Out Of These Two Round Diamonds, Which Is Better And Why?

[Asscher102]

Hi! Given only the information on these two round diamonds, listed below, which one is better and why?
I'm thinking Diamond # 2.

Thank you!

P.S. On a diamond between .55 and .65, what depth/table should I be looking for to make it appear the largest?

 

[Lorelei]

Can you post the crown and pavilion angles please?

 

[Asscher102]

Hi Lorelei! I would but they weren''t listed for either diamond :-/ I pretty much have to go only by the info listed.

 

[Lorelei]

Hiya assch!

If these diamonds are from where I think they are from ( assuming each are from the same vendor), click on the GIA reports then that should bring the angles up on the diagram to the right.

 

[Asscher102]

Lorelei, thank you so much! I never knew that I re-did the picture for you below with the crown angle and pavillion angle for each.

 

[Lorelei]

LOL!! You are most welcome and thanks for the info!

Ok they both look good, maybe you are leaning towards the slightly larger stone? Next step would be to check carefully if either of these diamonds are eyeclean to your standards then go from there. Make sure you tell the rep what your expectations are concerning '' eyecleanliness'' so you are both on the same page.

 

[Asscher102]

Hi Lorelei! How are you? I actually have an update. I made a new post with the now 3 official diamonds that I am choosing between and I would really love your opinion

The link is https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/ecstatic-about-choosing-my-e-ring-diamond-and-would-love-your-opinions-please-on-which-diamond-to-pi.100273/

Thank you so much! Ttys.