Please help on this diamond

[mx5_dvr]

Experts, please help review this diamond: https://www.bluenile.com/diamond-details/LD15149764

Does combination of 33 crown & 41 pavilion work here?

 

[lovedogs]

I personally don't like the look of this one because the table looks a bit large and the arrows don't look "sharp" in the middle.

 

[headlight]

Will look flat due to shallow crown height, and due to the large table I do not find the table reflection attractive (the circle in the middle). It will give you a big look - that’s a positive. Also, the medium blue fluorescence will make the color appear more colorless.

 

[mx5_dvr]

What about this one: https://www.bluenile.com/diamond-details/LD14785715

I see graining but it's not mentioned in GIA report.

Opinion please.

 

[headlight]

Where do you see the graining?
Did you run through HCA? If scores less than 2 I like it. I think @lovedogs is going to like those arrows (I do, too!)

 

[mx5_dvr]

See light blue arrow for graining.
I'm pretty sure HCA would be under 2 since proportions look good on paper.

 

[lovedogs]

Where do you see the graining?
Did you run through HCA? If scores less than 2 I like it. I think @lovedogs is going to like those arrows (I do, too!)

Haha you are right I do like the arrows!

 

[magpie2]

You're going to get more love in these parts for the more 'Ideal' angles on the VS1 than the 60/60 style VVS1. However, I've just bought a larger stone with similar proportions to the VVS1 and can tell you it's lovely. I also believe it looks better cut than the VS1. When you mess about with the 360deg view a little you can sharpen up all 8 arrows and expose the majority of the opposing triangles on the star facets between the arrow heads which are always visible on 'Super-ideal' stones. Your money and your choice however, and I should point out I'm just an enthusiastic amateur!