Please assist with this comparison

[The sun is shining]

1.61
J
VS2
7.52 x 7.54 x 4.64 mm
Depth %: 61.6%
Table %: 56%
Crown Angle 35.1
Pavilion Angle 40.8
$7,946 after discount

1.54
K
VS2
7.47 - 7.52 x 4.59 mm
Total Depth 61.2 %
Table Size 55.0 %
Pavilion Angle 40.8 °
Crown Angle 34.5 °
$8,729 after discount

1.58
I
VS2
Depth 61.8%
Table 57%
Pavilion Angle 40.6 °
Crown Angle 35.5 °
$12,777

Could you provide opinions please? The cost of the first one seems so good that it means I could get the setting of my dreams! I am working on getting idealscope images for them all, please bear with me!

TIA

 

[tyty333]

You need to ask admin to move this to Rocky Talky so you will get more input. I think the
experts are going to want IS images of the stones to further evaluate (all the numbers look
good to me.) The experts may have a favorite between the numbers though.

 

[D&T]

I is way out of the running for me - mainly for cost, My favorite numbers are for K, but I would still pick J not only for cost, bigger diamond, but it still will be a nice diamond and safer on the color scale and sounds like you are leaning towards it as well, plus you get a dream setting with that - what more could you ask for (sounds like a package deal when you choose J) - wait for images for reconfirm

 

[The sun is shining]

Oh Lordy me!

I was looking through Rocky talk for this post and wondering why I couldn''t find it!

I shall ask Admin to move it.

At any rate, This picture is the J Stone

 

[The sun is shining]

This is the K idealscope

 

[The sun is shining]

And this is the ASeT of the K

 

[The sun is shining]

Silly Me, lets try that again. The K ASET

 

[The sun is shining]

The I is pretty much out of the running for me too - I was placing it in there for the comparison - my local diamond dealer in Australia has said can sell it to me set for not much more than the price listed - I have also managed to find it in America... I''m not sure the price is justifiable for the one colour grade though. For the record, the measurements of the "I" are 7.43 - 7.49 x 4.61 mm. I am still waiting on the idealscope.

 

[The sun is shining]

My brain must''ve flown out the window -
the J is a different j - a 1.71 J VS2
Specs are as follows
7.66*7.69*4.78
Depth 62.2%
Table 53.0%
Crown 35.1
Pav 40.8

Small table?