Which one would you choose: Got the Sarin reports

[avacado]

Same question as before. Two princess cut stone. My budget (including setting is under $5000). Only this time Ive got the Sarin reports

Diamond 1(Princess cut): Price:$4,680
GIA report for Diamond 1 Sarin report for diamond 1
1.24-Carat Wt 1.246ct
Clarity: SI1 Total Depth 70.7% 4.17mm
Color: I Crown Angle 43.4 (42.2-44.5)
Depth/Table: 71.8/69 Crown height 13.0% (12.5-13.5)
Polish: EX Pavil angle 58.1(57.2-58.9)
Symmetry: G Pavil Depth 54.0% (53.3-54.9)
Fluorescence: None Table Size 69.9%(69.8-70.1) 4.16mm
Measurements: 5.89 x 5.82 x 4.18 mm Width/Length: 5.90-6.00; L/W:1.02
Girdle Thickness 3.6% (3.2-3.


Diamond 2(Princess cut): Price:$3,758
GIA report for Diamond 2 Sarin report for diamond 2
1.15-Carat Wt 1.15ct
Clarity: SI2 Total Depth 71.2% 4.05mm
Color: H Crown Angle 37.3"
Depth/Table: 71.3/70 Pavil:Crown height 56.6% :9.7%
Polish: VG Pavil angle 39.5
Symmetry: VG
Fluorescence: Faint Table Size 72.7%, 4.14mm
Measurements: 5.93 x 5.68 x 4.05 mm Width/Length: 6.02-5.69; L/W:1.06
Girdle Thickness 4.8% (3.9-7.1)

 

[mrssalvo]

Hi avacado. I can''t really help you with princess cuts, sorry

but wanted to give you a bump in case some of our resident princess experts are around. there aren''t as many of them as there are for rounds so be patient and hopefully someone will jump in with some guidence. have you seen these stones? i would be very nervous to go down to a SI1-SI2 in a princess but if you''ve seen them or the vendors seen them and says they are eye clean you might be ok. hopefully someone else will chime in

 

[Kaleigh]

Hopefully belle or researcher will chime in and help you out. Good luck!!!

 

[avacado]

Thanks for your replies mrsalvo and kaleigh. Havent seen the diamonds myself but the vendor says that the rocks are eyeclean.

Belle, researcher or any other expert could you chime in...... Im dont know how to begin comparing the Sarin reports

 

[JulieN]

I like the angles on stone 2, but I don''t like that it''s sort of rectangular, as well as that spot where the girdle is so big. How does such a girdle like that happen? There''s also a pretty big difference between 6.02x5.69 and 5.93x5.68, and table of 70 vs 72.7 is a big difference. Calibration needed?

Two different vendors, right? Sarin formats are different.

Get Ideal Scopes.

 

[belle]

i would lean towards #1 it looks better on average. it would be GREAT if you could get idealscope images. if not, i would still take my chance with #1.

best of luck avacado. i know how difficult the decision of picking a diamond can be!