Pls share your opinion on this antique cushion -new buyer

[lemonlimekisses]

Hello!

I have been lurking on this forum for months, casually browsing diamonds and learning a little bit about the cuts I like. My bf and I went and saw diamonds a couple weekends ago, as we have been discussing getting engaged this year. I wasn't looking when I found this diamond but now that I have, I am crazy about it! Please tell me if this is a good buy. As a first time buyer, I'm really unsure, and of course, I want to make sure we get a good deal and a good diamond.

I initially wanted to get a branded antique cushion, like a Victor Canera or GOG AVC. But the more I looked around, the more I fell in love with true antiques. I love how different each one is. I especially adore the rose gold OMC halo from ERD that was posted - sorry, I can't link to it as I'm at work and don't have my bookmarks! It's the gorgeous one photographed with succulents.

This diamond is well within our budget and I think the size is good too. I wanted to be somewhere between 6.5x6.5 and 7x7.. I'm a little concerned about the color and clarity - I am not color sensitive, at all (poor guy at the jewelry store had a hard time convincing us to go for D color).

Anyway, before I get carried away rambling, I'd like input on whether this is a good deal and if not, what kind of price range I should be looking at for a 1.3-1.5 antique cushion with similar specs (perhaps a little bit better clarity and maybe J color). If it's a dud, I need to get over it, because right now I'm so crazy about the chunky facets that I want to impulsively buy!

Thank you so much for your help!

http://www.jewelsbygrace.com/loose-diamonds/1-28-ct-antique-cushion-cut-diamond-gia-k-si2.html#.Uynzi_ldXAt

Oh and the measurements are 6.77 x 6.44 x 4.087 mm. It's K color and SI2 clarity.

 

[faded264]

Re: Pls share your opinion on this antique cushion -new buye

Hello!

I have been lurking on this forum for months, casually browsing diamonds and learning a little bit about the cuts I like. My bf and I went and saw diamonds a couple weekends ago, as we have been discussing getting engaged this year. I wasn't looking when I found this diamond but now that I have, I am crazy about it! Please tell me if this is a good buy. As a first time buyer, I'm really unsure, and of course, I want to make sure we get a good deal and a good diamond.

I initially wanted to get a branded antique cushion, like a Victor Canera or GOG AVC. But the more I looked around, the more I fell in love with true antiques. I love how different each one is. I especially adore the rose gold OMC halo from ERD that was posted - sorry, I can't link to it as I'm at work and don't have my bookmarks! It's the gorgeous one photographed with succulents.

This diamond is well within our budget and I think the size is good too. I wanted to be somewhere between 6.5x6.5 and 7x7.. I'm a little concerned about the color and clarity - I am not color sensitive, at all (poor guy at the jewelry store had a hard time convincing us to go for D color).

Anyway, before I get carried away rambling, I'd like input on whether this is a good deal and if not, what kind of price range I should be looking at for a 1.3-1.5 antique cushion with similar specs (perhaps a little bit better clarity and maybe J color). If it's a dud, I need to get over it, because right now I'm so crazy about the chunky facets that I want to impulsively buy!

Thank you so much for your help!

http://www.jewelsbygrace.com/loose-diamonds/1-28-ct-antique-cushion-cut-diamond-gia-k-si2.html#.Uynzi_ldXAt

Oh and the measurements are 6.77 x 6.44 x 4.087 mm. It's K color and SI2 clarity.

I'm certainly not an expert, in any way, shape or form, but I also have an appreciation for antique stones. I wouldn't buy this stone simply because it's not eye clean, and has a pretty large visible inclusion. I think K color would be fine, but the visible inclusion would drive me batty. Looks like Grace has another antique cushion that is 1.27 K, VS1 for about $1000 more that I would consider before this one. It does have a more roundish shape than the one you are considering though. I would keep looking rather than buy the one you linked above.

Here's a link:

http://www.jewelsbygrace.com/loose-diamonds/1-27ct-oec-egl-k-vs1.html

But I would wait for others to chime in! Happy shopping!

 

[lemonlimekisses]

Re: Pls share your opinion on this antique cushion -new buye

Hello!

I have been lurking on this forum for months, casually browsing diamonds and learning a little bit about the cuts I like. My bf and I went and saw diamonds a couple weekends ago, as we have been discussing getting engaged this year. I wasn't looking when I found this diamond but now that I have, I am crazy about it! Please tell me if this is a good buy. As a first time buyer, I'm really unsure, and of course, I want to make sure we get a good deal and a good diamond.

I initially wanted to get a branded antique cushion, like a Victor Canera or GOG AVC. But the more I looked around, the more I fell in love with true antiques. I love how different each one is. I especially adore the rose gold OMC halo from ERD that was posted - sorry, I can't link to it as I'm at work and don't have my bookmarks! It's the gorgeous one photographed with succulents.

This diamond is well within our budget and I think the size is good too. I wanted to be somewhere between 6.5x6.5 and 7x7.. I'm a little concerned about the color and clarity - I am not color sensitive, at all (poor guy at the jewelry store had a hard time convincing us to go for D color).

Anyway, before I get carried away rambling, I'd like input on whether this is a good deal and if not, what kind of price range I should be looking at for a 1.3-1.5 antique cushion with similar specs (perhaps a little bit better clarity and maybe J color). If it's a dud, I need to get over it, because right now I'm so crazy about the chunky facets that I want to impulsively buy!

Thank you so much for your help!

http://www.jewelsbygrace.com/loose-diamonds/1-28-ct-antique-cushion-cut-diamond-gia-k-si2.html#.Uynzi_ldXAt

Oh and the measurements are 6.77 x 6.44 x 4.087 mm. It's K color and SI2 clarity.

I'm certainly not an expert, in any way, shape or form, but I also have an appreciation for antique stones. I wouldn't buy this stone simply because it's not eye clean, and has a pretty large visible inclusion. I think K color would be fine, but the visible inclusion would drive me batty. Looks like Grace has another antique cushion that is 1.27 K, VS1 for about $1000 more that I would consider before this one.

Hi there, thanks for your response! I know, that inclusion is something. I don't know how visible it would be in person.. I'm also not the most OCD person out there, though I have my moments. I just have no idea.

I'm also wondering how much of a great deal this is. We had originally budget 10k for the stone, ideally 8k.. and this just seems like a steal for the size. But that inclusion! In the videos, it's not noticeable to me but I know it can all change in person.

I don't like the other antique cushion (if we're talking about the same one) because I like chunkier facets. This one is just more visually interesting and pleasing to me.

 

[faded264]

Re: Pls share your opinion on this antique cushion -new buye

Hello!

I have been lurking on this forum for months, casually browsing diamonds and learning a little bit about the cuts I like. My bf and I went and saw diamonds a couple weekends ago, as we have been discussing getting engaged this year. I wasn't looking when I found this diamond but now that I have, I am crazy about it! Please tell me if this is a good buy. As a first time buyer, I'm really unsure, and of course, I want to make sure we get a good deal and a good diamond.

I initially wanted to get a branded antique cushion, like a Victor Canera or GOG AVC. But the more I looked around, the more I fell in love with true antiques. I love how different each one is. I especially adore the rose gold OMC halo from ERD that was posted - sorry, I can't link to it as I'm at work and don't have my bookmarks! It's the gorgeous one photographed with succulents.

This diamond is well within our budget and I think the size is good too. I wanted to be somewhere between 6.5x6.5 and 7x7.. I'm a little concerned about the color and clarity - I am not color sensitive, at all (poor guy at the jewelry store had a hard time convincing us to go for D color).

Anyway, before I get carried away rambling, I'd like input on whether this is a good deal and if not, what kind of price range I should be looking at for a 1.3-1.5 antique cushion with similar specs (perhaps a little bit better clarity and maybe J color). If it's a dud, I need to get over it, because right now I'm so crazy about the chunky facets that I want to impulsively buy!

Thank you so much for your help!

http://www.jewelsbygrace.com/loose-diamonds/1-28-ct-antique-cushion-cut-diamond-gia-k-si2.html#.Uynzi_ldXAt

Oh and the measurements are 6.77 x 6.44 x 4.087 mm. It's K color and SI2 clarity.

I'm certainly not an expert, in any way, shape or form, but I also have an appreciation for antique stones. I wouldn't buy this stone simply because it's not eye clean, and has a pretty large visible inclusion. I think K color would be fine, but the visible inclusion would drive me batty. Looks like Grace has another antique cushion that is 1.27 K, VS1 for about $1000 more that I would consider before this one.

Hi there, thanks for your response! I know, that inclusion is something. I don't know how visible it would be in person.. I'm also not the most OCD person out there, though I have my moments. I just have no idea.

I'm also wondering how much of a great deal this is. We had originally budget 10k for the stone, ideally 8k.. and this just seems like a steal for the size. But that inclusion! In the videos, it's not noticeable to me but I know it can all change in person.

I don't like the other antique cushion (if we're talking about the same one) because I like chunkier facets. This one is just more visually interesting and pleasing to me.

I understand! That other cushion looks almost like an OEC to me; it's not everyone's cup of tea.

If I were you, I would hold out and keep checking her website. I've been stalking it for a while, and she gets quite a lot of antique cushions in around your price range.

 

[treasurehunter]

Re: Pls share your opinion on this antique cushion -new buye

http://www.diamondsbylauren.com/index.php/jewelry/old-mine-brilliant-101ct-nvvs2-branded-dbl-modern-antique-diamond-gia-r4767

Heres a good one in your price range, warm colour antique cushion but a great performer.

 

[lemonlimekisses]

Re: Pls share your opinion on this antique cushion -new buye

Hello!

I have been lurking on this forum for months, casually browsing diamonds and learning a little bit about the cuts I like. My bf and I went and saw diamonds a couple weekends ago, as we have been discussing getting engaged this year. I wasn't looking when I found this diamond but now that I have, I am crazy about it! Please tell me if this is a good buy. As a first time buyer, I'm really unsure, and of course, I want to make sure we get a good deal and a good diamond.

I initially wanted to get a branded antique cushion, like a Victor Canera or GOG AVC. But the more I looked around, the more I fell in love with true antiques. I love how different each one is. I especially adore the rose gold OMC halo from ERD that was posted - sorry, I can't link to it as I'm at work and don't have my bookmarks! It's the gorgeous one photographed with succulents.

This diamond is well within our budget and I think the size is good too. I wanted to be somewhere between 6.5x6.5 and 7x7.. I'm a little concerned about the color and clarity - I am not color sensitive, at all (poor guy at the jewelry store had a hard time convincing us to go for D color).

Anyway, before I get carried away rambling, I'd like input on whether this is a good deal and if not, what kind of price range I should be looking at for a 1.3-1.5 antique cushion with similar specs (perhaps a little bit better clarity and maybe J color). If it's a dud, I need to get over it, because right now I'm so crazy about the chunky facets that I want to impulsively buy!

Thank you so much for your help!

http://www.jewelsbygrace.com/loose-diamonds/1-28-ct-antique-cushion-cut-diamond-gia-k-si2.html#.Uynzi_ldXAt

Oh and the measurements are 6.77 x 6.44 x 4.087 mm. It's K color and SI2 clarity.

I'm certainly not an expert, in any way, shape or form, but I also have an appreciation for antique stones. I wouldn't buy this stone simply because it's not eye clean, and has a pretty large visible inclusion. I think K color would be fine, but the visible inclusion would drive me batty. Looks like Grace has another antique cushion that is 1.27 K, VS1 for about $1000 more that I would consider before this one.

Hi there, thanks for your response! I know, that inclusion is something. I don't know how visible it would be in person.. I'm also not the most OCD person out there, though I have my moments. I just have no idea.

I'm also wondering how much of a great deal this is. We had originally budget 10k for the stone, ideally 8k.. and this just seems like a steal for the size. But that inclusion! In the videos, it's not noticeable to me but I know it can all change in person.

I don't like the other antique cushion (if we're talking about the same one) because I like chunkier facets. This one is just more visually interesting and pleasing to me.

I understand! That other cushion looks almost like an OEC to me; it's not everyone's cup of tea.

If I were you, I would hold out and keep checking her website. I've been stalking it for a while, and she gets quite a lot of antique cushions in around your price range.

I just went back to her site, and I was mistaken about which cushion you were referencing. The one you mentioned is great! So pretty. Love the flower.. I just want a very cushion-y cushion. This one looks more round. I wish I liked rounds - OECs are beauuutiful.

Thanks for the input.

 

[lemonlimekisses]

Re: Pls share your opinion on this antique cushion -new buye

http://www.diamondsbylauren.com/index.php/jewelry/old-mine-brilliant-101ct-nvvs2-branded-dbl-modern-antique-diamond-gia-r4767

Heres a good one in your price range, warm colour antique cushion but a great performer.

Hi treasurehunter - thanks for the link! Unfortunately, it is a bit small and low in color. Ideally, I'd like 6.5x6.5ish, in a perfect world, 7x7mm! We did budget 10k for the diamond, so we can keep looking. Like I mentioned earlier, my last resort (and not a bad last resort at all!) is to go with an AVC or CAC. All gorgeous, just not a true antique, which is my first choice. I might get in touch with Adam at OWD, I've heard great things. I just wanted some input on this particular diamond and whether it's a good enough steal that I should bite the bullet and order it. Grace has a great return policy, she's been wonderful to email with.

 

[treasurehunter]

Re: Pls share your opinion on this antique cushion -new buye

By True antique you mean a stone cut too poorer standards of light return and symmetry , the antique style is larger broader facets but the modern ones like the AVC have better light return but cut to the antique style.
Side by side I think you wouldn't hesitate getting a modern cut antique style cushion over an actual antique cushion.
Note K colour is going to be yellow too.

 

[Fancygems]

Re: Pls share your opinion on this antique cushion -new buye

K color in true antique cut diamonds appears white enough to my eyes, however color Is subjective.. Perhaps others see more warmth. There are true antique lovers and those who love the antique style and it seems to be brought up frequently. It is not completely a fair comparison a hand cut (without today's technology) true authentic antique diamond to a precision newly cut antique style. One is cut for light performance the other one is out of round and has a history to it. Some are sentimental about antiques and all the wonky charm or individual personality, and other are not. Both will sparkle so which ever you chose, neither are right or wrong just which is right for you!

 

[treasurehunter]

Re: Pls share your opinion on this antique cushion -new buye

True antique diamonds do not sparkle and the new precision cut antique diamonds are hand cut, many by a world class cutter Diagem who is a member on the forum and they are not cut by a laser.

 

[Asscherhalo_lover]

Re: Pls share your opinion on this antique cushion -new buye

Honestly if you think the diamond you posted might be a contender order it and check it out yourself. I find that a static image is usually worse for showing inclusions than many stones IRL. It's well under your budget so let the vendor know you want it loose to check the inclusion and agree upon shipping charges. Could be worth it.

 

[liaerfbv]

Re: Pls share your opinion on this antique cushion -new buye

True antique diamonds do not sparkle and the new precision cut antique diamonds are hand cut, many by a world class cutter Diagem who is a member on the forum and they are not cut by a laser.

Say what now?? Antique diamonds do not sparkle? Are you living in an alternate universe?

 

[Fancygems]

Re: Pls share your opinion on this antique cushion -new buye

Oh yes Yoram, but I don't know about the Canera cushions the OP is looking at. Whaaa? Oec's and OMB's do not sparkle!? Ohhhh Yes they do! They produce Colorful ones too. There is a reason the oldies are so adored...
OP see both in person and see which you prefer. Both can be lovely.

 

[lemonlimekisses]

Re: Pls share your opinion on this antique cushion -new buye

I do appreciate every one's input! I'm leaning towards getting it, I was just wondering what the opinions of the "experts" were.

Does anyone feel this diamond is not a good buy??

As of now, I would rather get an antique diamond but I hear ya about the new ones. They're gorgeous. I wish I could see some of them in person!

 

[treasurehunter]

Re: Pls share your opinion on this antique cushion -new buye

Well any diamond that is polished sparkles,alot of the antique cushions are abraded or scratched and have polish issues so they don't sparkle as much or have the same light return as the modern due to better optics.

 

[Gypsy]

Re: Pls share your opinion on this antique cushion -new buye

I like the faceting and measurements of the original stone. And if I was buying for MYSELF, sure I'd have it shipped to me to see what I thought of the inclusion in person, so long as there is a good return policy. But I wouldn't buy it for someone else as a surprise.

 

[SB621]

Re: Pls share your opinion on this antique cushion -new buye

I"m not sure who treasurehunter is but I would ignore their advise. Anyone who gives absolutes as facts and is not listening to what you want for YOUR engagment ring I never find to be helpful. For what it's worth I know many people who have chosen to have antique cushions/ OECs/ Trannys in real life over "true antiques" or equivlent. The draw of having an antique I find to be so romantic! However I also understand that are not for everyone. I think if you have decided on antiques then you should go that way. If you were super anal about light return and precision optics I would say go branded. Though between us I have compared my AC to other branded AC's and I still think mine is way nicer, but it is my ering so I might be slightly biased

For me the shape you picked out is my favorite for an antique cushion. Meg, Just Ginger and myself all have very similar cushions with that soft pillowy look and strong maltese cross. Is there a video of it to see if their is leakage?

So in regards to the inclusion, what type of inclusions is it? Sorry I'm on my phone so can't pull the GIA report. Also do you know how will you have this set? You might be able to cover a portion of the inclusion up. I have an 2ct I1 from Jbeg. It is low in color so the inclusion blends right into the body. It was a screaming deal so it does not bother me at all, however it is also not my ering and I dont' wear it everyday.

What I would do is ask Grace to ship you the diamond to see if you like it. Play around with it in different lightening and really scrutize how you feel about the inclusion to see if it bothers you. For me personally at that price (pending inclusion type) I would jump on it as that is a smoking deal.

 

[armywife13]

Re: Pls share your opinion on this antique cushion -new buye

True antique diamonds do not sparkle and the new precision cut antique diamonds are hand cut, many by a world class cutter Diagem who is a member on the forum and they are not cut by a laser.

As someone who has personal experience from owning an antique cushion and multiple old european cuts, I find this statement to be untrue. A well cut AC or OEC will have lots of sparkle. It is true that they do not perform the same as a MRB or Modern Cushion, but they still perform wonderfully. To me, comparing an old cut to it's modern cut counterpart is unfair. They are both beautiful and perform well, but differently. One isn't better than the other, they are just a different flavor of diamonds.

 

[armywife13]

Re: Pls share your opinion on this antique cushion -new buye

I like the faceting and measurements of the original stone. And if I was buying for MYSELF, sure I'd have it shipped to me to see what I thought of the inclusion in person, so long as there is a good return policy. But I wouldn't buy it for someone else as a surprise.

OP, with regards to the stone you first posted, I would follow Gypsy's advice. I think the stone is gorgeous, but you should definitely see it in person to determine how you feel about the inclusion in real life.

 

[lknvrb4]

Re: Pls share your opinion on this antique cushion -new buye

True antique diamonds do not sparkle and the new precision cut antique diamonds are hand cut, many by a world class cutter Diagem who is a member on the forum and they are not cut by a laser.

I have to disagree with you on this one. I own a true antique and it sparkles like crazy.

 

[lknvrb4]

Re: Pls share your opinion on this antique cushion -new buye

I like the shape of the diamond you picked and like the facet pattern. I would totally have it sent to me and inspect it in person and then make a decision.

 

[susimoo]

Re: Pls share your opinion on this antique cushion -new buye

Just on to add my support to antique stones.

I have owned an AVC (which I traded in) and I have just bought a real antique cushion.

I would say that whilst I loved the precision of the AVC, nothing can replace the charm and romance of a excellent performing antique. To say that they do not sparkle is nonsense. Like all diamonds each must be judged on its own merits. PS have plenty of vendors who can source you a well cut, excellent performing antique.

Plus there are advantages to having a true antique on your finger. They are much cheaper than the newly cut ones, if you shop carefully.

 

[yennyfire]

Re: Pls share your opinion on this antique cushion -new buye

True antique diamonds do not sparkle and the new precision cut antique diamonds are hand cut, many by a world class cutter Diagem who is a member on the forum and they are not cut by a laser.

By True antique you mean a stone cut too poorer standards of light return and symmetry , the antique style is larger broader facets but the modern ones like the AVC have better light return but cut to the antique style.
Side by side I think you wouldn't hesitate getting a modern cut antique style cushion over an actual antique cushion.
Note K colour is going to be yellow too.

Ummm, have you ever seen a true antique in person? I own 6 antique stones and I can tell you that each and every one of them sparkles like mad! Are there plenty of antique stones that are dud's? Yes. But there are plenty of modern stones that earn the title "dud" as well. Educate yourself before you try to educate others. Many of the members here have had 50 or more antique stones pass through their hands and have done extensive research about what to look for in an antique stone. Not one of them would have made the statements that you did.

OP, I agree that the stone you linked to would be worth seeing in person. If you decide to order it, I'll be anxious to hear what you think about it!

 

[GemFever]

Re: Pls share your opinion on this antique cushion -new buye

lemonlime -- I really love the look of the first cushion you picked out (and the second one posted, the more flowery one). As others have suggested, you need to see for yourself if the inclusion will bother you. See if it's a "neat" looking inclusion or if it makes the stone look like something is stuck to it and you'll always want to wipe it clean. That could get annoying. I have a 1ct OEC with an SI1 inclusion right under the table and I never ever see it. I also have an OMC that slightly over a carat with two stick-like inclusions under the table and they don't bother me at all (the stone is in an earring though, so I don't actually gaze into it much). So definitely this one is worth a look!

As for the sparkle discussion here, I'll just say ---

 

[lemonlimekisses]

Re: Pls share your opinion on this antique cushion -new buye

I"m not sure who treasurehunter is but I would ignore their advise. Anyone who gives absolutes as facts and is not listening to what you want for YOUR engagment ring I never find to be helpful. For what it's worth I know many people who have chosen to have antique cushions/ OECs/ Trannys in real life over "true antiques" or equivlent. The draw of having an antique I find to be so romantic! However I also understand that are not for everyone. I think if you have decided on antiques then you should go that way. If you were super anal about light return and precision optics I would say go branded. Though between us I have compared my AC to other branded AC's and I still think mine is way nicer, but it is my ering so I might be slightly biased

For me the shape you picked out is my favorite for an antique cushion. Meg, Just Ginger and myself all have very similar cushions with that soft pillowy look and strong maltese cross. Is there a video of it to see if their is leakage?

So in regards to the inclusion, what type of inclusions is it? Sorry I'm on my phone so can't pull the GIA report. Also do you know how will you have this set? You might be able to cover a portion of the inclusion up. I have an 2ct I1 from Jbeg. It is low in color so the inclusion blends right into the body. It was a screaming deal so it does not bother me at all, however it is also not my ering and I dont' wear it everyday.

What I would do is ask Grace to ship you the diamond to see if you like it. Play around with it in different lightening and really scrutize how you feel about the inclusion to see if it bothers you. For me personally at that price (pending inclusion type) I would jump on it as that is a smoking deal.

Here is a link to pictures and videos, if you would like to take a look! I don't know how to spot leakage, to be honesty.. I just go "oooh sparkly!"

And your ring is beautiful!!!! I can see why you would think your AC is nicer!

 

[lemonlimekisses]

Re: Pls share your opinion on this antique cushion -new buye

I like the faceting and measurements of the original stone. And if I was buying for MYSELF, sure I'd have it shipped to me to see what I thought of the inclusion in person, so long as there is a good return policy. But I wouldn't buy it for someone else as a surprise.

OP, with regards to the stone you first posted, I would follow Gypsy's advice. I think the stone is gorgeous, but you should definitely see it in person to determine how you feel about the inclusion in real life.

Hi armywife13, Gypsy --

Luckily, I am buying it with my boyfriend's funds for myself. He's very easygoing and happy to please me, I am the more difficult one in the relationship! I'm especially pleased, Gypsy, that you liked the stone because I've seen your posts all over PS and hold your opinion in high regards!

 

[lemonlimekisses]

Re: Pls share your opinion on this antique cushion -new buye

Honestly if you think the diamond you posted might be a contender order it and check it out yourself. I find that a static image is usually worse for showing inclusions than many stones IRL. It's well under your budget so let the vendor know you want it loose to check the inclusion and agree upon shipping charges. Could be worth it.

In the videos, I had a hard time spotting it but it may just be wishful thinking/my novice eyes! Thanks for your input, though, it is reassuring that others people static images are worse for showing inclusions.

 

[lemonlimekisses]

Re: Pls share your opinion on this antique cushion -new buye

I like the shape of the diamond you picked and like the facet pattern. I would totally have it sent to me and inspect it in person and then make a decision.

Hi lknrv4!! I'm so excited to see your post because I adore your ring and it was my inspiration! If this stone works out, I want it set in a very simple, low solitaire.

 

[lemonlimekisses]

Re: Pls share your opinion on this antique cushion -new buye

Yennyfire, susimoo, gemfever --

Thanks for your support and encouragement!

If it is not clear, I did go ahead and purchase this diamond last night. After rewatching the videos for the 15th time, my bf asked we buy it so we can take a real look. I think he's just as curious as I am now. I don't know if it is because it is the first diamond we have purchased but I am SO EXCITED! I will definitely update everyone on how it goes. It should arrive tomorrow afternoon so we are going to play with it for the weekend before deciding on whether to return.

Any tips on where or what kind of lighting I should see it in? I'll be checking it out indoor, outside under the sun, at night, when it is dimmer.. should I go to my office to see how it performs as well?

Thanks again, everyone, for chiming in!!

 

[diamondseeker2006]

Re: Pls share your opinion on this antique cushion -new buye

I love the cut on the one you are looking at, and I am very particular about cut. But do you have the link to the GIA report? If it is a primary feather inclusion near an edge, it would be a no go for me whether it is visible or not. You have a budget over double the cost of this stone. Why not ask Grace to search for an equally beautiful and maybe a little larger cushion with better clarity? This one would be better as a pendant stone, in my opinion. I love it, but a pendant is not viewed as closely nor does it have the risk of bumping into things and possibly cracking where that feather is like a ring does.