shape
carat
color
clarity

How to set an oval emerald?

Cabochon1

Shiny_Rock
Joined
Nov 18, 2010
Messages
112
Hello Pricescopers,

not surprisingly I am a longtime lurker :love: But this is my first post.

Instead of a ring, I was given an oval cut emerald for our engagement by my future husband. And now I am looking for a setting.

The setting will be yellow gold because it suits me better than any kind of silver colored metal and is my personal preference for emeralds anyway.

Up until sometime today I had one preference which was this one

http://www.krikawa.com/jewelry/body-of-work/details.aspx?style=23&view=3

but then I discovered McTeigue &McClelland

http://www.mc2jewels.com/gallery/McTeigue-McClelland-Bridal-Collection/8077_G

or

http://www.mc2jewels.com/gallery/McTeigue-McClelland-Bridal-Collection/8349_G

all would need to be in yellow gold.

anyway I don't know how to decide. I need your help :)

I also attach photos of the stone. It's columbian, very beautyful color, very sparkly and eyclean but impossible to photograph.

Anyway any opinions on the settings?

emerald 023.jpg

emerald 020.jpg
 

T L

Super_Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Sep 20, 2008
Messages
25,160
Beautiful stone, let me caution you that you should be very careful who sets it, as emeralds can chip easily when set. If setting in platinum, you have to be doubly careful. Emeralds look beautiful in buttery 18K YG.

Congratulations on your engagement!

Also as an e-ring, I probably wouldn't wear it every single day, as beryl is not durable enough for everyday wear. Just to caution you as I would hate to see anything happen to that gorgeous gem.

Also, I would love to know how you managed to capture the great color AND the glow in your photo. I can't get a good photo of my emeralds to save my life.

I would probably avoid bezeling it as it could chip the stone unless the jeweler is amazingly careful. I like the McTeigue rings best. However, the setting of the stone in that form of head would need to be so carefully done. I would think you would be safer with double prongs.
 

m76steve

Brilliant_Rock
Joined
Dec 21, 2008
Messages
605
tourmaline_lover|1290546887|2777110 said:
Beautiful stone, let me caution you that you should be very careful who sets it, as emeralds can chip easily when set. If setting in platinum, you have to be doubly careful. Emeralds look beautiful in buttery 18K YG.

Congratulations on your engagement!

Also as an e-ring, I probably wouldn't wear it every single day, as beryl is not durable enough for everyday wear. Just to caution you as I would hate to see anything happen to that gorgeous gem.

Also, I would love to know how you managed to capture the great color AND the glow in your photo. I can't get a good photo of my emeralds to save my life.

I would probably avoid bezeling it as it could chip the stone unless the jeweler is amazingly careful. I like the McTeigue rings best. However, the setting of the stone in that form of head would need to be so carefully done. I would think you would be safer with double prongs.
iv got some pics of similar emeralds & they photo almost as nice as cabochons' stone-u gave hime some good info but the quality of his pic is already in the stone-all u have to do is capture the image under the right light-steve...
 

Cabochon1

Shiny_Rock
Joined
Nov 18, 2010
Messages
112
thank you for your comments tourmaline_lover.

I am still not satisfied with the photos, but I am glad you like them. I have no comparison, so I don't know what you do when you photograph your stones? I just put the stone on various surfaces and either natural or artificial light and wait what the pictures looks like- more or less.

I know that the emerald is not as hard as a diamond or even ruby or sapphire so I will sometimes wear the promise ring my bf gave me a while ago. Maybe there is also the need for an extra ring :Up_to_something: in the future to protect my emerald. Who knows?

The funny thing is that the emerald dealer, the gemmologist and a goldsmith all agreed that a bezel was the best setting for an emerald as it would protect the stone. But I will not forget your advice. And yes you are right about the yellow gold, the pictures are platinum but I want yellow gold!
 

Treenbean

Brilliant_Rock
Joined
Feb 25, 2010
Messages
798
Your stone is a beauty! I love McII and that is one of my favorite settings! I think it would look lovely with an oval center stone. I have never contacted them myself, but I have heard they will customize. Budget wise, I know they are pretty pricey too, is that a factor? I love the blueberry earrings they make.

Congrats on your new stone and the engagement. :appl:
 

Cabochon1

Shiny_Rock
Joined
Nov 18, 2010
Messages
112
Thank you Treenbean. I hadn't thought about cost yet really, just looked at the setting and wanted to have it.
Money is not the only issue, I live in Europe and I don't want to ship the stone to the US to be set. Nor let them ship a setting and have the stone set by a goldsmith here. But will need to find a solution.
 

JewelFreak

Ideal_Rock
Joined
Sep 3, 2009
Messages
7,768
Lovely emerald -- you don't give your photography skills enough credit! I'm with Treenbean, love the McTeigue 2nd setting, unusual, feminine, classical & elegant. Your emerald would be gorgeous in that if you can find somebody who can set it okay.

I don't know where you are in Europe but when we lived in Amsterdam I always went to London for jewelry stuff. Styles available are so varied & there are many experienced & skilled jewelers. Wish it hadn't been so long since I was there or I'd recommend someone.

--- Laurie
 

T L

Super_Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Sep 20, 2008
Messages
25,160
Cabochon|1290554395|2777259 said:
thank you for your comments tourmaline_lover.

I am still not satisfied with the photos, but I am glad you like them. I have no comparison, so I don't know what you do when you photograph your stones? I just put the stone on various surfaces and either natural or artificial light and wait what the pictures looks like- more or less.

I know that the emerald is not as hard as a diamond or even ruby or sapphire so I will sometimes wear the promise ring my bf gave me a while ago. Maybe there is also the need for an extra ring :Up_to_something: in the future to protect my emerald. Who knows?

The funny thing is that the emerald dealer, the gemmologist and a goldsmith all agreed that a bezel was the best setting for an emerald as it would protect the stone. But I will not forget your advice. And yes you are right about the yellow gold, the pictures are platinum but I want yellow gold!

You're very welcome Cabochon.

The problem with emeralds, in particular Colombian emeralds, is that they have a multitude of surface fissures and cracks. Generally, these fissures are filled with resin or oil to mask their appearance, but if the setter isn't skilled at setting emeralds, these cracks can give way under the pressure of setting. A bezel is a very invasive way to set a stone, and although it may protect the edges in the long run, there should be extreme caution performed during the process of setting an emerald in a bezel. Oh, and make sure they NEVER EVER EVER put the finished ring in an Ultrasonic cleaner to clean it off from the residue of setting. That can make the surface cracks more evident by removing the filler. 99% of emeralds are filled, and this is an accepted practice in the trade. Another thing to consider is that If your emerald is oiled, and not treated with the more permanent and stable modern resins, it needs to be oiled every few years to retain it's beauty. Again, once set in a bezel, it would be impossible to retreat without destroying the integrity of the bezel if you have to remove the stone. Some emeralds with minor or faint treatment don't need such pampering, but I don't know the level of treatment and the type of treatment (oil or resin) in your stone. In order to properly care for the stone, if you don't know the type and level of treatment, you may want to find out.

As for your photographs, you must have a camera that loves the color green!! What camera do you own (brand and model) if you don't mind my asking. :)
 

Cabochon1

Shiny_Rock
Joined
Nov 18, 2010
Messages
112
Hello tourmaline_lover I appreciate all your comments and I am keen to learn from you. The emerald was supposedly not fracture filled before or after cutting-no treatment with opticon or permacen or other resins. It is probably slightly oiled, don't know wether this translates to minor or faint oil treatment. (My info is in German) I will inquire wether reoiling it when bezeled would be an issue. I am not really a prong fan, so hopefully it won't.

I will take care to use only an experienced goldsmith or even let this be done by a stone setter, which is an apprenticed trade/profession in Germany.

For the photos I have used a simple digital Canon EOS 20D with a canon lens Canon EF 17-85mm 1:4-5.6 IS USM.
I am not using the proprietary Canon picture format but jpg and the pictures have a size of 1.6 to 1.8MB when I download them to my computer. They look pretty ugly when seen with the Windows picture viewer - wrong colors. So to crop and save them I use the freeware Irfanview which I think handles colors better..What program do you use to crop the pics?

As you like my pictures, I'll attach two more. This is in daylight (the others were in artificial light) unfortunately cloudy weather. Haven't seen the sun in months.
One is upside down.

smaragd 014.JPG

emerald 016 upside down.jpg
 

T L

Super_Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Sep 20, 2008
Messages
25,160
Beautiful emerald and it appears to be very clean too! Do you mind me asking the stats on it (carat weight)?

No wonder you take better photos than I do, you're using a much better camera. I use a cheapo point and shoot, and I crop in paintbrush, which is very archaic, and I'm embarassed to admit it :oops: . I wish I knew as much about photography as I did about colored stones!!

I love that face down shot, you can really see the green glow to it. Very beautiful. I own six Colombian emeralds, as it is one of my favorite gems.
 

Cabochon1

Shiny_Rock
Joined
Nov 18, 2010
Messages
112
I am happy to talk about my emerald all day long ..

It's a 1.95 carat emerald and measures 10x6.8x4.7mm

I searched for photos of your emeralds and they seem to have a very beautyful and deep color. Have you ever set any of them?

Just one last artistic photo :bigsmile:

emerald 025.jpg
 

chrono

Super_Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Apr 22, 2004
Messages
38,364
If your emerald looks better than pictured, it’s a beauty! I wish I can capture even a fraction of the beauty of mine. Yours is amazingly clean, glowy and barely treated too. Congrats on the engagement and stone. McT is very pricey but I love the 2nd McT setting best. I concur with the rest that a high karat gold is best for emeralds and prong set too.
 

serenitydiamonds

Shiny_Rock
Trade
Joined
Dec 12, 2008
Messages
437
Congrats on a very beautiful crystal emerald! I would also tend to point you in the direction of a prong setting. While a bezel will prevent edges from chipping it doesn't protect emeralds where they are most vulnerable, an impact to the table. It's important you find a setter who has set a lot of emeralds, they are actually the most vulnerable when being set. Naturally the final choice is up to you.;')

--Joshua
 

Cabochon1

Shiny_Rock
Joined
Nov 18, 2010
Messages
112
Hello Joshua,

may I ask you what a 'crystal emerald' is? I tried to google this, but wasn't successful.
 

T L

Super_Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Sep 20, 2008
Messages
25,160
serenitydiamonds|1290607946|2778026 said:
Congrats on a very beautiful crystal emerald! I would also tend to point you in the direction of a prong setting. While a bezel will prevent edges from chipping it doesn't protect emeralds where they are most vulnerable, an impact to the table. It's important you find a setter who has set a lot of emeralds, they are actually the most vulnerable when being set. Naturally the final choice is up to you.;')

--Joshua

Very true. I remember the story of a lady who had a bezeled emerald, and she knocked the stone on her kitchen counter. A huge fracture appeared, so bezeling does not necessarily protect emeralds. In fact, I think the stress and pressure of a bezel tends to weaken their internal fractures, but I could be wrong.
 

Michael_E

Brilliant_Rock
Trade
Joined
Nov 19, 2003
Messages
1,290
The last two settings that you've shown are the best approach to setting an emerald. This is because the petals of the flower are extending above the edges of the stone and would help to reduce impacts to the top of the stone. Beautiful stone, it doesn't look like it has any internal fractures and so probably hasn't even been oiled. If that's the case, then this stone is as durable as any other beryl with few inclusions, (aqua, morganite, etc), and it can be treated as such, (meaning no special requirements for how it's set or cleaned).

People get all wound up about emeralds being sensitive and if they are clean with no surface reaching fractures they are definitely not sensitive and are actually fairly tough. Check in out under a microscope, oiled or filled inclusions are easy to see and if there are any, then you can start worrying about being more protective of the stone, (although that first setting you'd show with an open sided bezel is something that I wouldn't recommend for anything but a sapphire or diamond).
 

serenitydiamonds

Shiny_Rock
Trade
Joined
Dec 12, 2008
Messages
437
Cabochon|1290615860|2778147 said:
Hello Joshua,

may I ask you what a 'crystal emerald' is? I tried to google this, but wasn't successful.

Sure, a crystal emerald is a lighter tone and saturation emerald that is bright and very clean internally.

--Joshua
 

serenitydiamonds

Shiny_Rock
Trade
Joined
Dec 12, 2008
Messages
437
Michael_E|1290622280|2778265 said:
The last two settings that you've shown are the best approach to setting an emerald. This is because the petals of the flower are extending above the edges of the stone and would help to reduce impacts to the top of the stone. Beautiful stone, it doesn't look like it has any internal fractures and so probably hasn't even been oiled. If that's the case, then this stone is as durable as any other beryl with few inclusions, (aqua, morganite, etc), and it can be treated as such, (meaning no special requirements for how it's set or cleaned).

People get all wound up about emeralds being sensitive and if they are clean with no surface reaching fractures they are definitely not sensitive and are actually fairly tough. Check in out under a microscope, oiled or filled inclusions are easy to see and if there are any, then you can start worrying about being more protective of the stone, (although that first setting you'd show with an open sided bezel is something that I wouldn't recommend for anything but a sapphire or diamond).

Internal fractures will not give you an idea of the treatment level of the stone. The surface of the gem must be examined with a loupe or a microscope to check for filled surface fractures.

Because of the way an emerald is formed, even if you cannot see visible internal texture, it is quite unsafe to assume it is like another beryl and place it in an ultrasonic. Emeralds are a fairly hard material, but they are not a tough material. Only emeralds treated with modern polymers are deemed 'ultrasonic safe', but that is still discouraged.

--Joshua
 

Michael_E

Brilliant_Rock
Trade
Joined
Nov 19, 2003
Messages
1,290
serenitydiamonds|1290625525|2778318 said:
Internal fractures will not give you an idea of the treatment level of the stone. The surface of the gem must be examined with a loupe or a microscope to check for filled surface fractures.

Sure they will. Internal fractures are either filled, or are not surface reaching, in a stone that's been treated. Looking for filled surface fractures may give you a good idea of the extent of fracturing and that's always handy to check before trying to set a stone which has some obvious problems. The point here is that a stone which has no fractures is MUCH more durable than one which has fractures, filled or not.

Because of the way an emerald is formed, even if you cannot see visible internal texture, it is quite unsafe to assume it is like another beryl and place it in an ultrasonic. Emeralds are a fairly hard material, but they are not a tough material. Only emeralds treated with modern polymers are deemed 'ultrasonic safe', but that is still discouraged.

You're right Joshua, I'd never recommend that anyone put their emerald in a hot ultrasound, not even one that's "deemed safe".
 

T L

Super_Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Sep 20, 2008
Messages
25,160
Michael_E|1290622280|2778265 said:
it doesn't look like it has any internal fractures and so probably hasn't even been oiled.

It's very difficult to see internal fractures from a photo, so I would be cautious regardless. The lady that knocked her stone that I was talking about earlier in this thread had an eye clean gem, and after she banged it, one of the internal fractures appeared that had been filled with resin. These resins and polymers, as well as oils, are very good at hiding fractures. Cabochon, did you get a reputable lab report indicating the level of treatment? If faint or minor, I would probably not worry as much, but I would still exercise caution.

Here's a small article on that very very clean looking emerald that was filled with resin, and when she banged it, a huge internal crack appeared. I saw the photo of the internal fracture, but I can't find it now. Notice it was in a bezel.
http://www.ganoksin.com/borisat/nenam/emerald-case-ring.htm
 

Cabochon1

Shiny_Rock
Joined
Nov 18, 2010
Messages
112
tourmaline_lover|1290646506|2778717 said:
Michael_E|1290622280|2778265 said:
it doesn't look like it has any internal fractures and so probably hasn't even been oiled.

Cabochon, did you get a reputable lab report indicating the level of treatment? If faint or minor, I would probably not worry as much, but I would still exercise caution.

http://www.ganoksin.com/borisat/nenam/emerald-case-ring.htm

Well I bought this from a very reputable dealer here in Germany and I chose it in person from a large number of ovals that he had. This one spoke to me :love: The dealer guarantees that his stones aren't clarity enhanced or fracture filled apart from maybe oil.

Even so I have made an appointment to have it evaluated. It will be tested and microscoped. As this is only on the 29th I showed it to a small stone dealer here who said there was no indication of any treatment or fractures. The guy was really emotional about my stone when he saw and louped it and said one rarely saw such a beauty. So I am confident that the more elaborate testing will confirm this. If not, my dealer would be prepared to take the stone back.
 

Lovinggems

Ideal_Rock
Joined
Mar 28, 2009
Messages
3,622
Just want to pop in and say your emerald is gorgeous, and welcome to CS! :wavey:
 

T L

Super_Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Sep 20, 2008
Messages
25,160
Cabochon|1290675027|2778901 said:
Even so I have made an appointment to have it evaluated. It will be tested and microscoped.

Very good!! Even though I'm sure you trust your dealer, it can never hurt to verify by a second party.
 

ooo~Shiney!

Brilliant_Rock
Joined
Jun 6, 2010
Messages
1,501
Oh I LOVE Emeralds!!!!
I can hardly wait to see which setting you choose and more more more pictures!!!!
 

chrono

Super_Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Apr 22, 2004
Messages
38,364
Cabochon,
You are taking all the correct steps - trust but verify! :appl:
 

Cabochon1

Shiny_Rock
Joined
Nov 18, 2010
Messages
112
A small update. The stone is indeed an emerald of colombian origin and untreated. But I am rethinking settings :roll:

If I decide to set it North South instead of East West I could make a three stone ring but it would be much more "dressy". Well I am sure I'll come to a solution at some stage.
 

JewelFreak

Ideal_Rock
Joined
Sep 3, 2009
Messages
7,768
If your other 2 stones are harder than beryl they might provide some extra bit of protection for the emerald. But I surely do love that MC2 setting. Think I'll dream about using it for something myself! With so many beautiful choices, it's a tough decision to make, isn't it? Good luck -- want to see what you decide on..

--- Laurie
 

canuk-gal

Super_Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Apr 19, 2004
Messages
25,649
HI:

Stunning, simply stunning! Leon Mege has some wonderful oval settings....

cheers--Sharon
 

Pandora II

Ideal_Rock
Joined
Aug 3, 2006
Messages
9,613
Something similar to Harriet's amazing tsavorite setting design that LM made for her could work well with a N/S oval.
 

LD

Super_Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Jun 29, 2008
Messages
10,261
If you're setting it N/S (and I think it would look gorgeous), I would be tempted to have a very classical 3 stone setting with a white oval diamond on each side. :love: Personally I'd set it in Platinum but Emeralds look equally at home in white or yellow coloured metals.
 
Be a part of the community Get 3 HCA Results
Top