Post by Diamond Mo » January 15th, 2006, 12:13 pm
Hi folks.  This is my first post, after lurking almost daily for more than a year.  My goal has been to learn everything I need to know to buy a quality diamond to celebrate reaching two of life''s milestones. Thanks go out to all of you PS''ers who tirelessly and freely, give your time to others. 

I have narrowed down my finalists, and will have both stones appraised by someone I learned of through this website.  Stone #1, is from a reputable, local jewelery store in business for over a century. It is pretty, but, no "WOW factor."  Reality hit.  What kind of a chump would I be for not using all of the information I have learned, just because I am nervous about an internet purchase?  Stone #2, I held my breath and called Whiteflash.  

I am soooooooo excited!  I wanted to share my experience, but any feedback would be cool. 

Stone #1:  (Jeweler represented as Ideal Cut) 

GIA report, dated September 6, 2005 

2.01 Ct.  Round Brilliant,  Represented as Ideal Cut
F/VS2
Depth:         62.1
Table:          56.1
Girdle:         MED to SLTK
Culet:           V.S  - .6% 
Crown Ang. 34.9
Pavil. Ang.   41.1
Fluor.           None 
Pol/ Sym      VG/VG  
   
Inverted Natural at, or near girdle which I just realized.  It was hard to see on copy of report,and was never discussed.  Should the jeweler have mentioned it?   

Stone #2

AGS, report dated December 15, 2005
2.164 Ct, Round Brilliant, A Cut Above, H&A

G/VS2 
Depth:           61.2%
Table:            55  on advertisement page (Sarin Rpt shows 55.7) ?
Girdle:            H to SLTK - Faceted
Culet:            .4% Pointed
Crown Ang.   34.7      
Pavil. Ang.     40.7
Pol/Sym         ID/ID
Pinpoints and a Needle

Thanks so much for any thoughts!!