Just curious, why would you WANT a c-section if it is not medically necessary? It is major surgery and hard to recover from while caring for a newborn. I certainly wouldn''t have chosen a c-section if I had a choice.Date: 1/8/2009 12:43:11 PM
Author:Peepa
Anyone here have a doctor in the south bay who was happy to oblige to wanting a scheduled c-section? Any referrals?
With all due respect Steph, Peepa didn''t ask if she should have one or not. People have their reasons for wanting scheduled c-sections and I would hope the decision is made after doing their homework.Date: 1/8/2009 12:45:24 PM
Author: steph72276
Just curious, why would you WANT a c-section if it is not medically necessary? It is major surgery and hard to recover from while caring for a newborn. I certainly wouldn''t have chosen a c-section if I had a choice.Date: 1/8/2009 12:43:11 PM
Author:Peepa
Anyone here have a doctor in the south bay who was happy to oblige to wanting a scheduled c-section? Any referrals?
Norcal and thanks, I do have my reasons.Date: 1/8/2009 12:49:48 PM
Author: TravelingGal
With all due respect Steph, Peepa didn''t ask if she should have one or not. People have their reasons for wanting scheduled c-sections and I would hope the decision is made after doing their homework.Date: 1/8/2009 12:45:24 PM
Author: steph72276
Just curious, why would you WANT a c-section if it is not medically necessary? It is major surgery and hard to recover from while caring for a newborn. I certainly wouldn''t have chosen a c-section if I had a choice.Date: 1/8/2009 12:43:11 PM
Author:Peepa
Anyone here have a doctor in the south bay who was happy to oblige to wanting a scheduled c-section? Any referrals?
Peepa, are you talking South Bay in NorCal or So Cal?
You''re right...sorry.Date: 1/8/2009 12:49:48 PM
Author: TravelingGal
With all due respect Steph, Peepa didn''t ask if she should have one or not. People have their reasons for wanting scheduled c-sections and I would hope the decision is made after doing their homework.Date: 1/8/2009 12:45:24 PM
Author: steph72276
Date: 1/8/2009 12:43:11 PM
Author:Peepa
Anyone here have a doctor in the south bay who was happy to oblige to wanting a scheduled c-section? Any referrals?
Just curious, why would you WANT a c-section if it is not medically necessary? It is major surgery and hard to recover from while caring for a newborn. I certainly wouldn''t have chosen a c-section if I had a choice.
Peepa, are you talking South Bay in NorCal or So Cal?
I actually know so many women who want an elective. It''s more and more common, especially here in LA where stars seem to make it seem like the norm.Date: 1/8/2009 8:28:37 PM
Author: steph72276
I didn''t mean to offend the OP, but I was just a little miffed. I had to have an emergency c-section, and would never have wanted to have one if it wasn''t necessary. I guess I have just never heard of someone wanting to have a c-section, especially if their original doctor didn''t want to do it and was confused about it.
Date: 1/8/2009 10:36:37 PM
Author: TravelingGal
Date: 1/8/2009 8:28:37 PM
Author: steph72276
I didn't mean to offend the OP, but I was just a little miffed. I had to have an emergency c-section, and would never have wanted to have one if it wasn't necessary. I guess I have just never heard of someone wanting to have a c-section, especially if their original doctor didn't want to do it and was confused about it.
I actually know so many women who want an elective. It's more and more common, especially here in LA where stars seem to make it seem like the norm.
I had an emergency as well. My recovery was very easy. However, I would have loved to have a vaginal delivery. Area hospitals do not allow VBAC so I do not have a choice if I want to deliver near my home. And now that I have had a c-section, I'm not all that excited about possibly butchering things 'down there' when the c-section has already left a lovely scary and an apron which will most likely never go away.
People have made a good point that insurance may not cover an elective c-section...they are way more expensive and hospital stays are longer. Mine was 6 days due to complications.
I saw this article and it was interesting and seems to be reputable! For those who don''t read links, it basically says that if you are going to do a scheduled c-section, just be sure not to do it prior to 39 weeks... earlier than 39 weeks can lead to a lot of added complications for baby.Date: 1/8/2009 2:11:45 PM
Author: robbie3982
Someone posted this on thebump.com today. Thought you might find it interesting:
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB123138530855663493.html?mod=googlenews_wsj
Date: 1/8/2009 10:48:01 PM
Author: steph72276
hmmm, very interesting. What would be the benefit? Just being able to pick your delivery date?
No. Benefits (perceived or otherwise) would be:
The benefits are usually for the mother and not the child. However, maybe one can argue happy mother, happy child?
I myself will admit I AM happy that my bits were left unscathed by having a c-section. However considering how scary it was to have my newborn cough out fluid that was still left in her lungs because they were squeezed out since she didn''t come out vaginally...well, I would without question choose to have vaginal delivery. I will say though that Amelia seems perfectly healthy now, minus the gimpy refusing to crawl thing.
I was in recovery for at least 2.5 hours. That SUCKED.Date: 1/8/2009 11:59:36 PM
Author: packrat
I''m wondering why it is w/celebrities that they seem to prefer sections over vaginal deliveries? I''ve had a couple people tell me they were scared of labor, so wanted to have a cesarean instead, but my guess is you''d have to travel (here anyway) a couple hours to find a hospital that would do it. My recovery after the 2nd was harder..I suppose b/c it''s going right back in over scar tissue, the muscles weren''t near as strong as the 1st time around and I had a 3 1/2 year old to chase after. I think it''s a lot more stress to put on your body, if you don''t really need to. JMO of course. I remember being quite jealous of friends who''d delivered vaginally and they''d be up and at em shortly afterwards..while I was stuck shuffling around, cursing every time I had the smallest sneeze or cough or needed to blow my nose. Generally, the reaction I''ve gotten when people hear I had c-sections is ''Oh, I''m so sorry''. I do remember 1 person saying ''Jeez, you''re lucky'' and my husband burst out laughing.
We got a big charge out of picking our son''s birthday, and it was nice knowing what to expect, having done it before. Husband took 1 week off w/our 1st, and when the 2nd one came, he took 2 weeks off. Even little things are harder to do after major abdominal surgery.
I know on a pregnancy board I used to belong to, that some women who''d had cesareans were upset afterwards. I''d watched so many baby shows on Discovery when the baby would be delivered and immediately placed on mom''s tummy/chest..and it would make me bawl, I was so excited to experience that. And then I got to see my baby''s face for about 5 seconds, and then it was another 1/2 hour or whatever in recovery until I was able to actually hold her and nurse. So that''s something to think about too..would it bother you to miss that bonding experience?
I wouldn''t want to pay out of pocket for something like that either..Elective surgeries generally just aren''t covered, or are covered at a way lesser extent. When I called the insurance company before our son was born (I didn''t need to pre-certify, but I figured I should, just in case), they did ask what type of delivery we anticipated, and I said it was repeat c-section, and was told that was fine, but they did ask what the reason for the 1st one was as well.
Wow-sorry to be so long winded!
I know how you feel, same thing happened t me.Date: 1/9/2009 12:11:25 AM
Author: TravelingGal
I was in recovery for at least 2.5 hours. That SUCKED.Date: 1/8/2009 11:59:36 PM
Author: packrat
I''m wondering why it is w/celebrities that they seem to prefer sections over vaginal deliveries? I''ve had a couple people tell me they were scared of labor, so wanted to have a cesarean instead, but my guess is you''d have to travel (here anyway) a couple hours to find a hospital that would do it. My recovery after the 2nd was harder..I suppose b/c it''s going right back in over scar tissue, the muscles weren''t near as strong as the 1st time around and I had a 3 1/2 year old to chase after. I think it''s a lot more stress to put on your body, if you don''t really need to. JMO of course. I remember being quite jealous of friends who''d delivered vaginally and they''d be up and at em shortly afterwards..while I was stuck shuffling around, cursing every time I had the smallest sneeze or cough or needed to blow my nose. Generally, the reaction I''ve gotten when people hear I had c-sections is ''Oh, I''m so sorry''. I do remember 1 person saying ''Jeez, you''re lucky'' and my husband burst out laughing.
We got a big charge out of picking our son''s birthday, and it was nice knowing what to expect, having done it before. Husband took 1 week off w/our 1st, and when the 2nd one came, he took 2 weeks off. Even little things are harder to do after major abdominal surgery.
I know on a pregnancy board I used to belong to, that some women who''d had cesareans were upset afterwards. I''d watched so many baby shows on Discovery when the baby would be delivered and immediately placed on mom''s tummy/chest..and it would make me bawl, I was so excited to experience that. And then I got to see my baby''s face for about 5 seconds, and then it was another 1/2 hour or whatever in recovery until I was able to actually hold her and nurse. So that''s something to think about too..would it bother you to miss that bonding experience?
I wouldn''t want to pay out of pocket for something like that either..Elective surgeries generally just aren''t covered, or are covered at a way lesser extent. When I called the insurance company before our son was born (I didn''t need to pre-certify, but I figured I should, just in case), they did ask what type of delivery we anticipated, and I said it was repeat c-section, and was told that was fine, but they did ask what the reason for the 1st one was as well.
Wow-sorry to be so long winded!
And then you know what? They wheeled me back into a regular room (bigger delivery room, not post delivery since I had complications and they needed to monitor me). The nurse was holding my daughter as they got me set up. My SIL was there and said, ''she''s so cute!'' The nurse said, ''You want to hold her?'' And so my SIL did.
I must have looked absolutely crestfallen because TGuy, who is normally not an overly sensitive guy, said, ''you''ll get her in a minute honey,'' in a sweet apologetic way. I know others held her before I got to hold her...nurses, etc. But sitting there feeling nauseous and not being able to hold my daughter first while my SIL cradled Amelia gently in her arms...well, that will be something I always will remember and be pretty sad about, as petty as that sounds. I still wish my SIL had been way more sensive and my brother smart enough to intervene and say that I had waited long enough and should have held her first. All I could think about while in recovery was that I wanted to hold her. Had I not had a c-section, this would not have even been an issue.
Vent over!
Ok. Gotcha.Date: 1/8/2009 11:57:48 PM
Author: TravelingGal
Date: 1/8/2009 10:48:01 PM
Author: steph72276
hmmm, very interesting. What would be the benefit? Just being able to pick your delivery date?
No. Benefits (perceived or otherwise) would be:
- better chance of not having incontinence either right after or later on in life
- Tighter in happy places
- no chance of tearing which would have made it quite an unhappy place
- lesser chance of hemerrhoids
The benefits are usually for the mother and not the child. However, maybe one can argue happy mother, happy child?
I myself will admit I AM happy that my bits were left unscathed by having a c-section. However considering how scary it was to have my newborn cough out fluid that was still left in her lungs because they were squeezed out since she didn''t come out vaginally...well, I would without question choose to have vaginal delivery. I will say though that Amelia seems perfectly healthy now, minus the gimpy refusing to crawl thing.
Date: 1/9/2009 8:08:05 AM
Author: steph72276
I had major complications, too. Another surgeon had to be called in to help. It was so lovely being operated on for 2+ hours while completely awake. Afterwards, I was shaking for several hours, was on oxygen and they were debating whether or not to give me a blood transfusion....so yeah, I didn''t get to hold my little guy until the next day! So everyone including my DH, both sets of grandparents, and sister-in-laws got to hold him before me and I missed out on that whole bonding experience. I guess I would never in a million years expect that some people WANT to go through that, but whatever it is their body and they can do whatever they want to with it....
Exactly. My understanding is that elective is different from emergency. One thing I heard (although I can''t verify) is that you don''t get the shakes as bad. My incision is nasty and I am hoping with my 2nd c-section, they can make it look better!Date: 1/9/2009 9:10:45 AM
Author: neatfreak
Date: 1/9/2009 8:08:05 AM
Author: steph72276
I had major complications, too. Another surgeon had to be called in to help. It was so lovely being operated on for 2+ hours while completely awake. Afterwards, I was shaking for several hours, was on oxygen and they were debating whether or not to give me a blood transfusion....so yeah, I didn''t get to hold my little guy until the next day! So everyone including my DH, both sets of grandparents, and sister-in-laws got to hold him before me and I missed out on that whole bonding experience. I guess I would never in a million years expect that some people WANT to go through that, but whatever it is their body and they can do whatever they want to with it....
Just thought I would comment here, a lot of the things you guys were so unfortunate to experience don''t often happen with scheduled c-sections...it''s a whole different ballgame than an emergency C IMO.
Mine was scheduled because my twin B was butt first, and I had a pretty great experience. My DH was with me the whole time, I had a spinal for anesthesia and my anesthesiologist was really great so I felt pretty much nothing and he controlled my nausea very well. When the babies were born they popped them over the curtain for me to see, then took them to be checked out by the NICU team (protocol with twins), then they let DH take them back into the room with me while they were stitching me up. So while he held them first, I was able to see them and touch them right there in the delivery room.
Then they wheeled me to recovery and were able to give me the babies pretty much right away to snuggle with.
Add those things to the fact that your body isn''t stressed at all because there was no stressful situation beforehand, your surgeon has the time to make a nice incision, and the stuff TGal added and I can understand why some women would want an elective C. My incision is so small and well done that even the nurses in the hospital were having a hard time finding it days after surgery. I am not kidding here.
Would it be my choice after going through one already and quite frankly having a super easy recovery? No, because I don''t think that it''s worth the additional risks to mom or baby. Medically it does not seem like a smart decision unless you need one. But I can see the appeal for some people.