shape
carat
color
clarity

Please share your opinions on this J/SI1!

Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.

Katya DXB

Shiny_Rock
Premium
Joined
Jan 21, 2018
Messages
113
IMG_7847.jpg IMG_7848.jpg IMG_7849.jpg Dear All,
I would be very grateful for your opinions on this 1.25ct J/SI1:
Total depth 60.7%
Table 59%
CA 34
PA 40.6
Pavilion depth 42.5%
Girdle STK 4%
Star length 50%
Lower half 80%

The table falls outside of the range that is often recommended here, but this diamond scores 1.1 on HCA so I thought it may be worth pursuing. I have doubts about the PA - it states 40.6 but it must be on the borderline with 40.4 as the pavilion depth is 42.5%. HCA still gives 1.1 with 40.4 pavilion angle, but the light return changes to 'very good' instead of 'excellent'.

I took a few IS and ASET photos and apologies for the quality, it had to be done in the store with my iPhone. I am still hoping it's good enough to judge the optical performance. I didn't alter the images except sharpening. What do you think?

The diamond looked great in person, although it had much more color than I expected to see face up (my G solitaire looked very white in comparison). I am not yet sure if I am ok with it as originally I was looking for H/I, but if I decide to go for this one I would set it in a yellow gold pendant and it also has medium blue fluorescence. That might make it appear whiter, right?

I'd really appreciate your opinions. Like I said I was hoping for a higher color grade, but this is the best cut I was able to find and the price seems really good (USD 4,700). Upgrades accepted, too. I just want to make sure it is a top performer when it comes to the cut.

Thanks a million!
 
Sorry, forgot to mention it is GIA Triple X. Thanks!
 
Anyone? Please? :confused:
 
I’m not crazy about the placement of the inclusions can you confirm with your eye it’s sfficiently eye clean
 
The angles and HCA are great for a pendant if the color is ok with your tastes.
 
I’m not crazy about the placement of the inclusions can you confirm with your eye it’s sfficiently eye clean

Yes, it was eye clean to me :)
 
IMG_7850.jpg
I’m not crazy about the placement of the inclusions can you confirm with your eye it’s sfficiently eye clean

Although since you've mentioned it, I must say I was surprised to see so much on the side. It's not quite what I thought I saw on the plot (attached). Should I be concerned?
 
I think you’re fine that plot looks like what your stone presents. It’s lovely
 
Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top