oval diamond question

[cleary123]

I have two oval diamonds very similar..need help on which you all think is better


diamond A excellent cut f color vvs1 l/w ration 1.33 polish excellent sym good .9 carat

diamond B very good cut f color vvs2 lw ratio 1.45(which like super ideal) polish excellent sym excellent

when i looked at the depth/table for diamond B it was very close to being excellent cut

diamond A when i looked at depth/table it was like fell in the cat of like super ideal..

I know cut is like the most important so is this a no brainer or is the second one better bc of l/w ratio and sym being excellent

probably so similar it does not matter?

 

[pandabee]

We need actual pictures of the stones for ovals in order to help you out. This is a fancy shape that cannot be judged solely by numbers.

 

[cleary123]

I do not have pictures. I have seen them both. i can not tell the difference except Diamond B looks a little bigger bc of the l/w ratio