What do you think? Round Brilliant

[njseeker]

Please give me some opinions on these three and a rating of a 1 to 10 on all of them if you can...

1. (H VS1 1.72):
http://www.goodoldgold.com/diamond/4337/


2. (G VS2 1.71):
http://www.goodoldgold.com/diamond/4867/


3. (G VS2 1.70)
http://www.goodoldgold.com/diamond/4317/

 

[Ellen]

Hi nj,

I don''t know that I can rate them 1-10, but I can list in the order of preference.


1. 1.71 G VS2

2. 1.72 H VS1

3. 1.70 G VS2

They are all nice stones, but I like all the numbers on the first one best. Hope this helps!


p.s. You might reserve these while you''re thinking. One could get snatched out from under you if you don''t.

 

[:)]

If you are near GOG, perhaps you could take a quick trip over to compare all 3 in person? If not, call Jonathan and ask him to compare them side by side for you and tell you what he thinks - he may even be able to send you a video.

the 1.72 h vs1 is 18,782
the 1.71 g vs2 is 20,238
the 1.70 g vs2 is 20,400 - has a small premium for being a canadian diamond.

The diameters on all are approximately the same.

GIA rounds their #s, but the pics look ok on the 1.71 (it falls into gia ex but not ags ideal category)

The slightly shorter LGF on the canadian one will give you a bit broader flashes of light.

If your budget is willing,
I lean towards the 1.71 g vs2 (like the actual pics slightly more than the canadian one),
then the 1.7 g vs2 canadian
the final is the h vs1 for me.

 

[Lorelei]

Date: 1/14/2009 6:43:20 PM

Hi nj,

I don't know that I can rate them 1-10, but I can list in the order of preference.

1. 1.71 G VS2

2. 1.72 H VS1

3. 1.70 G VS2

They are all nice stones, but I like all the numbers on the first one best. Hope this helps!

p.s. You might reserve these while you're thinking. One could get snatched out from under you if you don't.

Ditto, they are all lovely diamonds.