by tigertales » Apr 5, 2019 So, I got a new ring from my trusted jeweler of 20 yrs, just a sweet anniversary present for a special day we usually celebrate. It was sized for me. When I put it on, I noticed a small diamond on the end was badly cracked, and the prong had been retouched with a glob of solder really sloppily. We returned it to the jeweler within the hour. I had worn it for all of five minutes. He agreed to replace the stone. Well, I got it back this week and the diamond is smaller, it's not G/H color, more like K and has a very dark inclusion. It's just awful!!!!! I hate to go back there for something so trivial, but it's really bothering me. Why would they cheapskate out on me like this!!! I told him take your time, there's no rush, get a nice match etc. ARGGH! I have a good relationship with him, which I don't want to sour with this picky little issue. What to do?