Rate these Emerald cut diamonds

[Dayamond]

Final diamond stone options. Please i need honest feedback..lol! This process has been a long journey...haha! Thanks to everyone who helped.

Option 1 - https://www.yadavjewelry.com/diamond/emerald-diamond-2.01-carat-h-si1-yd9487045

I saw this stone in person and shocked it was an H SI1, cos it looked like a VS1 or 2 that i had seen. My concern is the surface grading commwnt on the GIA cert. what is the impact of surface grading? Also, the stone has a cloud near the center. Is it worth the price?

Option 2 - https://www.b2cjewels.com/dd/17848587/Emerald-diamond-J-color-VVS2-clarity

J color i know. Does medium fluorescence matter and can it diffuse the warmth of a J? I know some folks have an issue with J, so i am on the fence. Fits carat requirements abd Proportions are great

Option 3 - https://www.b2cjewels.com/dd/18101639/Emerald-diamond-J-color-VVS2-clarity

Also a J, same concerns as above. Nice proportions and meets the carat requireements. I have a video but cant upload here. Any advice on how to upload or link?

thoughts on these stones? thinking the H is expensive but within my budget. J stones are also great and seem nice for cost. Looks nice but wanna hear your thoughts.

 

[Matthews1127]

Upload the video to YouTube and copy/paste it here.
I will reply to each example above....

 

[Matthews1127]

Final diamond stone options. Please i need honest feedback..lol! This process has been a long journey...haha! Thanks to everyone who helped.

Option 1 - https://www.yadavjewelry.com/diamond/emerald-diamond-2.01-carat-h-si1-yd9487045

I saw this stone in person and shocked it was an H SI1, cos it looked like a VS1 or 2 that i had seen. My concern is the surface grading commwnt on the GIA cert. what is the impact of surface grading? Also, the stone has a cloud near the center. Is it worth the price?

Option 2 - https://www.b2cjewels.com/dd/17848587/Emerald-diamond-J-color-VVS2-clarity

J color i know. Does medium fluorescence matter and can it diffuse the warmth of a J? I know some folks have an issue with J, so i am on the fence. Fits carat requirements abd Proportions are great

Option 3 - https://www.b2cjewels.com/dd/18101639/Emerald-diamond-J-color-VVS2-clarity

Also a J, same concerns as above. Nice proportions and meets the carat requireements. I have a video but cant upload here. Any advice on how to upload or link?

thoughts on these stones? thinking the H is expensive but within my budget. J stones are also great and seem nice for cost. Looks nice but wanna hear your thoughts.

Option 1. The link does not open for me.

Option 2. Gorgeous stone!
The medium Fl should assist in balancing the tint in a J, in certain lighting environments.
As mentioned before, EC’s pick up colors in their environment. It’s the nature of the beast. The stone will appear lighter or more tinted depending on lighting environment and the surrounding colors of the outdoors or indoor walls.

Surface graining:

"Surface Graining Is Not Shown" Comment - Should You Worry?

What does the comment "Surface graining is not shown" in a GIA grading report mean? Should you worry when you see this in an internally flawless diamond?

beyond4cs.com

Option 3. There is not enough info to comment. I do not believe the clouds are positioned in a manner that would cause any issues or obstruction. Clouds are clear inclusions. These do not sit against nor right under the center of the table. I do think you will not notice them from 6” or more away.
Please try to upload your video so we may see the actual stone.

Right now, the only option I can choose is #2, as I cannot see 1 or 3.

 

[tyty333]

You really need videos of Emerald cuts to see how they react as they move. You havent given us much to work with.
Option 1 - link wouldnt come up
Option 2 - no video but looks to have potential
Option 3 - no picture much less video

Perhaps let people know your budget and spec requirements and they can help you look/make suggestions.