Which diamond to choose

[michelles85]

Hi everyone, long story short... I lost my ring on New Years day, therefore getting a replacement stone but wanted some input.
Between these 3 IS images, is there one that's favored over the other? I am not sure how to view IS images.
Any input would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks in advance!

 

[tyty333]

Well 2 of the images are really small but from what I can see (and knowing that they are all WF stones), they all look good.

You'll need to give us cost, color/clarity etc to be able to give you any helpful info....are these all ACAs?

 

[michelles85]

that would make sense! Sorry- i'm just in such a hurry to find a replacement.

2 are ACA's and 1 is Expert Selection. All of them are I color, vs2.

1st IS image= 1.7 ct (7.8x7.82), depth 61.4, table 57, CA 34.9, PA 40.7, $15,889 (ACA)
2nd IS image= 1.8ct (7.83x7.8, depth 61.8, table 55.9, CA 34.5, PA 40.9, $15975 (Expert)
3rd IS image= 1.7 ct (7.7x7.72), depth 61.6, table 55.7, CA 34.6, PA 40.6, $14978 (ACA)

Would this info be sufficient? Thank you for your input!

 

[tyty333]

that would make sense! Sorry- i'm just in such a hurry to find a replacement.

2 are ACA's and 1 is Expert Selection. All of them are I color, vs2.

1st IS image= 1.7 ct (7.8x7.82), depth 61.4, table 57, CA 34.9, PA 40.7, $15,889 (ACA)
2nd IS image= 1.8ct (7.83x7.8, depth 61.8, table 55.9, CA 34.5, PA 40.9, $15975 (Expert)
3rd IS image= 1.7 ct (7.7x7.72), depth 61.6, table 55.7, CA 34.6, PA 40.6, $14978 (ACA)

Would this info be sufficient? Thank you for your input!

The 3rd one would probably be my choice because it is not that much smaller than the 7.8mm stones and it is about $1k less
(but I'm more money conscious than others ).

 

[michelles85]

OK i think you're right, i'm on the same page as you! I am waiting for WF to send photos of these 3 diamonds so I will see if they can hold this one for me.


Thank you so much!

 

[michelles85]

so sorry, between these 4, color wise, which appears the whitest? any suggestions?