Need help in choosing a perfect diamond!

[mrsyu]

Hi All,

I really need your opinions to decide between these 2 stones:

Diamond A:

Carat: 0.93
HCA score: 1.00
Grade: Ex Ex Ex
Colour: D
Clarity: IF
Measurements: 6.30 x6.32x3.84

Diamond B:
Carat:1.01
HCA score:1.1
Grade: Ex Ex Ex
Colour: E
Clarity: VVS 2
Measurements: 6.47x 6.51x3.94

I'm really not sure if I should go with diamond A or B, they are both around the same price. My finger size is 4.5. I want something that looks WOW on my finger and has a great sparkle. Diamond B is bigger by size, but looking at the measurements, it won't be as round as diamond A. Besides, the colour and the clarity are not perfect as Diamond A.
I heard you can't really see the difference between colour D and E. Is this correct?

Any opinions on which diamond I should go with?

Thanks for all your advice in advance

 

[Bailey_Lou]

Hi mrsyu,
Do you have any idealscope images or aset for these diamonds? That would help when making a decision

 

[Gypsy]

Do you want honesty?

If you want "perfection" for some reason. Then go for the D FL.

There's no point in getting the E VVS. It's not perfect. So it's a ridiculously overpriced stone that will be indistinguishable from an eyeclean F VS2.

If you are going for BALANCE, then the E VVS is a waste. You are MUCH better off going for an eyeclean F VS2. And going up in size. OR saving money.

So. Basically if you want perfection get the D FL. And frankly if I was getting a D FL I would want one that is AGS0 and hearts and arrows to boot. Cause if you overspending by that much, you SHOULD go for the most perfect stone... which means precision cutting and perfect performance.

If you want balance and size or savings... keep looking.



Also, you need an idealscope image of both.

 

[Dancing Fire]

Diamond B is good enough for me!, in fact too good... I'll take a bigger well cut F VS1 H&A stone..

I know Chinese people prefer high color/clarity stones...