PLEASE GIVE EXPERT OPINIONS ON STONES, WILL BE PURCHASING VERY SOON!!!!!

[scotty13]

Hello,

I have been searching online for a diamond engagement ring over the last month, and the prices here are great!! I have also given my local B@M jeweler a chance to find me a diamond before I finally choose one within the next week or so.

PLEASE GIVE ME YOUR EXPERT OPINIONS!!!!!!!

Here is what the jeweler was able to find for me in my price range under $5000 for the stone.

1. Do any of these diamonds seem great, what is your opinion?
2. Are these diamonds being sold at good price, average price, or are they too high?
3. Which one is the better diamond in your opinion if you had to choose one?
4. Any links to great diamonds around the same price of under $5000 would be appreciated?
Diamond 1
GIA Report
Princess
5.58x5.38x4.00
1.02
E
VS2
Depth 74.3%
Table 66%
Girdle Medium to Slightly Thick
Cutlet None
Polish EX
Symmetry GD
Fluorescence None
Price $4500
Offered at B@M
I calculated a Final Grade of 1B
Diamond 2
GIA Report 2
Princess
5.47x5.38x3.98
1.01
E
VS2
Depth 70%
Girdle Slightly Thick to Thick
Cutlet None
Polish VGD
Symmetry GD
Fluorescence None
Price $4500
Offered at B@M
I calculated a Final Grade of 2A
Thanks,
Scotty13

 

[hikerchick]

I know very little about princesses but diamond one listed below looks like it might be beautiful based on the numbers. Have you seen them in person? The prices look competitive.

 

[scotty13]

Thanks for the reply!!!!

I agree with you, based on the information from this forum!!

I have not yet, but I plan on taking a look at them when they come into the store, he had to order them.

Scotty13

 

[scotty13]

I hope to also acquire the Sarin Reports for them soon!!!!!

But without the reports in hand, please give your opinions on the stones????

Scotty13