ASET VS Idealscope: Conflicting message?

[martell]

Hey guys,

I have two images here of the same diamond. One is the Idealscope image and the other is the ASET. I know Gary has been saying that there is no need for an Aset when you have an Idealscope. However, from what I see here, there seems to be some discrepancy. In the table on the idealscope image, there appears to be some leakage. When viewing with the ASET, I get a red in the table. I would have been expecting some green to show up in the ASET image? Are one of these images poorly taken? Looking forward to the expert''s response.

I also notice that WF has some of the best ASET and IS images around. Are these photoshoped?

Thanks!

 

[yssie]

IS?

aset looks good, but only IS is needed for rounds - aset is a much better tool for fancies

 

[martell]

The idealscope

 

[yssie]

Do you have a regular pic?

 

[yssie]

In any case, looks like slight leakage under the table that you're not going to see IRL because people see with two eyes, not just the one.


Also looks like they dialed up the saturation/contrast on the ASET</?

 

[martell]

actual

 

[CharmyPoo]

These pictures really need work. Sorry I am no help