Please help me decide between these 2 diamonds

[RN01]

Thank you all for your helpful suggestions in my previous post. After consideration to the comments and further research, I am deciding between the following 2 diamonds.

2.32
H
VS1
GIA Cert
Triple Ex
Depth - 61.9
Table - 56
Crown Angle - 34.5
Pavilion Angle - 41
HCA Score - 1.8

and

2.06
G
VS2
GIA Cert
Triple Ex
Depth - 61.6
Table - 57
Crown Angle - 34.5
Pavilion Angle - 40.8
HCA Score - 1.4

Which would you recommend? I purchased an idealscope and will post IS images of both. I need to make a decision by Monday.

 

[stone-cold11]

both look promising from the numbers.

 

[TitanCi]

what's the $$? I doubt you'll see color diff bwtn g/h, so if $$ is the same and the 2.32 is considerably larger than the 2.06, I'd say go for the larger one as both have good numbers...

 

[RN01]

what's the $$? I doubt you'll see color diff bwtn g/h, so if $$ is the same and the 2.32 is considerably larger than the 2.06, I'd say go for the larger one as both have good numbers...

The larger H VS1 diamond is $1500 more than the G VS2

 

[hearts-arrows_girl]

I like the H VS1 2.32 best, because of the extra size. Both are very nice, so which ever one you choose will look fabulous. Can't wait to see what you pick.

 

[RN01]

Received both stones today. After looking at the G and H side by side, I could see a noticeable yellow tint in H. The color was much more than I expected it to be and even though I appreciate the extra size, I am leaning toward the smaller G colored option.

I also found a 2.04 F VS2 that is slightly more expensive. The cert is attached. I like that none of the inclusions are shown on the face up side. This stone has a lower HCA score of 3.0 v. 1.4 on the G. Should I be so concerned about this score?

Please let me know your thoughts