Two Princess Diamonds with Ideal Scope, help decide

[brymerica]

I have two to make a final decision on, please advise. Thanks much in advance.


1.10
E, VS2
Depth 71.3
Table 68
Girdle: Medium to thick
Polish/Symmetry: Good
5.62 x 5.83
crown 11.2%
girdle 3.4%
pavillion 57.1

Ideal scope image and picture following

 

[brymerica]

Diamond picture, 1.10

 

[brymerica]

Diamond 2

1.11
F, SI1
Depth 68.8
Table 69
Girdle: Thick
5.70 x 5.75
Polish/Symmetry: Ex/VG
crown 13.4%
girdle 3.5

pavillion 52.5

 

[brymerica]

Pic of 1.11 diamond

 

[researcher]

What are the crown and pavilion percents of both diamonds? What are the measurements?

 

[Garry H (Cut Nut)]

I prefer the top IS image (by a tiny margin) but like the lower color clarity combo (better price , no visual difference).

I also do not mind thicker girdles on princess or other square stones as they are the diamonds we will be making a business out of repolishing chipped diamonds in years to come.

 

[brymerica]

i've added the crown height and pavilion dimensions. thanks for any advice.

 

[moremoremore]

I kinda like # 2 also....


Hey Gary- feathers that break the surface with a med to slightly thick girdle.... good or bad...fact or fiction!!!!???

 

[brymerica]

The top diamond looks like it has thicker facets, can someone explain why? does that affect the sparkle?