't make parenting a horrible chore, don't do things that other people think you ought to and don't allow yourself to feel guilt if you can possibly help it. (This applies to me only, because I do recognise that my views on your child rearing don't matter either. ;)) )
 

partgypsy

Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Nov 7, 2004
Messages
6,628
I think that article was a little flip. I mean there are some things if you have a child, you've signed on for kind of a package deal. Even if you don't LOVE changing diapers, getting up in the middle of the night, or yes reading them a story, don't have a child.

But leave it to Americans to make something rather inherently simple (raising a child) and make it into something overly complicated.

I mean the very term "attachment parenting" I'm sorry, is stupid. So is there any normal parenting in which the parents and child do NOT form an trusting loving emotional bond? Even Dr. Sears didn't make a lot of specific rules that all parents must follow to show good parenting (though there were certainly many things that got "attached" to his name later).

:rolleyes:

If people want to do the more extreme forms of attachment parenting, then they should do it but understand they are doing it because it's their preference. I personally don't see it as being superior to "traditional" parenting.
 

NewEnglandLady

Ideal_Rock
Joined
Jul 27, 2007
Messages
6,299
I get the theme of the article and I agree. But I also agree that having a child means that some things are going to be tougher. Thems the breaks. So do I love cooking and cleaning and waking up in the middle of the night to feed my baby? No. But do I resent doing it? No. And do I particularly love Pixar movies? No, but if my kid ends up loving them and wants to watch them with me, so be it.

I guess my point is that all parents can make the choice about what their willing and not willing to do. But it's amazing how much more you're willing to do when it comes to your own kid...with no resentment at all.
 

Sha

Ideal_Rock
Joined
Jun 27, 2007
Messages
2,328
Interesting comments! Thanks for sharing!
 

partgypsy

Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Nov 7, 2004
Messages
6,628
NewEnglandLady|1337203996|3196779 said:
I get the theme of the article and I agree. But I also agree that having a child means that some things are going to be tougher. Thems the breaks. So do I love cooking and cleaning and waking up in the middle of the night to feed my baby? No. But do I resent doing it? No. And do I particularly love Pixar movies? No, but if my kid ends up loving them and wants to watch them with me, so be it.

I guess my point is that all parents can make the choice about what their willing and not willing to do. But it's amazing how much more you're willing to do when it comes to your own kid...with no resentment at all.

totally ditto! Yes I may have played more candyland and polly pockets than I care to remember, but I don't resent it. Because it's time with my child, and that makes it interesting.
 

iLander

Ideal_Rock
Joined
May 23, 2010
Messages
6,731
Oh, I ignored it right from day one. I saw the cover and my reflex was to go :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes:

I am waiting for a cover that asks "Are You Dad Enough?".

It's all sexist tripe.

I thought we got past this in the '70's. :|
 

Gypsy

Super_Ideal_Rock
Joined
Aug 8, 2005
Messages
40,225
NewEnglandLady|1337203996|3196779 said:
I get the theme of the article and I agree. But I also agree that having a child means that some things are going to be tougher. Thems the breaks. So do I love cooking and cleaning and waking up in the middle of the night to feed my baby? No. But do I resent doing it? No. And do I particularly love Pixar movies? No, but if my kid ends up loving them and wants to watch them with me, so be it.

I guess my point is that all parents can make the choice about what their willing and not willing to do. But it's amazing how much more you're willing to do when it comes to your own kid...with no resentment at all.


I think this is a great post. You can't just up and stop doing everything you hate (how many people would quit their jobs altogether and move to Hawaii to be beach bums). But there is a spectrum it's not all love or hate, there are some things you have to tolerate and accept, and not resent even though you don't love. And part of parenting is that acceptance and tolerance. But with regard to breastfeeding, as a single topic, I agree with the article.

As Circe said to me: Perfect is the Enemy of Good. You don't have to be a perfect mom, you just have to be a good mom. And while a 'perfect' mom by some standards might breast feed until puberty, a good mom can never do so and rely on formula if it suits. Nothing wrong with it, IMO.
 
Be a part of the community Get 3 HCA Results
Top