Which idealscope image is better?

[dancinbaby]

Here are two different stones I am considering. About 1/10 ct. difference. Price and HCA score is almost the same, too. I feel like the idealscope image will make the deciding factor. Which would you choose?

1) G: VS2 - there seems to be more red color....but pale HCA: 1.7 TIC

2) D SI1: Darker arrows, but leakage at the edges??? HCA: 1.5 TIC

THANKS! DB

 

[strmrdr]

both are awesome.
one is a classic aca the other a new line aca.
They are cut slighly differently thats why they look different.

 

[cushioncut]

I think #2 is better... I like the dark arrows.

 

[headlight]

I think you are splitting hairs...

 

[Garry H (Cut Nut)]

I agree.
The first one will have a little less contrast / hard edged brilliance.
But it will probably show more obvious fire and amy appear a little larger for its weight.