Your opinion please...

[Cade1]

Hi again, I just love it that many of your know so much about diamonds!! Could you please give me your input on these 2 EGL radiant cut diamonds. They both look great in the pictures but which do you think is the better diamond?

Diamond #1 - 1.00CT
5.18 x 5.12 x 4.18
Depth: 81.6%
Table: 75%
Crown: 8.6%
Girdle: Medium to ex. thick polished
Polish: VG
Symmetry: G
Clarity: VS1
Color Grade: I

Diamond #2 - 1.04CT
5.69x 5.37 x 3.98
Depth: 74%
Table: 74%
Crown: 9%
Girdle: sl. thick polished
Polish: VG
Symmetry: G
Clarity: VVS2
Color Grade: H

Thank you so much for all you input!

 

[alexah]

I'm by no means a radiant expert, but those sound rather deep (esp #1) & the crowns are low...

have you looked at the AGA chart for radiants so you have some guidelines as to what to look for? LINK - on the left side, click on AGA cut grade chart & choose radiant from the dropdown