New to site. Which would you choose

[elmotalks]

Which of these two tiffany round brilliant would you choose if you could only have one. I have tried to attch a pic of the two together, but not sure whetehr worked

.89ct G VVS1 1.20ct H VS1 gia from 2000 so some information not available for this diamond
depth 62.1% depth 60.6%
table 56% table 60%
culet none culet small
girdle thin to sl thick faceted girdle very thin to medium faceted
fluor none fluor med blue
prec of cut excellent
sym very good sym very good
pol very good pol very good
crown angle 34.4
pav depth per 43.2%

 

[stone-cold11]

Cut for the .89c is promising from the numbers. Not enough info for the 1.2c stone.

Clarity for both is overkill for me. If I can see it personally, I would get a idealscope and check it out. It is a cheap tool that you can buy for $25 + shipping here.

http://www.ideal-scope.com/cart_order.asp

 

[Lorelei]

Date: 9/23/2009 10:52:22 AM
Author:elmotalks
Which of these two tiffany round brilliant would you choose if you could only have one. I have tried to attch a pic of the two together, but not sure whetehr worked

.89ct G VVS1 1.20ct H VS1 gia from 2000 so some information not available for this diamond
depth 62.1% depth 60.6%
table 56% table 60%
culet none culet small
girdle thin to sl thick faceted girdle very thin to medium faceted
fluor none fluor med blue
prec of cut excellent
sym very good sym very good
pol very good pol very good
crown angle 34.4
pav depth per 43.2%

Both have possibilities, the first one appears to have quite long lower girdle facets from what I can see in the image which appeals to me, I would like the crown and pavilion angles for the second diamond if you can get them as that would give a better idea of the cut - but as it is pre cut grade GIA you would need to ask Tiffany if they could get this info if they have access to a Sarin machine, but they might not be able to do this.

The clarity is fine if thats what you value, some prefer VS or above as these clarity grades appeal to them, yes you could go lower without visual sacrifice if the cut is good but if you want VS plus then stick with that.

Are both these diamonds for sale in a Tiffany store?