confused about a pink stone

[Icelover]

i need help!! cant decide between two stones.
1) 3.38 carats natural fancy pink vvs2, very good cut polish and symmetry

2) 4.24 carat fancy intense orangy pink radiant vs1, very good cut, polish and symmetry again

both the stones are very similarly priced. i don't have the picture of the round with me now but i have the picture of the radiant. i like the color on both stones but which one will be a good investment type of stone is what i am thinking about.

i could really use lots of help. thanks guys !!

 

[snoopkat]

I'm no colour expert, but the orange stone looks rather brown to me. Then again, I'm very biased towards pink.

 

[stargurl78]

I voted for the pink only because I think the stone in the pic is too brown, as snoopkat stated.

 

[DearBuddha]

I agree with the previous two posts: that orange-pink is too brown-hued for my tastes. I'd go with the smaller, more pink stone.

Of course, the choice is ultimately up to you, and either way, you're going to end up with a nice stone!

 

[Enerchi]

Ditto the above posters - I'd prefer the pink sight unseen as the orange is too brown for my liking.

Can you get a photo of the pink to show us? Are there other styles in the running or definitely down to only these 2?

Very luxurious ring - which ever you go for!