shape
carat
color
clarity

What time of day for Thanksgiving dinner?

Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.

Ara Ann

Brilliant_Rock
Joined
Jan 5, 2009
Messages
1,204
This may turn into a MIL vent, sorry in advance if it does.

What time does your family have Thanksgiving dinner?

It''s usually not a conflict, but it is this year for us!


I came from a large family, with in-laws, etc. and my mother made her annual huge Thanksgiving dinner and we ate early in order to accommodate the other families as well, so everyone could see their extended families too. I personally prefer to have an early meal too, just because if I eat a large meal later in the day, I don''t sleep well, etc. And typically DH has to work the next day, so early is better all the way around.

So. Last year I had T-day dinner at our house, my MIL had surgery on her foot and couldn''t have dinner at her house. I had it early, since our guests had a long drive and didn''t want to be out too late, etc. When planning a party, I try to accommodate my guests as well and try to be flexible, like my mom taught me.

This year it''s at my MIL''s again and she''s having dinner at 5. Not too much of a biggie, but our oldest son''s GF/fiance''s mother is also having T-day dinner at her house and the kids want to visit both homes and his GF is supposed to help her mother with their dinner as well.

So I called my MIL to ask if she could have her dinner start a little earlier so the kids could visit both places....BTW, drive time is about 45 mins. from place to place, her mother lives near our house, my MIL is about 45 mins. away, so it''s a bit of travel time involved too.

Well, my MIL won''t budge on her timing. I told her that''s kind of late for us (DH has to work Friday), and explained about the kids wanting to do both places, etc., but she won''t change it by a minute.

Yes, our son could come with us alone and go to GF''s house later in the evening, which is what will probably end up happening, but I am just irritated that my MIL won''t even try to compromise.

Yes, I get it that she''s the hostess and can set the time of the dinner, but ALL of the others are retirees! The timing doesn''t matter to any of them either way, ya know?

My son''s GF is very important to us and our family...for reasons I won''t get into, she has been very close to us as well (she had family issues and sees us as her family)...she is trying to build a stronger bond with her mother though, which is good, and which is why it''s important for her to be with her mom this holiday too. But she really wants to see both families too! And our son wants to be there for/with her at her mom''s as well.

Honestly, I''d rather have dinner at my house again and not have to deal with this timing stuff.

Arrgh. Vent over.


So, how do you work out ''fair time'' within your families?


And I do plan to have a nice dinner this weekend, with just the 5 of us...but I''m still irritated!
 
This one is a toughie. We usually try to work out holidays as fairly as possible. Since our families live pretty close, we usually split the day up. Afternoon at my families, evening at Dhs. Seems to work pretty good, although we are very tired at the end of the day. However, before we had a system worked out, both families used to have t-day at the same time. We simply had to tell them it would be 1 family this year, 1 family the next, well mil hated that idea
2.gif
, so she switched her dinners to later. If I was doing Thanksgiving at MY house, we would eat at 2. Perfect timing to eat, watch a couple flicks, drink some vino, and munch through the day
3.gif
, but that will have to be later. Pretty sure my mom and mil dont want to step down from hosting just yet. Someday.. ETA- just reread your post, I think if my Dhs gma was unwilling to accommodate our schedule on tday ( if we had graciously done so for her the previous year) in order to be fair with MY family, we would buy a nice card to send and respectfully decline.
 
Umm...yeah, my MIL won''t budge on her timing but she will pout and complain if...

1. We don''t stay late after dinner

and

2. If my son would choose to go with his GF to her mother''s instead. I''d never hear the end of it.

And my parents live in Florida during the Fall and Winter, so we only see DH''s family most holidays as it is! My siblings each do their own thing for T-day, we only get together Christmas morning at my sister''s house.

I think my MIL would spit mud if we chose to see any of MY family instead for T-day!
 
What is going to happen when you son gets married? Is his grandma going to throw a hissy fit when he needs to split time with the in laws? Sounds pretty selfish to me IMHO, 1 family is not more important than the other. It sounds like you are not too excited for thanksgiving, AraAnn
7.gif
, Ifeel bad for you. This is supposed to be the time that you get to be around people you love, not people that make you miserable. Would it be possible to host at your home so everyone can be invited and all see each other? Including the gf mom? I know I would be ticked off if my Dhs family expected me to spend all day with them, and none with mine. Just would not work for us.
 
Ugh. Yep, MIL is certainly not used to sharing family time...since my parents have been commuting to FL since DH an I got married, she never had to ''share'', so this is a new concept to her, LOL!

And I offered to host T-Day again, but she insists on having it this year. She likes to have all the holiday parties at her house, to carry on ''her'' mother''s tradition of ''going to grandma''s'' every holiday. But our sons are older now and there are no other kids at around at all...just our sons, son''s GF, DH and I and the rest are senior citizens/great grandparents! We LOVE them all dearly and enjoy their company, but yeah, not too pleased with my MIL this holiday.


Son''s GF lost her father earlier this year...she has a younger brother too and wants to be there for him especially...and my son wants to be there for them too. he''s like a big brother to her brother...so it''s not ''just our family'' anymore and my MIL needs to get a clue about that!

And son''s GF''s mother isn''t a peach to work with either...she''s stubborn too. I am hoping she''ll hold her dinner early, then the kids can come to MIL''s later, but they will be FULL, LOL!

We will do a ''family thing'' over the weekend, but it won''t make ''the day'' any less stressful!

Already dreading Christmas too
20.gif
 
I think 2-4 is standard. I prefer earlier so we''re not too wiped out since these things drag on!
 
My family did something years ago that has made splitting Thanksgiving sooo much easier, we to it to Saturday
2.gif
. It started when my mom went back to work and had to work the Friday after Thanksgiving (Grandma''s house is 4 hours from my mom, 8 hours from me), and we''ve just kept it that way. Grandma plans dinner to be around 4pm, but it''s usually 5 by the time everything is ready. DH''s dad''s side of the family does a big thing around 2pm or 3pm on Thanksgiving, and then we used to have to drive 30 minutes from there to DH''s mom''s side for another dinner at 7pm.

I know it''s her meal and all, but if she wants to spend more time with you guys she''ll have to be a bit more flexible. Just do what you/your son need to to fit it all in, and if she feels slighted, maybe she''ll do it earlier next year.
 
See? I''d LOVE to do something like that, move it to another day too...but my MIL would NEVER do that for us, "it''s just not done!" I am totally going to be very flexible with my kids and their future families! I''d gladly have it another day, which is what we are already planning so we can have ''us time'' and RELAX!

Even my son''s GF''s extended family has theri Christmas the weekend before the 25th! They have a big family too! But GF''s mother had a FIT last year, when GF wanted to do our families activities last Christmas Day, even though they already HAD theirs! So even that ''alternative date'' celebration idea doesn''t always work out!!!

HELP!
23.gif
 
I like Thanksgiving Dinner to be at DINNER time. So between 5-7pm. It just seems wrong to me to have it at lunchtime but I know for some that is THE time to have it so they can have leftovers right away. I am not going to poop on someone''s party plans if they have it early, but it feels wrong lol
 
ours will be around 2-3pm since we will have a large breakfast and skip lunch (so supper time?) then everyone can still gnaw on the leftovers throught the evening
 
I''m stubborn sometimes and in your situation I might just say - well we''re having it somewhere else and we''ll be back to your house for pie later.
 
My parents are divorced (Mom is re-married) so lots of family stuff.
Everyone worked together to schedule so people could spend as much time as possible with each of their families.


Our craziest year:

Thanksgiving-Eve at paternal gradparents (around 7pm)
Thanksgiving morning at step fathers parents (around 10am)
Thanksgiving lunch at maternal grandparents (around 2)
Thanksgiving dinner with fathers family (around 6)


We did run into time conflicts some years even though people tried to keep them at different times. Those years we tried to alternate. Depending on other circumstances. (health of family members, etc.)
 
Date: 11/16/2009 3:42:59 PM
Author: Cehrabehra
I like Thanksgiving Dinner to be at DINNER time. So between 5-7pm. It just seems wrong to me to have it at lunchtime but I know for some that is THE time to have it so they can have leftovers right away. I am not going to poop on someone''s party plans if they have it early, but it feels wrong lol
LOL, me too. We have dinner at 5 or 6 on holidays (we eat much later on regular work nights). Of course, we do not live near any family, so anyone who travels to join us for Thanksgiving is only eating with us. I would be more flexible about the time if I knew someone also needed to go to another family dinner the same day.
 
I just want to also add that since we have lived so far from family most of our married life, I have been the one cooking. I think in 19 thanksgivings as married folk, we have had maybe 5 or 6 at someone else''s house and I just go with the flow when I do.

If I had family all in one town who were fighting over me I would accommodate the most accommodating person and let the person or group that was most demanding suffer. Maybe I''m mean like that, but I HATE HATE HATE to indulge poor behavior!
 
I think I''ll tell the kids to start off at GF''s mother''s house, if it starts any earlier than my MIL''s meal...then they can come over later for dessert. If my MIL is upset, she''ll only have herself to blame and maybe she''ll remember for the next time she insists on having a holiday dinner at her house! (she''ll still complain about it though!)

Since we''ll be having our own turkey dinner that weekend, at our house, we''ll have ''our'' family time with the kids too. It won''t be the same, but I can''t tell them to split up between their families this year, since it''s probably going to be a rough one for his GF and her brother.


And a side note...

My nephew got married last year and his new bride went to her family''s house for Christmas brunch, instead of doing our ''one day only get together party'' with all the cousins, etc. - her family does things for Christmas both days (Eve and Day). I just thought it strange that she''d opt out of her new husband''s only family get together to see her family, when she sees them all the time. Oh well, that''s their thing, I just thought it odd.
 
Cehrabehra- I like your style.
2.gif
 
2-4 seems about right for us. Your MIL needs to bend a little. I mean what is the harm doing it a tad earlier, thus making everyone happy.. I know when my kids get married, I will do what ever they want. I won''t be that stubborn MIL... Trust me..
3.gif
 
We only celebrate with DH''s side so we figure out the best time when everyone is off from work. Well, the last few years, a couple of the family members have had to work and as a result some haven''t shown up. This year, instead of hosting like we normally do, we''re going out of town. Only half the family is coming. What can we do about it? I know some people love tradition, but it gets so old hosting at hour house year after year. Plus every year we seem to be in a new home so we have to give the tour again and try and justify why where we live now is better than the last home.

Anyway, with holidays, you cannot please everyone. Figure out the way to make your thanksgiving best *for you* and try not to hurt feelings. If you have to pick between people, pick the ones you like better!
1.gif
 
Between 2 and 3 pm. Lots of time to eat and enough time for the guys to take a nap afterwards.
 
Date: 11/16/2009 5:36:59 PM
Author: Kaleigh
2-4 seems about right for us. Your MIL needs to bend a little. I mean what is the harm doing it a tad earlier, thus making everyone happy.. I know when my kids get married, I will do what ever they want. I won't be that stubborn MIL... Trust me..
3.gif


Me neither Kaleigh! I told my boys to give me the smackdown if I get out of line as a MIL, LOL! Well, respectfully that is.
2.gif
DH and I already agreed, if we have to do our holidays on a different date to make everyone happy, we will! The DATE doesn't matter, the PEOPLE do!


After speaking with our son again, I think we are going to go to MIL's for dinner, at 5 as a family (GF will go to her mom's), but we will leave early and take our son over to GF's house for dessert.

It doesn't make sense to me to have our son's GF drive 45 mins. to MIL's house after dinner at her mom's, then drive all the way back to our town to go home again.

This way MIL will get the message loud and clear, we can't stay long after dinner and it's HER inflexible attitude that chased us off early! This plan also gets DH home early enough too.

The main reason we will go to her house at all and not bail altogether, is DH has both of his grandmas! They are 91 and 94! We won't have them much longer and they are both very dear to all of us...I'd never forgive myself if we bailed out on Thanksgiving, over a few hours, if it was the last one we'd have with them.

Someday things will be different, heck, maybe we'll go to MY sister's house one year! For now I'll have to suck it up!
20.gif
 
My family usually has our Thanksgiving meal called for sometime between 2 and 3, and it''s for the exact reason you mentioned--so people could split the holiday.

DH''s family usually calls the meal for 5:30, which worked really well in the past when we had to go to both meals.

Now, this year my mom is hosting Thanksgiving for DH''s entire family, and they''re already grumbling that it is starting too early and it''s not the way they''ve always done it. My mom feels like she should move the time back but I think she should keep it as is, at 3 PM. Nobody in DH''s family wants to host, which is why my mother is hosting all of them.

ANYWAY, I suppose I just shared all that to say that I understand your frustration.

Did you already ask your son''s GF if her mother would consider changing the time of their meal? Did she say no, too?
 
You''re really asking your MIL to change her dinner time for a GF? I get that you think of her as "family" but the reality is, she isn''t even officially a FI yet. I''m sorry but if I''m cooking, I''m deciding when the meal is. People can show up or not. I wouldn''t complain if anyone couldn''t make it, or left early, but that''s just how I roll.

FWIW, I usually served sometime around 2ish but that''s just because I get hungry and I don''t want to have a lunch, and then start cooking a big meal for dinner
1.gif


Anyway, I think it''s best for guests to decide if they can attend or not - not ask someone to change what they are doing when they are doing the work.
 
Yep, I wouldn't even consider asking someone to change their dinner schedule for a GF or BF no matter how much I liked them.

I also like dinner to be at dinner time but I understand people with digestion concerns.

This year our Thanksgiving dinner has been pushed to 1pm. Way too early for me. It'll feel like breakfast! But I am a guest and wouldn't think of suggesting a change. My SIL is doing the cooking and like a good guest I will be on time, offer to help, and no grumbling about the time. I CAN move very slowly when setting the table or chopping onions and hope that the bird doesn't get on the table until 2pm!
 
We do Thanksgiving with my husband''s family because mine live out state. We used to have it around 2pm, but now we have it at lunch time because my brother-in-law recently married and her family is in-state, too and they are divorced, so they have lunch with her dad''s family, then come to our gathering, then go to her mother''s house for another meal around dinner time. By the time they finish at her dad''s, they''re not really hungry anymore and they graze and talk more than anything....

I think it''s great to spend time with all family members for the holidays, but at some point, it gets to be too much. I doubt they''ll drag around from house to house once they have little ones in tow. But you never know...
 
Ara Ann, I think your compromise idea is perfect! Just brace yourself for the guilt and dragging on of things...
5.gif
 
thankfully my inlaws have theirs at the same time my family did and the foods are all about the same and they never ever get pissy if we''re there or not - we''re always welcome but never expected. My mom''s family is different, my mom''s been gone for 10 years now and when her sisters found out I''d be here in oregon they changed the venue to accommodate (very nice) but then got kinda pissy when I said I couldn''t stay for 5 days. Experience tells me 2 days is plenty lol Plus with the upcoming move that''s one of the few weekends we have left and our to-do list is insanely long. They understand, sort of, but my cousin didn''t hesitate to let me know, "they''re doing all of this for you" (guilt guilt guilt) well, I''m sorry - I''m glad I can come but let''s not make this about me :P

On another note, christmas this year will be WEIRD. 18 christmases spent at home, our tree, our traditional meal... when my mom was alive she always came to OUR house for christmas and christmas eve was christmas eve - but christmas day - THAT was CHRISTMAS! Presents, brunch, a big lovely dinner (prime rib, yorkshire pudding etc.). My husband''s family has their big meal on christmas eve and unwraps gifts christmas eve and does NOTHING on christmas day. Nothing. So way early in our marriage we compromised and decided okay... christmas dinner will be christmas eve but gifts will be christmas morning followed by brunch and in late afternoon french dips. yes, a compromise but we think a good one. And this year... married christmas #19... we''ll be at the inlaws for the first time. I''m really glad to see them (known them since I was 5) and I love them to death, but I only like turkey once a year and am going to seriously miss the usual and am going to have a hard time opening gifts at 11pm or midnight or whatever instead of in the morning. I''m actually kinda dreading it. Not dreading the people, just missing christmas... it''s bad enough I won''t have a home to decorate, I won''t see my ornaments, it''s going to feel like the year there wasn''t a christmas. And if those inlaws get my kids anything bigger than a deck of cards we''ll have to leave it behind... we just don''t have space in the luggage!!!
 
Date: 11/16/2009 2:50:51 PM
Author: janinegirly
I think 2-4 is standard. I prefer earlier so we''re not too wiped out since these things drag on!
Ditto. I''ve never had a Thanksgiving dinner that started later than 4 pm.
 
It''s just my husband and me for every holiday, and we eat between 3:30 and 4:00. Really it''s whatever time I get everything ready.
 
Date: 11/16/2009 10:13:14 PM
Author: purrfectpear
You''re really asking your MIL to change her dinner time for a GF? I get that you think of her as ''family'' but the reality is, she isn''t even officially a FI yet. I''m sorry but if I''m cooking, I''m deciding when the meal is. People can show up or not. I wouldn''t complain if anyone couldn''t make it, or left early, but that''s just how I roll.


FWIW, I usually served sometime around 2ish but that''s just because I get hungry and I don''t want to have a lunch, and then start cooking a big meal for dinner
1.gif



Anyway, I think it''s best for guests to decide if they can attend or not - not ask someone to change what they are doing when they are doing the work.


I understand your POV PP, but I guess I expect family to be more flexible if they are able to. This is ''family'', not dinner a friend''s house...again, my mother was very flexible and tried her best to make things easy for everyone and she had a huge crowd to cook for. And yes, I have personally changed my schedule, when entertaining, to better accommodate my guests...IMO, entertaining is not about the hostess, it is about the guests.

This is something my MIL could do, but just won''t do. So we will do what we have to do as well.

And if my MIL wants to stick to her guns about dinner time, that is fine, we''ll deal with that, however, then she doesn''t also then have the right to complain about us leaving early, which she WILL. She can''t have it both ways, but she wants to.
20.gif


And son and GF are ''pre-engaged'' - meaning they are planning to marry, but don''t have an official date set, etc., so she is already an acknowledged and accepted part of our family. She''s not just some random GF off the street he met a month ago...I would not ask my MIL to make changes based on that kind of situation.

It will work out I suppose...just not looking forward to the drama and indigestion following dinner!
2.gif
 
Whatever happens, I''d try to figure out who''s going to have the better desserts and make sure to finish the day at that party.
11.gif
 
Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top