Which one would you select?

[dgirl]

Hello All,

I had already selected my diamond a 1.16 GVS2 ACA diamond, but then I saw a 1.51 J VS1 ACA diamond. I dont know if I should go with bigger or go with whiter. I have read all these threads about how J''s are pretty white, might have a tint of yellow. So, which one would you go with?

Thank you

 

[angeline]

You know I really don''t think you will know what *you* like until you see it yourself in person and in different lighting situations. I have had stones from WF ranging from E to I and turns out I am color sensitive even though I didn''t think I would be. (either that or it''s just a mind thing) Either way I wasn''t happy till I got a colorless.

WF have a good return policy, you''re only out the shipping. I would get the J and see what you think in person.

my .02

a

 

[bae7]

I was trying to decide between a D and an H. The jeweler mixed them up, set them in front of me, and told me to find the D. I couldn''t tell a difference and actually guessed the H!! So, obviously I am not sensitive to the color. My original ering is a J and I was shocked. It looks pretty white to me. I think the bigger stone is definately worth a look. Good luck!