Ideal Scope Images -- which H&A do you prefer and why?

[jhe02000]

I'm curious PSers you're thoughts on these two round diamonds. Both have excellent cut and symmetry according to GIA. Both are VS2. Both have HCA scores below 2 (excellent). So they look good on paper in those respects.

Which would prefer (and why) between Diamond #1 and Diamond #2 based on the idealscope?


Thanks in advance for the opinions!

 

[smelvinwrong]

The only thing I notice is a slight leakage on #2 between the 12 and 1'o clock position. Any other info would help including dimensions and anything else

 

[Dancing Fire]

IMO, neither one is a H&A stone...any pics of the hearts?