We found our justice of the peace by simply doing a google search. Most of them seemed like they were pretty run-of-the-mill, no difference, just do the job and be on their way, which isn't what we wanted. I eventually found a lady who fit our bill though, and we met with her and absolutely are thrilled that she will be marrying us. I knew the second we found her that she would be perfect, I guess it just depends on what you are looking for.
We knew we wanted someone we knew to perform our wedding. My sister and I aren''t close, so I didn''t want to make her a BM, but she was perfect for the officiant role, which is more important anyway!
For a more ''professional'' approach, I''d check your local knot recommendations.
One of the photographers we interviewed recommended her. DH and I are not religious at all and it was very important to us that we had a ceremony that was meaningful to us with no religious undertones. She was great! She respected our opinions and values and, even though they weren''t necessarily hers, wrote up a beautiful ceremony that was perfect for us.
Talk to your vendors - they''ve done lots of weddings and probably have tons of recommendations. You certainly don''t have to use them but it''s a great place to start.
Our venue had a list of JPs, but they recommended one specific person on that list. We met her and instantly clicked with her. We were very happy that she''d be performing our ceremony. A few months before our wedding, she had to back out and she recommended another woman to us. We used this person, and while she was good, we really wished that our original JP could have been there.
It just seems so confusing as they all say the same things on their websites! I have actually made contact with a woman who I found some recommendations for on a different forum. We will be meeting sometime next week and if we like her we will book her and be done with it. I just don''t want to waste a huge amount of time vetting people.