Choosing between these two stones

[ready]

I actually think I've seen the new stone at another local diamond broker before (shows how much I've been looking for a diamond).

New one (unfortunately I don't have the specs in angle form, just %):

1.31C Round Brilliant
Color: G
Clarity: VS1
Measurements: 7.11 X 7.09 X 4.36 mm
Depth 61.4
Table 55.0
Crown 15.5
Pavilion 43.2
Girdle: Thin to Medium
Polish: VG
Symmetry: VG
Flourescence: None
Cutlet: None
Comments: Ideal Cut

Here's the one from yesterday that CutNut posted the results for. It is a more shallow cut giving it a bit more spread.

1.3C round
VS2
G Color
Diameter: 7.19 mm avg
Depth: 57.9%
Crown Angle: 33.8 degrees or 12.5%
Pavil Angle: 40.4 degrees or 42.5%
Table Avg. Size 62.7%
Cutlet: Very Small

Both are the same price. Whichever one I decide on will be appraised independently.

Which one looks best??? Pros/Cons? Thanks!

 

[ready]

I should say that I can clearly see the Hearts and Arrows in the first one. Wonder how the light return on it would be.

 

[pricescope]

[/u]

 

[pricescope]

You can see from GemAdviser that #2 has rather decent light return.

Keep in mind these models do not take minor facets or symmetry into account.[/u]