Seven stone diamond wedding ring (0.75 ctw) from Whiteflash or James Allen?

[toki]

Hi!

I've been looking around for a seven stone diamond wedding ring (around 0.75 ctw). I found similar rings at Whiteflash and at James Allen, but can't decide which one to choose and would appreciate your advice!

Whiteflash, F/G - VS

Seven Stone Open Basket Diamond Wedding Ring | 6834

Radiate beauty and grace with the Seven Stone Open Basket Diamond Wedding Ring. Find it at Whiteflash and symbolize your everlasting love. | 6834

www.whiteflash.com

James Allen, H/I - SI1/SI2 (currently has a 25% discount)

Platinum Seven Stone Shared Prong Contour Diamond Ring (0.75 CTW - H-I / SI1-SI2)-16003p3b

Open shared prongs contour the diamonds to better showcase their unmatched beauty. A scalloped setting provides protection while allowing more light to shine through the diamond for added sparkle. This anniversary ring is elegant and timeless.

www.jamesallen.com

The Whiteflash ring has higher color, clarity, and ACA melee. Is it worth the premium of over $700 price difference?
The James Allen ring doesn't mention about the cut.

Note: my engagement ring is G color, but I likely will wear the wedding ring by itself.

Thank you for any comments or advice!

 

[AprilBaby]

To me, yes. the best possible stones vs good stones. If you can afford it do it.

 

[winnietucker]

I agree. For $700 more I’d go with the best possible quality. That way there’s no second guessing down the road. I had my wedding band remade with better quality diamonds because it ended up bothering me so much. Cost me more than $700 in total... if I knew about PS then I would have done it better quality the first time.

 

[OoohShiny]

We went for a WF ring with their ACA melee in it, and although I was sceptical how much difference it would make, they really do sparkle nicely in direct lighting and look nice and bright in flat lighting!

I would definitely go with WF over JA on that basis - plus, WF customer service is excellent

 

[MissGotRocks]

Definitely WF for the ACA's if you can swing it. Definitely better cut stones!

 

[flyingpig]

WF. No brainer.

 

[toki]

Thank you for all your comments; they are so helpful. I will go for the WF ring! Thanks!!