Which of these Princess cuts is most desireable?

[niceguymr]

Which of these do you think is most desireable?

Depth Table Girdle Cul Sym Pol Flr Measurements

1.51 G SI1 75% 67% GIA m-tk no gd ex no 6.22x6.08x4.56

1.51 G SI1 74% 72% GIA thn-med no gd ex no 6.21x6.16x4.56


On one hand, I''m thinking the first one b/c of the Table percentage

On the other hand, the second has a better length/width ratio.

I''m not really sure which of the girdles is most desireable for a Princess Cut.

So which would you rather have most?

 

[niceguymr]

Bump for the night crew

 

[Capitol Bill]

Unfortunately you cannot tell much from these kinds of numbers when it comes to a princess cut. The only sure way to know is to see it in person. Barring that, at the very least you should try to get a photo. In my experience the only thing close to a "sure thing" in a princess cut is an AGS-0, but even then each stone has a touch of its own personality.

Best of luck!
Bill Scherlag

 

[Elliot]

I would say price is a key factor. The second stone looks better but it really depends on the price.