Opinions on this Blue Sri Lanka Sapphire?

[Marcus Aurelius]

I know natural light photos are critical. Any thoughts on the potential for this one? Pricing seems fair and it is Lotus Labs certified, which is good.

Unheated Eye Clean - Cornflower Blue Sapphire - 2.17ct - Oval - Certified

Blue Sapphire Gemstones 7.48 x 6.78 x 5.19mm 2.17 carats Auction #1271346 Gem Rock Auctions

www.gemrockauctions.com

 

[kenny]

For me it all comes down to how reputable that gem lab is.
I've never heard of Lotus, and the marketing verbage they print on their report makes me suspicious.

For me to buy a colored gem the report has to be from GIA or AGS.

 

[Marcus Aurelius]

AGL? GRS? Others?

 

[icy_jade]

Lotus lab is ok. But the stone doesn’t seem to be silky enough to be a true cornflower.

 

[Bron357]

Lotus Gemology was founded by Richard W Hughes who wrote THE book on Rubies and Sapphires. He is a coloured gem guru.
A Lotus report is extremely well regarded.
as for the sapphire, it is lovely.
my only quibble would be its face up size, its got quite the underneath and that’s carat weight you can’t see and enjoy.

 

[Marcus Aurelius]

Lotus lab is ok. But the stone doesn’t seem to be silky enough to be a true cornflower.

It seems to be a clear sapphire with a nice medium tone. Seems cornflower to me. Perhaps you are thinking more of a prototypical Burmese sapphire here?

 

[Marcus Aurelius]

Lotus Gemology was founded by Richard W Hughes who wrote THE book on Rubies and Sapphires. He is a coloured gem guru.
A Lotus report is extremely well regarded.
as for the sapphire, it is lovely.
my only quibble would be its face up size, its got quite the underneath and that’s carat weight you can’t see and enjoy.

Exactly re: Lotus. Lotus may actually be better than GIa for sapphires and rubies gemstones.

 

[icy_jade]

It seems to be a clear sapphire with a nice medium tone. Seems cornflower to me. Perhaps you are thinking more of a prototypical Burmese sapphire here?

No... to give it a velvety appearance, as described here:

https://www.git.or.th/eng/news_en/2016/CornflowerBlue4Web_RGB_EN_final_Feb2016.pdf

Lotus can be lax re trade desired names IMO.

 

[kenny]

AGL? GRS? Others?

Opps, yes AGL not AGS.
When it comes to D-Z diamonds it's AGS and GIA for me.

Being in USA I rarely encounter GRS, though I understand they are fully reputable too.

Frankly, the only Colored Stones I've ever bought have been FCDs graded by GIA, so I'm not a seasoned veteran colored gem collector.

 

[kenny]

Thanks all for the info on Lotus Lab.

 

[Marcus Aurelius]

Thoughts on this (presumably Ceylon) cornflower blue sapphire?



https://etsy.me/3rOjh9R

 

[Polyhex]

I think that's a lot of money for a lumpy stone. I have bought lumpy stones, but they were cheap and big.



What are you trying to make? Have you considered starting with some inexpensive sapphires to decide what your color preferences are?

 

[Marcus Aurelius]

Honestly, am trying to find a nice sapphire moderately over 1ct for collection purposes. But don’t necessarily want to pay over odds (have access to IGS gem price guide)

 

[Marcus Aurelius]

As for color, something along the lines of the stone you referenced will be ideal. FWIW I really appreciate the input from folks here.

 

[icy_jade]

Thoughts on this (presumably Ceylon) cornflower blue sapphire?



https://etsy.me/3rOjh9R

My first reaction is overpriced?

 

[Marcus Aurelius]

My first reaction is overpriced?

Agree, this price would need to have some give. But as was pointed out above, the cutting isn't that great. Have to keep looking. Very difficult to source the right sapphire.

 

[Polyhex]

Since it's for your collection, and you'll presumably be looking at the gem in a box or display case, I would suggest trying to get one that is beautifully cut since it won't have a setting or sidestones distract from any cut issues.

When I began looking at sapphires, looked for Sri Lankan IG vendor recommendations, and the two that I found from threads here were ceylonsapphiregems and leenagemslk. Leenagemslk specializes in inexpensive (usually $300 - $1k) and smaller (1-2 ct) stones and Ceylonsapphiregems carries larger, grander, and more expensive stones. Worth a look.

 

[Marcus Aurelius]

Thanks

Since it's for your collection, and you'll presumably be looking at the gem in a box or display case, I would suggest trying to get one that is beautifully cut since it won't have a setting or sidestones distract from any cut issues.

When I began looking at sapphires, looked for Sri Lankan IG vendor recommendations, and the two that I found from threads here were ceylonsapphiregems and leenagemslk. Leenagemslk specializes in inexpensive (usually $300 - $1k) and smaller (1-2 ct) stones and Ceylonsapphiregems carries larger, grander, and more expensive stones. Worth a look.

Thanks! I am realizing I am going to have to take a risk and go off the beaten path. I am finding that the vast majority of gems on offers are either suspect or have some pretty major flaws. In addition, domestic (US) dealers tend to be priced at the high end of retail overwhelmingly. Definitely open to sourcing from a source country wholesaler or similar.

 

[Marcus Aurelius]

Since it's for your collection, and you'll presumably be looking at the gem in a box or display case, I would suggest trying to get one that is beautifully cut since it won't have a setting or sidestones distract from any cut issues.

When I began looking at sapphires, looked for Sri Lankan IG vendor recommendations, and the two that I found from threads here were ceylonsapphiregems and leenagemslk. Leenagemslk specializes in inexpensive (usually $300 - $1k) and smaller (1-2 ct) stones and Ceylonsapphiregems carries larger, grander, and more expensive stones. Worth a look.

For Ceylonsapphiregems, what is his typical asking price per carat for a nice cornflower blue?

 

[Polyhex]

For Ceylonsapphiregems, what is his typical asking price per carat for a nice cornflower blue?

I don't know because I'm not looking for one, but he was very responsive for the stones I did ask about, so try asking?

 

[TreeScientist]

Regarding Lotus Lab, as Bron said, Richard, Wimon and Billie Hughes wrote THE books on corundum. I consider their lab one of the best out there for Sapphires, Rubies, and Spinels, particularly when it comes to their color grading. They're one of the few labs that won't call EVERY piece of pink corundum with a smidgen of orange and/or brown modifier "Padparadscha" (looking at you GRS and GIA).

I bought an unheated yellow sapphire from ClassicCeylon a few years ago. Seenu is a trustworthy man and his pictures and videos accurately represent what the stone looks like IRL (at least, this was my experience). I believe his family operates a few mines in Sri Lanka.

From the photos and video, the first 2.17ct you posted looks like a nice prototypical example of a Sri Lankan cornflower blue. I think it would be as beautiful cornflower blue that would likely hold its color in as variety of lighting situations, but it's unlikely that it would be "glowy" like the best of Burmese cornflowers. Then again, it's a fraction of the cost of a Burmese cornflower. Depends on what you're looking for and what you're willing to pay.

 

[Polyhex]

Regarding Lotus Lab, as Bron said, Richard, Wimon and Billie Hughes wrote THE books on corundum. I consider their lab one of the best out there for Sapphires, Rubies, and Spinels, particularly when it comes to their color grading. They're one of the few labs that won't call EVERY piece of pink corundum with a smidgen of orange and/or brown modifier "Padparadscha" (looking at you GRS and GIA).

I bought an unheated yellow sapphire from ClassicCeylon a few years ago. Seenu is a trustworthy man and his pictures and videos accurately represent what the stone looks like IRL (at least, this was my experience). I believe his family operates a few mines in Sri Lanka.

Great to know thank you for sharing your experience!

 

[Marcus Aurelius]

Thanks folks. Two more sapphires I would like to get opinions on.

An Important Vintage Art Deco Unheated 3.03ct Blue Sap Platinum Ring GIA | eBay

The beautifully made Estate ring contains a superb pair of clean and white tapered baguette diamonds of excellent quality totalling 0.30ct approx. The stone is not only eye clean but also virtually loupe clean, with only a couple of truly tiny inclusions being visible under magnification.

www.ebay.com

Superb Unheated 3.73ct Burma Blue Sapphire Platinum & Diamond Ring GIA | eBay

The beautifully made Estate ring contains a delightful array of clean and white diamonds of excellent quality totalling 0.17ct. Lustre and brilliancy are excellent - the stone is positively 'alive' and is exceptionally vibrant and lively.

www.ebay.com

 

[chrono]

1st stone: shallow pancake with huge window

2nd stone; cut is ok but I'm not sure if I'm seeing inclusions. Perhaps the ring wasn't cleaned well? What is the return policy like?

 

[MissyBeaucoup]

Have you checked gemfix.com? They have a variety of blue sapphires around the “cornflower“ range but they don’t normally put those labels on them. Some people prefer silky with a little rutile and some people prefer clear water. Or save up and get both, LOL!

 

[emeraldhummingbird]

1st stone: very pretty colour but there's spottiness and I can't tell what it is? It might be facet reflections

2nd stone: it looks suuuuuuper windowed to me, which would explain why it is half the price of the first. I wouldn't pick this.