Please help me choose!!!

[hunger85]

Hello all! I''ve spent hours and even days looking at different stones on WF and I''ve narrowed it down to these 4 stones. Please help me decide on which is best and let me know if the price I''m is good. They are all ACA WF diamonds. I am somewhat educated on the four C''s but not all when it comes to the tables and depths. So any help would be appreciated...

http://www.whiteflash.com/diamonds/Compare_Diamonds.aspx?idnos=1844703,2141785,2141784,2141787

Also, how would these 4 diamonds compare to a Hearts on Fire diamond. I went to rogers recently and found a hearts on fire diamond with the ring set for $5900 and it was only a .50ct. The color is in between the category of GHI and the clarity is between VS2-SI1. My girlfriend and i both looked at the ring at Rogers and she fell in love with it. I''d like to know if the 4 stones from WF would be just as sparkly and nice as the HOF?

Thank you!

 

[stone-cold11]

Given that only the first stone have data and the cheapest of the lot, I will go with it.

ACA is on par with HOF from what I gathered from others that has owned both of these.

 

[Lorelei]

Date: 6/27/2009 2:25:29 PM
Author:hunger85
Hello all! I''ve spent hours and even days looking at different stones on WF and I''ve narrowed it down to these 4 stones. Please help me decide on which is best and let me know if the price I''m is good. They are all ACA WF diamonds. I am somewhat educated on the four C''s but not all when it comes to the tables and depths. So any help would be appreciated...

http://www.whiteflash.com/diamonds/Compare_Diamonds.aspx?idnos=1844703,2141785,2141784,2141787

Also, how would these 4 diamonds compare to a Hearts on Fire diamond. I went to rogers recently and found a hearts on fire diamond with the ring set for $5900 and it was only a .50ct. The color is in between the category of GHI and the clarity is between VS2-SI1. My girlfriend and i both looked at the ring at Rogers and she fell in love with it. I''d like to know if the 4 stones from WF would be just as sparkly and nice as the HOF?

Thank you!

Can you add the info for all the diamonds please so I can compare them?

ACA are said to be comparable to HoF, one of my fellow posters RisingSun has in fact owned both, she might be able to give you a description of each if she sees this.

 

[Kaleigh]

I have seen HOF diamonds and have seen ACA''s. To me they are very similar in appearance. The stones you are looking at are all going to be gorgeous. The one that is an H VVS2, is the most expensive and feel it''s over kill to pay for something you can''t see... So any of the others will be stunners for sure. HTH, good luck.

 

[Lorelei]

Date: 6/27/2009 4:30:09 PM
Author: Kaleigh
I have seen HOF diamonds and have seen ACA''s. To me they are very similar in appearance. The stones you are looking at are all going to be gorgeous. The one that is an H VVS2, is the most expensive and feel it''s over kill to pay for something you can''t see... So any of the others will be stunners for sure. HTH, good luck.

Thanks K

 

[Ellen]

I''d go with the H VS1!